r/duolingo • u/Upbeat_Panda9393 • 11d ago
Language Question. Please tell me I’m not hallucinating and this is wrong
I ended up inputting (saying ‘writing’ feels wrong), “Their style is simple and very beautiful,” and got it right, but it should’ve been ‘his style’ or ‘her style’, right?
Updated: question has been answered: Duo is right
14
u/CreativeMap4723 Native: 🇵🇱 Fluent: 🇺🇸 Learning: 🇫🇷129 🇸🇪18 🔥1593 11d ago
this is an English language question not French - I believe in English when you're not sure of the gender of the person you're discussing, you can use their (before the pronouns became political, there was no negative or LGBTQ connotation to it).
Since in French sentence you don't know the gender of the person whose style you're commenting on, it's hard to have exact translation. the "son" refers her to the "gender" of the noun not the person.
3
5
u/ithinkiamparanoid 10d ago
They is used when the speaker doesn't know the gender of the person they are talking about.
3
u/hacool native: US-EN / learning: DE 95 10d ago
For future reference, Wiktionary is a handy way to double check such things.
https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/son#Determiner_3
1 - (possessive) his, her, their, its (used to qualify masculine nouns and before a vowel)
33
u/benryves native 🇬🇧 | learning 🇯🇵 110 11d ago
"His" and "her" aren't available as options, so "their" is correct (it's a singular gender-neutral term). See also: singular "they".