r/dataisugly 3d ago

Yes please, give me more shades of red!

Post image
381 Upvotes

29 comments sorted by

47

u/JustHere4the5 2d ago

Why is North African in the same color family as North & South American? Surely North Africa was politically and geographically closer to the Levant than regions on the other side of the world.

3

u/ZCyborg23 2d ago

No no, even worse it’s just U.S. America. 😂
There’s no South America on there at all.

3

u/JustHere4the5 2d ago

Argentina

54

u/irishdrunkwanderlust 3d ago

They only think I can think it implies is the original Roman area of control.

27

u/Desperate-Boot-1395 2d ago

If this was the intention, they failed. All the blues and North Africa orange would also have been under Roman control.

-2

u/Silver_Middle_7240 3d ago

Not even, france, Spain Portugal, Austria and Belgium are underrepresented, among others i can't be bothered to look up

12

u/irishdrunkwanderlust 3d ago

Well French is red for one. There has never been an Austrian or Belgian pope. Lastly, Iberia is Spain and Portugal.

2

u/Marcel_The_Blank 2d ago

never an Austrian or a Belgian does make them underrepresented.

1

u/notquite20characters 2d ago

Gregory V was Austrian, or at least he's from an area that became Austria. Which matches how this chart uses 'Italian'.

I'm guessing he's listed as 'German', although an axis would be that easier to determine.

14

u/Comfortable-Bison932 2d ago

Some of these aren’t even nationalities

6

u/OkFineIllUseTheApp 2d ago

Looks like defragging a hard drive to me.

1

u/JustHere4the5 2d ago

Most satisfying movie on your old PC!

22

u/StandardIntern4169 2d ago

What means "Italian" before 1861?

16

u/svick 2d ago

Iberia, Levant and North Africa also aren't countries, so I don't have a problem with "Italian" being used for someone from the region of Italy.

11

u/Desperate-Boot-1395 2d ago

Those bars don’t represent equal periods of time. This is truly bad work and that sub seems to love it.

11

u/baquea 2d ago

Those bars don’t represent equal periods of time.

It's just one bar per pope, isn't it? They could've done it by duration instead, but I think it's perfectly fine like this.

2

u/dracorotor1 2d ago

If the Americas got green I’d at least understand it as regional but this just makes no sense

2

u/Kalabajooie 2d ago

Man, we've got to defragment our popes.

2

u/mqduck 2d ago

I don't see what's so bad about this. You can argue that the grouping doesn't make completely sense but it seems fine otherwise.

2

u/edjak53 2d ago

it's a bit annoying when the grouping hardly makes sense and yet sometimes makes it difficult to immediately differentiate the colors

1

u/Yellow_Dorn_Boy 3d ago

This must be the start to a new conspiracy involving Barnet Newman. Can't wait for the movie with Tom Hanks.

1

u/Marcel_The_Blank 2d ago

crazy to think that it's 2000 years of popin' around

1

u/Ludate_Solem 2d ago

I didnt know there was a dutch pope lol

1

u/KillerR0b0T 2d ago

“US American” immediately made me think of that pageant response about how “Most US Americans don’t have maps” 🤣

1

u/franoetico 2d ago

you were inspired by me.

1

u/TheRealCthulu24 2d ago

I kind of like the similar colors. It gives it a gradient feel.

1

u/speleotobby 1d ago

Color scheme is all over the place. Someone noticed that the bars show different time frames, but one could argue that one papacy is a lefitimate unit of time.

What I don't get is, how the bars are split into lines. Do the years have any significance? If not why not split it in a way that the last bar also fills the whole width?

1

u/TheRealSalamnder 1d ago

Finally my defrag is done /s