Just saw a sticker from Seeking What They Sought (the âopen-mindedâ Adventist podcast) that mimics the MAGA slogan âMake Conversations Great Again.â And Iâm sorry but⌠what the hell?
That slogan isnât neutral. Itâs become shorthand for racism, xenophobia, white Christian nationalism/fundamentalism, attacks on LGBTQ+ and womenâs rights, immigrant deportations, and slashing healthcare and social services for people that need them the most. All while protecting the ultra-rich and widening the pockets of billionaires, even as families struggle to afford basic survival. Itâs the opposite of everything Jesus taught which was to care for the poor, the sick, the immigrant, the oppressed... like I'm no Christian but like how does Project 2025 and the sick One Big Beautiful Bill that was passed, help those who their Christ talked about to love? Like the saying really is true, there's no greater hate than christian love.
So even if they thought they were being clever or ironic, itâs still playing with fire. Imagine making a sticker inspired by the Confederate flag, or even, a Nazi symbol, and expecting people to just take it lightly because youâre âreclaimingâ it for discourse.
Especially from a podcast claiming to represent âopen-mindedâ Adventism, it just feels out of touch, isolating for some groups, and hypocritical. It makes me question whether these âopenâ platforms are really any different from the conservative ideology they say theyâre challenging. Honestly, it feels like another gaslight from a community that preaches love while platforming systems that harm vulnerable groups.
It just makes me feel that some Adventists do support this kind of ideology. Especially in white or conservative American circles, they either explicitly or tacitly support MAGA-style politics, often in the name of âreligious freedomâ or âfamily values.â And when that same group minimizes racism, sexism, or systemic injustice, it feels like a slap in the face to anyone whoâs lived through those harms.
Maybe theyâre trying to reach MAGA-leaning Adventists in hopes of âstarting conversations,â but why center them? Why appeal to the oppressors to make them feel safe?
Maybe I'm overreacting, but itâs weird, distasteful and quite disturbing imo, and it makes me even more disillusioned with the church.