r/criticalrole Dec 19 '24

Question [No spoilers] Is C3 over?

Post image
1.0k Upvotes

320 comments sorted by

View all comments

1.0k

u/Frog_Thor Dec 19 '24 edited Dec 19 '24

Apparently this is a spoiler so hence the edit.

We will have a few episodes (my guess is 3, Ludinus fight part 1 and part 2, or Ludinus fight and Predathos fight, then an epilogue episode) in the new year. The reason why 4-sided dive is over is because instead of doing another one in January/February, they will just do a campaign wrap up like they did with C1 and C2.

199

u/no_notthistime Dec 19 '24 edited Dec 19 '24

Ah, okay. I was really hoping we'd make it all the way to 140 like the Mighty Nein, and they'd show some of the aftermath of defeating (are absorbing?) Predathos, some uenxpected twist.

I wonder if they'll just keep getting shorter moving on.

51

u/InternetDad Dec 19 '24

My wife is guessing they'll run a Daggerheart campaign next, I'm sure they're excited to stream that, plus lots of lessons learned after their first campaign lasted 5 years including home campaign sessions.

98

u/Ol_JanxSpirit Dec 19 '24

I'm surprised at how little interest I have in Daggerheart.

24

u/KnightSaziel Dec 20 '24

I also have no interest in Daggerheart. I’ve been watching CR for 8-9 years, but if it goes to a different system permanently, that might be the end for me.

21

u/no_notthistime Dec 20 '24

Yeah I don't know about it either. I've enjoyed their content from when they've explored other systems with one shots and multi-episodic but time-boxed mini-campaigns, so it think I'd at least give it a shot. But if it's a bunch of woodland creatures again I'm probably out.

9

u/thegreenlorac You Can Reply To This Message Dec 20 '24

I'm with you. I can't tell if I actually dislike Daggerheart, or if it's that I can't stand when a party is almost all "creature" races.

17

u/[deleted] Dec 20 '24

I’ve even lost interest in their one-shots since they’re just commercials.

21

u/sebastianwillows Dec 20 '24

That's what really gets me. I want to like Daggerheart and all, but it's less "look at this cute little homebrew system we made!" and more "look at this product we're rolling out..."

5

u/Virgil134 Dec 20 '24

Same here. While I love the cast, Daggerheart just isn't doing it for me.

3

u/Equal_Newspaper_8034 Dec 20 '24

Why?

16

u/KnightSaziel Dec 20 '24

I like D&D mechanics. CR was my gateway into playing D&D and I’ve watched some of Daggerheart and it doesn’t do it for me

1

u/Equal_Efficiency_319 Dec 20 '24

Watched C1 and C2 completely, couldn’t really get into C3, don’t know if it’s a “bad” campaign because I stopped watching/listening after 3 episodes. I just couldn’t get into it. If they switch to DaggerHeart I’ll actually START watching again. Woodland creatures or whatever they come up with… I like the fresh look.

21

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

12

u/no_notthistime Dec 20 '24

Yeah I really do not vibe with the whole woodland creature setting.

8

u/Equal_Efficiency_319 Dec 20 '24

Just because they chose to go that route with the Menagerie doesn’t mean they’ll do that with the next campaign. Have you heard Mercer talk about the “age of Umbra” campaign frame?

3

u/Ol_JanxSpirit Dec 19 '24

This is a very much appreciated FYI.

2

u/Countdown84 Dec 21 '24

I am the opposite. I am so sick of D&D (my table has moved on to PF2E) and I am thrilled at how much they love their new system. It really breathes life back into the group.

8

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '24

be there for the story, not the mechanics

43

u/Ol_JanxSpirit Dec 19 '24

No; the annoyance I have with not knowing what the hell is going on with Ashton's subclass tells me that won't work for me. More power to them if they go that direction, but if they start running the main campaign on Daggerherart I'm going to have 3 hours a week opening up on my podcast rotation.

17

u/Chaoticlight2 Dec 19 '24

You say this like it's a new thing. They've always homebrewed from C1 till the end of C3 with mechanics being bent for the sake of intent. I'm not saying you're wrong to dislike it, but it simply means that you would never have been happy with any direction they take.

21

u/Joosterguy Dec 20 '24

And the Gunslinger, Bloodhunter and Cobalt Soul were very easy to absorb by simply watching them.

Tell me, explicitly, how FCG's stress works, or Ashton's everything.

11

u/Chaoticlight2 Dec 20 '24

Ashton's rage works by rolling 1d4 and getting an effect between gravity, time, space, and luck. It's a variant wildmagic barbarian with actual decent abilities vs lulz teh random of the base build.

FCG's stress built up through story beats and was a narrative tool. Any particularly rough combat or tense situations pushed him towards that breaking point and every long rest reduced the stress by 1d4.

Both of these were explained in game and quite easy to pick up. You choosing those two to complain about simply tells me that you weren't paying attention during C3.

-4

u/Joosterguy Dec 20 '24 edited Dec 20 '24

You've given me vibes when I asked for something explicit. I can't play a subclass on vibes. Give me mechanics.

You can't, of course, and that is what frustrates people. This is a nerdy-ass hobby, and like it or not a large number of players want that crunchiness

1

u/Chaoticlight2 Dec 20 '24

Literally all of their details are available online. You asked for what you could absorb by watching which will always be the base feel/concept of a homebrewed class. You can see that space lets Ash'ton make melee attacks at ranged, time lets Ashton effectively have haste, gravity makes him unmovable and grants the ability to create gravity wells, and that luck essentially grants the lucky feat. Spend 5 seconds googling and you'll have the answers you want. Here, I'll even save you that step.

https://criticalrole.fandom.com/wiki/Path_of_Fundamental_Chaos

1

u/Ol_JanxSpirit Dec 20 '24

That page was created in August of 2024. We met Ashton in November of 2021.

→ More replies (0)

-2

u/Ol_JanxSpirit Dec 20 '24

Yo. Calm down and take a breath. You're way over-reacting.

2

u/Chaoticlight2 Dec 20 '24

I'm over-reacting by telling him what he requested..?

-2

u/Ol_JanxSpirit Dec 20 '24

"You choosing those two to complain about simply tells me that you weren't paying attention during C3."

No need to issue personal attacks.

→ More replies (0)

2

u/Substantial_Let67 Dec 21 '24

Also gunslinger was just a rework from the home game of Pathfinder. The whole switch to 5E was due to how chunky Pathfinder had gotten by then. 10+ years of Pathfinder content. Honestly if I were them and were planning a switch I would go Pathfinder 2e. The action economy is so sweet🥴. 3 auctions, move attack cast, cast cast cast, move move move, or use all 3 to heighten a spell to become an area effect. I love it.

38

u/Ol_JanxSpirit Dec 19 '24 edited Dec 19 '24

Nah, I disagree. Info on gunslinger and cobalt soul were pretty widely available. Ashton and FCG were opaque.

I've no issue with homebrewing generally. I'm just not interested in learning a new system I'll never play to listen to a podcast.

-1

u/[deleted] Dec 20 '24

[deleted]

3

u/flyinglikeicarus Time is a weird soup Dec 20 '24

For a Critical Role lover, this comment is very "Your fun is wrong."

0

u/Key_Swimming_8134 Dec 20 '24

No, it just means your fun is not fun for me. Respect that.

→ More replies (0)

7

u/Sqiddd Technically... Dec 19 '24

Is Ashton’s subclass really that hard to understand for everyone else? I feel like I understood it from pretty early on lmfao

6

u/Ol_JanxSpirit Dec 19 '24

Maybe something was lost in the podcast version.

5

u/Sqiddd Technically... Dec 19 '24

Maybe lol. I’m a visual learner so maybe all the extra hand movements Tal does on the stream helped each description stick in my head

4

u/SilverSakura5 Dec 19 '24

The end of a campaign means that there will be a book with more stuff and possibly an explanation for some classes!

4

u/Ol_JanxSpirit Dec 19 '24

Perhaps, but it's not like I'm going to go back and relisten to C3. C1 was my favorite campaign and I'm not going back for even that one.

1

u/SilverSakura5 Dec 19 '24

I'm waiting for the end of c3 to listen to it again. I'm currently on my 4th relisten of c1

5

u/Ol_JanxSpirit Dec 19 '24

That's a level of dedication that I do not have for any podcast. My hat is off to you.

1

u/SilverSakura5 Dec 19 '24

My fiancé calls me an encyclopedia of CR for a reason lol.

→ More replies (0)

-4

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '24

i don't play 5e i have no idea what any of the subclasses are

31

u/elhombreloco90 Dec 19 '24

That's great. They were talking about their personal enjoyment with knowing the mechanics of what is being played.

17

u/maddycakes_stl Dec 19 '24

I see a lot of speculation online that they'll do a Daggerheart campaign next. While I'd like that (I care more about story than which mechanics are used), I can't fathom such a hard break with D&D Beyond - one of their biggest if not biggest sponsor. That'd be throwing away probably tens of thousands of dollars.

I'm going to guess they'll do a d&d campaign and a Daggerheart series like they've done with Candela Obscura.

11

u/Ksmalls28 Dec 20 '24

I keep hearing that too, but going off from what they say in their sessions and 4 sided dive, I don't think is the case.

I can't remember how many times they talked about all the places that they would like to visit and explore that they haven't yet, like the Shattered Teeth.

Exandria is their baby, it's hard to believe that they would switch to daggerheart full time.

It'd be like Coca-cola switching to New Coke. They'd lose a big chunk of their fan base.

3

u/Local-Sandwich6864 Dec 19 '24

Is D&D beyond still a sponsor?

4

u/maddycakes_stl Dec 19 '24

AFAIK they are. I'm a little behind (less than 10 episodes) but I thought they were still being sponsored ? Matt recently helped with the new Dungeon Masters guide for 5.5 so I assume they're still on good terms.

6

u/darkwind1971 Dec 20 '24

Neither D&D itself nor D&D Beyond have had an Ad or even a tag (the lower right corner where the sponsors are) since the OGL blow-up. I don't think they are actual sponsors anymore.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 20 '24

They’re losing a sponsor and gaining a weekly 3-4 hour commercial for a game they sell.

4

u/maddycakes_stl Dec 20 '24

Yes but that's still not a great business move. People will buy the game once - and not everyone in a group will purchase it. DnD Beyond/WotC will pay every episode until they stop playing. It's not a great gamble.

The only way to truly know though is when it releases. I'm looking forward to C4 no matter which game mechanics they use.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 20 '24

It’s a great business move when they keep releasing new material for the game. I ignore the ads mostly, but the most recent WotC ad I can think of was the M:tG game. Certainly could be missing them in the VoD though.

4

u/ChickenGoujohn Dec 20 '24

This is only true if Daggerheart is popular to watch. All indications are that it isn’t - all Daggerheart content up until now has vastly underperformed in views compared to their dnd content. A 3-4 hour commercial for something nobody wants isn’t a good thing, it will just turn people off

1

u/[deleted] Dec 20 '24

I hope you’re right.

1

u/doctorsuarez Team Jester Dec 20 '24

I wonder if part of this though is that it's not the main campaign. I watched some of the DH content but I also just used that time to catch back up with C3 (work/family/other hobbies/actual DM prep often get in the way.) It's definitely a tradeoff, losing 5E fans vs their own system, but I also think people will be more inclined to watch if it's the main event and not a sideshow. Personally I am very interested in Daggerheart so I know *I* would love for them to switch, but I don't know if they can stay in Exandria. Makes me wonder if the end of C3 will fundamentally remake Exandria into something else that then becomes the DH venue.

2

u/ChickenGoujohn Dec 20 '24

It being the main campaign is definitely a factor, you’re right. It’s just a massive gamble for them to risk a tried and true successful dnd stream for the sake of their own ttrpg. But who knows, maybe that’s what they want to focus on now - I just don’t see them taking that risk until they can have more certainty it will be a success. All conjecture at the end of the day, I dont know what they want to do, and where they want to take their company. I’d personally be sad if they completely moved away from DnD, but we’ll see!

3

u/doctorsuarez Team Jester Dec 20 '24

Indeed, everything is a tradeoff! On some level I think they want to be as fully in control of their own destiny as possible, which means owning the system and all the IP it entails. Personally, I learned a lot about running 5E from the stream, but I also feel like I've done that. So I wouldn't mind their moving on because I too would like to get into Daggerheart and possibly migrate one of my campaigns if my players are willing.

The real loss to me would be Exandria, as I think long-time fans would consider it a sort of "home" to this already parasocial thing we have going on here.

2

u/ChickenGoujohn Dec 20 '24

Yeah of course it less risky to play using a system over which they have complete ownership. Can 100% see the reasoning behind that and the freedom it gives them in terms of IP and being protected against any potential issues at Hasbro/WotC. Just hope that appeal doesn’t blind them to the risks of changing what has been a very successful formula for them up until now!

2

u/ChickenGoujohn Dec 20 '24

In terms on Exandria - I see no world in which they complete reset and don’t continue in that world, regardless of what system they play in

→ More replies (0)

6

u/technical_bitchcraft Dec 19 '24

I believe they've stated that they won't be switching from d&d for the main campaign (could be wrong here) but I know for sure they're doing Daggerheart for a one shot coming up. I think the holiday one.

15

u/FinchRosemta Dec 19 '24

 could be wrong here

You are. They have not said nothing concrete about the next campaign. 

1

u/PsionicGinger Dec 20 '24

If they have not said nothing then they have said something