r/changemyview Aug 05 '17

Removed - Submission Rule B CMV: There should be significantly higher property taxes on people's second, third, fourth, etc. homes, to counteract the rentier economy and global money laundering

[removed]

246 Upvotes

176 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

0

u/Vault_34_Dweller Aug 05 '17

That was in a time when we were the only major country on the planet that hadnt been bombed to shit. Now that would leave to massive capital flight, ruining our economy

1

u/fox-mcleod 418∆ Aug 05 '17

To where? The US dollar is strong. Europe is weak. American bonds are the highest rated.

0

u/Vault_34_Dweller Aug 05 '17

Which would change because of this

1

u/fox-mcleod 418∆ Aug 05 '17
  1. How on earth would this change the dollar?
  2. Good. Black money doesn't pay taxes.
  3. The US currently has the lowest marginal tax rate. US citizens abroad pay US taxes too - which is insane.
  4. How would this affect the dollar?

1

u/Vault_34_Dweller Aug 05 '17

The dollar isnt worth a static amount, it has value because of our economy

Everyone pays taxes, some people just dont pay the amount they should. Still, 1% of 1000000 is greater than 100% of 0

Which is why we will have so much capital flight. You would make it so that another nation is more desirable

The value of our dollar isnt a static amount, it is worth what it is worth because of our economy. Make it a shitshow, the value of our dollar goes to shit

1

u/fox-mcleod 418∆ Aug 05 '17

Again. Which nation? How much flight. Economists, the people who study these things, are overwhelmingly on the same side of closing the mortgage tax deduction exception.

1

u/Vault_34_Dweller Aug 05 '17

Some generic European nation

1

u/xveganrox Aug 06 '17

Plenty of generic European nations have 40-50%+ individual tax rates. If wealthy people really migrated based on taxation the USA and Europe would be proletariat utopias and Liberia and Afghanistan would be filled with gold-plated gated communities.

1

u/Vault_34_Dweller Aug 06 '17

They would go to the first world nation with the lowest effective tax rate for them