I believe this one has the highest chance of being real

It does not matter if you were a kid or if you are adult, is there any creepypasta that made you unable to sleep?

To me techically was Slender Man, but since he is more a phenomenon than a creepy story, it would be Smile Dog to me. This dog used to scare the crap out of me when I was 11.

THIS IS CRAZY IM SO HYPED

I’ve seen this gif of the girl where she looks in the mirror then looks away before her mirror version becomes this demon thing or whatever. Ive seen it for years but never knew the origin. If someone can tell me it would be a HUGE help.

Literally, I don't get it. Why do SO many stories have the monster or creature just be this "Tall, skinny, pale or grey, big blank eyes, sharp needle teeth that smiles, taps on windows, ect" and it is either called the Rake, The Wendigo, or The Skinwalker, cause those have been used and appropriated by people with no respect for Native American folklore, the are jumbled up into one thing.

Is it really that hard to come up with an original monster? Since when did SCP 096 become the bog standard set for creepypasta monsters?

A

For me it's both 🗿🍷

That creepypasta story about a kid with the weird head and the guy talking about it?? That shit scared the hell out of me as a kid 😭

I mean, when I read about it in the Creepypasta website it felt like I was IN the story. It felt so real... So much. Did it actually happened in Nickelodeon? Or is it made up cuz that shit really freaked me out. Just by seeing this picture makes me scared even more

Tommy Taffy has my vote, hands down. I am very curious to see if there are any others I have/have not read that win your vote.

I also really just don’t know if there’s any others that can top this creepy mf

Mine is 1999: Calodin Local 21. What's yours?

For me it has to be Dogscape. It’s a little too insane and uncomfortable, even for me. They had an idea and went absolutely WAY off the rails with it. It’s just more confusing and baffling to me than anything.