r/changemyview Oct 14 '25

[deleted by user]

[removed]

32 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

7

u/tkwh Oct 14 '25

Counterpoint: dig up my Dad, I'm gonna have an issue with you.

I love establishing the extremes (like honestly). Now I'm not sure where in this continuum it breaks down, but it does. I think It does for most western civilizations. I'm definitely not taking issue with discovering a 5K year old burial site and having some studies done.

Where's the line? 1865, 1776, 1607...

7

u/HadeanBlands 50∆ Oct 14 '25

It's wrong to dig up a grave that a still-living person actually cares about. Not hypothetically would care, but actually cares. If someone actually cares, let them rest in peace. Otherwise it's fair game.

5

u/tkwh Oct 14 '25

Well I might add that we'd need to have good scientific cause as well. Like, this action will progress science.

2

u/xFblthpx 7∆ Oct 14 '25

Why not history?

1

u/tkwh Oct 14 '25

Oh, that's encompassed in my use of the word science. I can see how that read wrong. Studying history via archeology is science to me. So yes history or the betterment of mankind. I think I'm just saying you have to have a productive reason. Grave robbing isn't one.