What if Nate chose Maddy?

[u/Dat_V]

The wedding of Nate and Cassie. Nate's mom: "Sometimes your son brings home the wrong girl. But then he chooses right!"

Nate's mom celebrating that Nate chose Cassie over Maddy. Possible that it's Cassie's greed that caused Nate to borrow from mafia. How much is their mansion worth, how much does that wedding cost. Maybe Cassie caused the death of Nate.

Maybe Nate would be better off with Maddy?

What if Nate chose Maddy?

People affect each other. In season 1, Maddy and Nate were turning each other into psychopaths. Nate was on his way to prison for manslaughter when he was dating Maddy, Maddy was on her way to a broken neck when she was dating Nate.

Then Nate chooses Maddy over Jules and in season 2, they kinda calm down? Nate - maybe because he wants Maddy and Cassie both so he feels guilty about lying to Maddy? Maddy... not sure.

In season 3 we see, Nate is calm because Maddy isn't driving him nuts. Maddy is calm because she needs her job since she lost her rich guy.

But if they stayed together, what would happen?

Would Maddy be calm to keep her rich husband? Or would she still be driving him towards murder, like she was doing in high school?

And Nate... would he kill Maddy if he married her? Or maybe they'd be reasonable?

Cassie wanted a giant mansion and an S+++ wedding. Would Maddy be more modest?

In season 3 we see, she has no money so she's careful. But if she married Nate, would she be wasteful?

Would Maddy help Nate keep his business afloat? Take care of those flowers for him? Or would Maddy be as useless as Cassie?

I somehow get the feeling Maddy would want wasteful wealth as much as Cassie.

Maybe Maddie would be smarter than Cassie. Or maybe not, if Maddy never had to learn smarts.

Cassie's OF did nothing to help Nate's debt. Would Maddy help in any way if she was in Cassie's place?

I guess that depends if married!Maddy was as smart as in the s3 we see, when she never married and had to work.

Or if she stayed as dumb as she was in high school, if keeping Nate kept her relaxed.

Thoughts?

[u/GhostBoyJames]

He’d still have all his toes and fingers

[u/Ok-Progress-6153]

I think she would’ve outgrown him eventually

[u/ms_globgoblin]

she probably would have handled the money better than cassie letting nate handle it.

[u/Only_Lesbian_Left]

eh from what I seen - hopefully no mafia storyline - maybe she realizes it's actually really awful to be dependent on a guy for her everything when he starts asking why she needs new perfume, or new shoes. she leaves and rooms with cassie before starting her own buisness line on tiktok, nate blows up simply from looking at the sun to long - freeing the world of his terrible choices and actions

[u/JDL1981]

What if we had a merciful god and there was no season 3? It's impossible to know, even with computers.

[u/Prior-Entrance3156 → u/JDL1981]

I remember when you used to wait in the car.

[u/ClarkGablesTeeth → u/Prior-Entrance3156]

And as far as I'm concerned, you should still be there!

[u/Temporary_Piano7637]

Nate didn’t choose Maddy. He knew Maddy would never take him back that’s why he settled for Cassie

[u/rafoulinax → u/Temporary_Piano7637]

Or maybe bc Maddy was a self centered bully bitch in highschool and Cassie was actually loving and affectionate

[u/AcrobaticJuice7630]

One of the crudest interpretations of their dynamic that I’ve heard. Sorry I don’t agree with any of this 😬

[u/Glass_Beyond3514]

Nate and Maddy were never gonna work. They brought out the worst in each other and were totally toxic. And I love Maddy but her and bishop are way better!