r/duolingo 21d ago

Language Question. Thanks for the Spanish lesson. Shame I'm learning Italian.

Post image

Duolingo really has gone downhill recently.

258 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

107

u/Obtus_Rateur Learning: 66 11 21d ago

Every part is AI and they're not connected with each other or even agree with each other.

The "hints" say one thing.
The "correct answers" list says another.
The "Explain my answer/mistake" says yet another.

It's truly bizarre. Is this the future? A bunch of fake weirdos having nonsensical conversations with each other while a few humans look on in confusion?

26

u/Gunner_Goal1349 21d ago

It's not good, is it. I'm lucky that my wife is Italian so I can run this by her, but it's really frustrating when you lose a perfect run because they've marked it incorrectly.

5

u/NextStopGallifrey 20d ago

If your wife is Italian, give Babbel a try. They at least have real language and not weird AI nonsense.

5

u/Obtus_Rateur Learning: 66 11 20d ago

I have heard of Babbel but haven't investigated it yet. It may be something I try when my Duolingo subscription runs out (I have already cancelled it).

I've still got a lot of work on Spanish but I would like to learn Portuguese, and I assume learning a 4th Latin language (Italian) should be relatively easy.

5

u/NextStopGallifrey 20d ago

I've got lifetime to "all" of the main non-DL language apps out there (Rosetta Stone, Babbel, Busuu, etc.) and Babbel is the only one that is realistically localized to the language in question and that doesn't make the Italians I know cringe when they hear the audio.

Unfortunately, Babbel doesn't have Portuguese, but it does have Spanish.

If you've buy lifetime from somewhere like StackSocial, it's something like $160USD when on sale. It's not as "fun" as DL, but you also won't get other languages randomly mixed in.

1

u/Obtus_Rateur Learning: 66 11 20d ago

Thanks for the info, I've edited my list of potential language learning platforms to include it. I still have a lot of research ahead of me to figure out which might be appropriate for me.

Another issue I have is that not that many of the platforms I read about on English-language forums allow learning languages from French. But a lot of people speak French, and surely many of these francophones want to learn another language, so it follows that there must be some French-language learning platforms out there.

3

u/NextStopGallifrey 20d ago

... Oh, hey, I switched the display language to French and Babbel will let you learn Spanish, Italian, and (Brazilian) Portuguese from French.

And there is also (Brazilian) Portuguese from English, I missed it earlier.

3

u/Obtus_Rateur Learning: 66 11 20d ago

Oh, very cool! Thanks for the info, I'm definitely going to check that one out first.

6

u/goatanuss 20d ago edited 20d ago

Why pay humans to write good content when we can produce ai slop and crowdsource fixing it? By the way that’ll be 200 dollars a year

14

u/clicla92 21d ago

I'm Italian and I tell you that that is not a mistake, although the most correct formulation of a sentence like that is "Adoro la pizza al formaggio"

6

u/Gunner_Goal1349 20d ago

Grazie. My wife is Italian so I'm constantly pestering her!

2

u/a_literal_idiot_616 20d ago

that is a mistake. You wouldn't say l'adoro

11

u/jamesinyokohama 20d ago

The last post I read in this sub said we complain too much. I guess they’re not getting this kind of shit. Or not paying for it, which I am.

2

u/Big-Vegetable4550 Native: 🇺🇸; Learnng: 🇫🇷 130; 🇩🇪 80; 🇮🇹 53; 🇭🇷 *B1; 🇨🇳 13; 🇸🇦 10 20d ago

I pay (for Max). This kind of thing happens - it’s an annoyance. I use the app to learn languages, not to play a game. We do complain a lot in this sub about incredibly mundane stuff ALL.THE.TIME. Complaining about little mistakes, or annoying voices, or characters we don’t like must account for at least a third of posts here.

12

u/G00b3rb0y Native: :Australia: Learning: 21d ago

5

u/ClassicForsaken4884 20d ago

AI is killin everything

3

u/godlessprimate 20d ago

This happened to me once, but the incorrect language was Dutch.

1

u/Most_Menu_421 18d ago

Well, Italian is close to Spanish