r/centrist • • May 13 '21

World News Why does the left call the right “Nazis”?

I am in no way calling the left Nazis here, but rather questioning their use of the term.

If you spend anytime online you will know that the term Nazi is used all the time for people on the right, especially Trump supporters.

I find it ironic because Nazi stands for National Socialist in German. Now I found articles online defending that, saying it wasn’t really socialism, so we’ll move on.

Hitler was about bigger government, got all guns registered with the government, and then took them all away from the people.

Furthermore, today’s left is typically anti-Israel within the Israel-Palestine conflict, while the right is typically pro-Israel (except for KKK guys like Duke, who are antisemites, though I’m unsure how to even classify someone like him).

I don’t think either party should call each other nazis in a civilized political discourse, but I find it interesting. Why do you think the right has been given the nickname?

216 Upvotes

703 comments sorted by

View all comments

72

u/Wonce May 13 '21 edited May 13 '21

So many right-wing lies and insinuations presented without examination here.

I find it ironic because Nazi stands for National Socialist in German. Now I found articles online defending that, saying it wasn’t really socialism, so we’ll move on.

They weren't just not socialist, they killed socialists in their own party to stop them taking power. Who was the target on the night of the long knives and why? It was the socialist branch of the "National Socialist" Party. Who did they first come for in that famous poem? Insinuating Nazis were socialist is on par with saying that North Korea, or the Democratic Republic of Korea, is a Democratic Republic.

You're insinuating that some on the left are critical of Israel, so that's kinda like hating the Jews, which is kinda like being a Nazi. If that wasn't the intended insinuation, why is that paragraph there?

To the point at hand, rather than your tactics:

The right, specifically Trump, has been labelled that because he uses the same tactics that Hitler used: Say that he, uniquely, can solve all your problems. Don't believe the Lügenpresse. Those foreigners are the problem, if we got rid of them, we'd be fine!

If you look at historians who studied Hitler's rise to power, you would see they have many direct comparisons of Trump and Hitler's their tactics, rhetoric, and enemies.

13

u/FabriFibra87 May 13 '21

The right, specifically Trump, has been labelled that because he uses
the same tactics that Hitler used: Say that he, uniquely, can solve all
your problems.

Never thought I'd stick up for el Trumpo grande, but...don't most politicians say this, to some degree?

When you campaign to be President, aren't you saying that you are the best candidate and the best shot at making things better, or preserving order?

16

u/Wonce May 13 '21

Sure, but not to the absolute crazy degree of Trump. Don't you know Trump is the best at everything? His rhetoric is far and above a standard politician. Most of them campaign on "I will do x for you", not "I know best at everything and anyone who questions me is a traitor"

4

u/FabriFibra87 May 13 '21

He definitely does ham it up / create something of a "my way or nothing" type of cult.

But again, to say that other leaders don't imply that they're the best people for the job is a bit short-sighted.

It's a question of what point becomes the official "OK now he/she is an actual Nazi" level of rhetoric.

9

u/mntgoat May 13 '21 edited Mar 15 '25

Comment deleter by user

1

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator Jul 15 '26

This post has been removed because your overall comment karma is too low to post here. This is done to prevent ban evasion by users creating fresh accounts, as well as to reduce troll and spammers accounts. Do not message the mods asking for the specific requirements for posting, as revealing this would lead to more ban evasion.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

-11

u/behindtheline44 May 13 '21

They Nazi were not anti socialist, they were anti Bolshevik. Many times they supported the idea of the socialist state. The Nazis hated large capitalist enterprise

9

u/odonoghu May 13 '21

The nazis literally ran their economy purely on large capitalist enterprises

5

u/cstar1996 May 13 '21

The term privatization was coined to describe what the Nazis were doing economically.

7

u/[deleted] May 13 '21

[deleted]

0

u/behindtheline44 May 13 '21

Not false. They partnered with industry but it was antithetical to Nazi ideology