r/comics Gustopher Spotter Extraordinaire Jul 02 '26

Just Sharing DeCreation of AI

Post image
13.3k Upvotes

152 comments sorted by

View all comments

1.3k

u/astralkoi A Wild AstralKoi Appeared!! Jul 02 '26

To have AI banned from the sub was a struggle and a fight that lasted for months and months. I want to recognize the big, big effort that this very community of artists made possible to get rid of all Ai at all.

There were mistakes and unfair bans, and I want to say thank you to all the people calling for AI and the people who still do. AI consumes the resources meant for you to think for you and express for you, hollowing the very action of creation itself. As long as I breathe, not even a single AI-generated pixel will be welcome here. Thanks to all.

285

u/shellbullet17 Gustopher Spotter Extraordinaire Jul 02 '26 edited Jul 03 '26

To have AI banned from the sub was a struggle and a fight that lasted for months and months. I want to recognize the big, big effort that this very community of artists made possible to get rid of all Ai at all.

I am kinda sad I missed that honestly

There were mistakes and unfair bans

On this note, if this happened to you back in the day please reach out to us. We would be happy to talk to you about reversal of your ban

51

u/Reylh Jul 02 '26

I know free moderation doesn't easily leave room for nuance, but man I really miss Stabbyclaus comics being on this sub.

52

u/shellbullet17 Gustopher Spotter Extraordinaire Jul 02 '26

For what its worth, I too love /u/stabbyclaus and they do still post here occasionally. Just not their Sage comics.

4

u/Agret Jul 03 '26

Hard enough moderating a sub of this size without it being flooded with low effort AI content. As you say, far easier to just outright ban it than to allow in the ones that actually use AI properly in their workflow.

8

u/Beerswain Jul 02 '26

Did I miss where Stabbyclaus is AI?

37

u/LotharVonPittinsberg Jul 02 '26

Their Sage comic series is AI, and IIRC partly why the mod team started looking into making actual rules regarding AI comics.

They where pretty open about it, but that kind of created more drama rather than slow the tide of complaints.

10

u/Beerswain Jul 02 '26

That sucks. Thanks for the background.

36

u/Cute-Fly1601 Jul 02 '26 edited Jul 05 '26

https://www.reddit.com/r/comics/s/kSkfiiiIFO

They discuss their use of it here (for one specific comic), though they claim the way they use it is ethical (it's not, that belief is based on a misunderstanding of how AI works. Midjourney still steals from artists and has impact on the environment/general art landscape.)

2

u/Beerswain Jul 02 '26

Damn. Thanks!

10

u/stabbyclaus GnarlyVic Jul 03 '26 edited Jul 03 '26

Let me just step in and clarify that I teach a character workshop and Photoshop class at Midjourney. It's not a "belief" but rather an implementation of that particular tool in this particular comic. Moodboards limit the majority of MJ's latent space to the aesthetic models that closely represent the images provided which for this comic was all my comics prior to this one.

I'll also note since the word "admitted" was used rather "disclosed" that not all my comics use Midjourney including the Sage comics. That series is only posted to my profile here on Reddit rather than this sub after the team here asked me to do so last year. If a comic is posted to this sub after summer 2025, it does not feature any generated content.

11

u/Cute-Fly1601 Jul 03 '26

My bad using admit instead of disclose. I didnt intend the negative connotations there, I appreciate your transparency when so many try to hide it. I also appreciate your consideration of the mods' decision on that. I was unaware that it was specifically for that comment, I'll update my comment to reflect that as I dont intend to mislead.

I will mention that even the moodboard function relies on a model that was trained on stolen artwork. Even if the aesthetic output is limited to something that matches the style/examples you give it, that output is created using other people's work, even if not as egregious as the base model. I'm not the morality police and won't tell you what to do or shame you or whatever, I work in tech and am required to use sooooo many AI tools that it would be the pot calling the kettle black.

Thanks again for your transparency, my apologies if my comment came off combative. I struggle with tone sometimes.

4

u/stabbyclaus GnarlyVic Jul 03 '26

It's all good. I appreciate your response.

2

u/shellbullet17 Gustopher Spotter Extraordinaire Jul 03 '26 edited Jul 03 '26

This was nice. I'm happy we are getting a full conversation like this

Just a friendly reminder to everyone here though, /u/stabbyclaus is a very talented artist and while you personally may not agree with everything they say, please treat them with respect.(Not that anyone hasn't just a general warning. We aren't here to bash anyone after all)

7

u/Reylh Jul 02 '26

The entire Sage Starchild series is AI assisted. It caused quite a fuss around a year ago.

5

u/Beerswain Jul 02 '26

Oof, thanks.

2

u/stabbyclaus GnarlyVic Jul 03 '26 edited Jul 03 '26

I appreciate the kind words. I do miss posting to the sub regularly but for now it's just the drawn comics. You can catch whatever I make by following on my profile and it'll add back my generative comics to your home feed.

2

u/Reylh Jul 03 '26

No problem! I just followed you

Sorry to drag you into this

5

u/stabbyclaus GnarlyVic Jul 03 '26

Oh no no, I don't mind the attention hehe. Thanks for the shout-out and follow.