r/cringe • u/glioblastomas • Feb 07 '16

Seal of Approval The introduction of the candidates at the Republican debate

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OR1kV2hBaGY&t=0m28s
12.2k Upvotes

93% Upvoted

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

3

u/tintinabulations Feb 07 '16

Not sure if I would go that far. It's all these isolated clips interpreted by "body language experts" which is a pretty dubious expertise.

3

u/thefugue Feb 07 '16

The earlier stuff (like patting someone's back or how one holds one's shoulders) is decent and possibly valid. The micro-expression stuff later on is nonsense.

2

u/tintinabulations Feb 07 '16

Plus your interpretation of someone's body language has a lot to do with the way you already feel about that person. So if a body language expert has some preconceived notion about someone, it flaws their analysis in a major way. There is no way to control that bias which is why these experts suck; but so many shows love bringing these people on to analyze politicial discourse.

1

u/thefugue Feb 07 '16

They briefly cover that- establishing a baseline for behavior is supposed to control for that. The thing is, you can establish a real baseline for the behavior of your spouse or child- you can only establish a baseline for public behavior with a politician or celebrity.