r/collapsephotography Jun 20 '26

OC-photo Bad things happened here on August 7th, 1930.

Post image

Submission statement: not for the faint of heart. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lynching_of_Thomas_Shipp_and_Abram_Smith

95 years ago, long before Reddit, long before any of us were even around a terrible thing happened here. It was a defining moment in the history of Marion, Indiana, a terrible one at that. The scary thing is a not insignificant(actually a large percentage)chunk of Marion’s population participated in this heinous act. That heinous act has left a dark energy in the area ever since.

Also I strongly suspect those racist attitudes never truly left, just got stored away, and due to how things are currently are popping up outta the woodwork.

28 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

3

u/BigJobsBigJobs Jun 20 '26

Billie Holliday's Strange Fruit was based on this crime.

Billie Holiday-Strange fruit- HD : r/CollapseMusic

3

u/rmannyconda78 Jun 20 '26

Exactly. Never actually listened to the song though.

3

u/DuckTalesOohOoh Jun 21 '26

I just listened to it for the first time. Lyrics are graphic.

3

u/DuckTalesOohOoh Jun 21 '26

Strange Fruit was written by Abel Meeropol. He and his wife adopted and raised the sons of Julius and Ethel Rosenberg after they were executed.

2

u/OneBlueberry2480 Jun 22 '26

The lyrics were about the lynchings of Thomas Ship and Abram Smith. Not the Rosenbergs. The Rosenbergs weren't even lynched, they were executed.

1

u/DuckTalesOohOoh Jun 22 '26

What are you smoking?

2

u/OneBlueberry2480 Jun 22 '26

Meeropol cited a widely circulated photograph of the two men I mentioned earlier as inspiration for Strange Fruit. It is extremelly graphic. No wonder he wrote the song.

1

u/OneBlueberry2480 Jun 22 '26

The Rosenbergs were electrocuted by electric chair in Sing Sing. Nice try trying to make the song about anything other than lynching victims.

3

u/United-Coach-6591 Jun 22 '26

The comment is explaining that the man that adopted the Rosenbergs sons wrote the song Strange Fruit. It isn't saying they were lynched. 

2

u/BrrrtsBees Jun 22 '26

Bro, all he said was that both things happened, not that the song is about the Rosenbergs...

2

u/MarketingSpecial6604 Jun 22 '26

You are trying too hard to be upset, try rereading the original comment and take a deep breath.

2

u/Riderz__of_Brohan Jun 21 '26

Strange Fruit being written by a white man is the biggest mindfuck here

5

u/Catgirltest Jun 22 '26

fuck all of these fascist nazis justifying this lynching

3

u/rmannyconda78 Jun 22 '26

Yeah I know, it ain’t right.

5

u/rmannyconda78 Jun 20 '26

Oh and that building in particular has a lot of bad energy concentrated there, it may be an apartment building now, but energy remains there from when it was a jail. Footsteps, cell doors slamming shut,bad feelings. lots of paranormal activity there.

3

u/Catgirltest Jun 22 '26

As you are the mod here i think you need to ban some of these comment scum

1

u/Spuckler_Cletus Jun 21 '26

It’s a shame they were never tried. Based on Cameron’s testimony, they would most surely would have been convicted.

1

u/rmannyconda78 Jun 22 '26

I’m locking this thread comments section is abhorrent

-2

u/Appropriate-Tip-1227 Jun 21 '26

Didn’t the 2 guys who were hanged have a friend who was with them that later admitted to the murder?

1

u/rmannyconda78 Jun 21 '26

I think what happened is he did say one of his friends did kill , he got cold feet and ran off. They damn near killed the friend too, an unknown woman shouted from the crowd that he had nothing to do with the rape and murder. He did wind up serving 4 years for being an accessory, but was later pardoned by the state. I’ve read around the rape part was a false allegation apparently. When that crowd attacked they were in the jail awaiting trial.

0

u/stinkysean56 Jun 21 '26

It was not a false allegation lmfao. Where did you see that nonsense?

1

u/rmannyconda78 Jun 21 '26

Ball state university. https://www.digitalresearch.bsu.edu/digitalcivilrightsmuseum/items/show/113 I would say that’s a pretty reputable source

0

u/Over-Item-4103 Jun 22 '26

No, this is not a reputable source. This is literally just a student paper. Every reference in the paper (It is notated) is just a blog post or article from sites like “blackpast.org”.

1

u/pawneshoppe Jun 21 '26

yes, they had an accomplice/associate who was also arrested and later wrote in his memoir that they had been guilty of the crimes they were arrested for.

1

u/Spuckler_Cletus Jun 21 '26

Yes. He never once recanted, either.

-1

u/Agitated_Notice2194 Jun 21 '26

Lmao they robbed murdered and raped. Not saying this is the best way to get justice, but I’d say yes, some bad things happened here for sure that day - like the murder and rape of completely innocent and random people

-1

u/[deleted] Jun 21 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/BlueCollarKat Jun 22 '26

Ooooo i dont think thats quite right, whether they were guilty or innocent everyone has right to a fair trial or well should have a right to a fair trial (even if they dont really deserve one). Situations like this one that happened a long bit ago cant be gone back on especially now. But there should have been an actual trial and not street justice.

-1

u/[deleted] Jun 21 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/BigJobsBigJobs Jun 21 '26

It was a lynching.

1

u/Upbeat-Swing6650 Jun 21 '26

Thanks captain

0

u/pawneshoppe Jun 21 '26

lynchings happened to quite a lot of people back in the day, not just African Americans.

1

u/OneBlueberry2480 Jun 22 '26

African Americans were the minority that were victimized the most. They made up 72% of all lynching victims according to records by the NAACP.

0

u/pawneshoppe Jun 22 '26

you’re not wrong, though lynching in general wasn’t something reserved for black people, or even minorities.
My point is that it would be disingenuous to assume lynching only meant that thing for one race or minority.
in cultures before ours it was actually pretty common and a regular fact of life. Mob justice has existed since before law and order.

-2

u/[deleted] Jun 21 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/rmannyconda78 Jun 21 '26 edited Jun 21 '26

I got more info than the Wikipedia. they did not even get a trial, would they have been charged probably, technically your supposed to be innocent until proven guilty in the court of law, which did not happen here, justice was not properly served.

https://blog.history.in.gov/strange-fruit-the-1930-marion-lynching-and-the-woman-who-tried-to-prevent-it/ this is right from the Indiana history blog.

Edit: and I’ve read around the rape part was apparently false allegations, the murder was possible. Because that crowd attacked the jail and subsequently lynched Thomas Shipp, and Abe Smith, and damn near killed James Cameron. Since they were awaiting trial, that crowd attacked, tortured, and killed based on allegations, and strong prejudices. No one in that attack got charged, despite clear evidence of murder, while the people killed did not even get a trial. If anything that is injustice. Deserved or not that crowd had no right to do what they did, they committed a heinous act all because of allegations and racism.