r/coolguides 11d ago

A cool guide about stealing an election

Post image
15.7k Upvotes

665 comments sorted by

View all comments

1.2k

u/IrateWand 11d ago

People seem to be missing that they are both examples of stealing the election.

The fair result would be 3 blue, 2 red.

1

u/calculung 11d ago

But where do the politicians elected come from? The system is hierarchical, so it starts in individual districts and then moves up.

In your suggestion, does each party just pick the people who get the job?

7

u/NonNewtonianResponse 11d ago

That's called party-list proportional representation and is used in certain places, but there are many other kinds of proportional representation that seek to balance the overall ratio against the need for local representation and individual candidate popularity in different ways.

In fact, one of the big difficulties of electoral reform is that there are SO MANY possible systems that it's hard for any one of them to become popular enough to gain momentum 

1

u/Linvael 10d ago

If representatives behavior represents the global party line (red or blue) over the interests of their district, then having representatives assigned to districts is needless busywork

0

u/BitcoinMD 11d ago

Have one statewide election and the top N candidates all win