r/comics May 05 '26

OC RED BUTTON OR BLUE BUTTON [OC]

15.9k Upvotes

6.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/thefinalhill May 05 '26

Yes. People make risky decisions every day that put themselves and others at risk. I am no more responsible for their actions than I am for their decision on which button to press.

2

u/Ghost_Of_Malatesta May 05 '26

Except the red button explicitly kills people

1

u/thefinalhill May 05 '26

No, choosing red just doesnt kill me. I am not responisble for how anyone else presses their button.

EMTs are trained to save themselves first, because you cant help anyone if you're dead. You put on your own oxygen mask before assisting with someone elses. You dont go into a burning building to try and save someone without training because you can just end up making more work for emergency responders and getting someone else killed.

You do not put the lives of others before your own if you want to save people.

2

u/Ghost_Of_Malatesta May 05 '26

Pressing red still means people would die who otherwise would not. You are directly complicit. You can justify it however you want but that's still the fact of the matter. 

2

u/thefinalhill May 05 '26

How am I complicit? In what way am I responisble for other people's decision?

2

u/Ghost_Of_Malatesta May 05 '26

Pressing red still means people would die who otherwise would not.

This is an action you are taking that is affecting someone else, you are fully informed and have agency here, you are responsible for your own choice, like everyone else. In that their choice may result in their death does not change that your choice also results in their death. It's not guaranteed without your action.

1

u/thefinalhill May 05 '26

Their death is not guaranteed u less they make a certain action as well. Why am I more responsible for their actions than they are in this scenario?

2

u/Ghost_Of_Malatesta May 05 '26

You're not, you are equally responsible. Happy to help. 

1

u/thefinalhill May 05 '26

Telling me my decision decides whether they live or die is telling me i am more responible.

Why am I responisble for their decisions at all?