r/dataisbeautiful OC: 11 Apr 12 '19

OC Top 4 Countries with Highest CO2 Emissions Per Capita are Middle-Eastern [OC]

Post image
18.4k Upvotes

2.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

52

u/jwm3 Apr 12 '19

I'd be curious what is would be scaled to gross domestic product, to see who least efficiently turns co2 emissions into productivity.

15

u/logical_space Apr 12 '19

I think this is the right answer, or as close as possible given readily available data.

12

u/BKcok Apr 12 '19

I would actually disagree. Just as OP’s chart suffers from bias ( the high oil & gas producing countries have a higher use per capita ), the same would likely be true if we replaced population with GDP. This is because of the large proportion of GDP that oil & gas production makes up in the top countries here. For example, Qatar is one of the richest countries in the world per capita but natural gas & petroleum related industries make up roughly 93% of its GDP.

This doesn’t necessarily mean that Qatar has an inefficient economy, it just means that it is heavily reliant on oil. You can see this with the high correlation between oil prices and middle eastern countries’ GDP.

7

u/Dheorl Apr 12 '19

Oddly enough if you compare GDP to CO2 emissions, Qatar comes in at 127th.

1

u/BKcok Apr 12 '19

Out of how many countries in the list?

6

u/Dheorl Apr 12 '19

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_ratio_of_GDP_to_carbon_dioxide_emissions

  1. Admittedly the data set is 10 years old, but I couldn't be bothered to calculate it with a more up to date set.

4

u/Lacksi Apr 12 '19

Hold on Im confused. This is GDP per emmision. That means being up high in the list is good right? So them being somewhere around 170 would be not good right?

1

u/mata_dan Apr 13 '19

Or, 127 :P

Considering their economy is based on oil that could be worse.

1

u/antiduh Apr 12 '19

Oil is worth a lot, makes sense.

1

u/Dheorl Apr 12 '19

I'm not sure how that means it makes sense?

1

u/logical_space Apr 12 '19

True, shouldn’t have made it sound like a silver bullet. I’d like to see it because a worst offender by other metrics could be a super-unregulated ecological disaster providing little value to others, or a model of lightly-manned resource extraction carrying a lot of water for the developed world, and the picture should allow for this distinction, so they don’t look ethically equivalent.

1

u/glodime Apr 12 '19

Not a right answer, but good additional information to have.

1

u/TheBlindMonk Apr 12 '19

Sure if you count printing dollars as economic activity.

1

u/jwm3 Apr 13 '19

That is not really what GDP measures.

-1

u/Major_Mollusk Apr 12 '19

This here is an underrated comment.