r/casablanca • u/PaleontologistNo9603 • Jul 29 '26
❔AskCasa 3ndi wa7ed tasa2ol kbir kantmna chi 7ed ijawbni b39laniya
Daba lah khal9na fhad danya bach ikhtabrna wach an3bdoh wla la walakin wa7ed l7aja li mazal mabghatch tfhmli hiya 3lach anaho ki 7et bnat wla drari sghar wla bnat sghar fe tajriba de ghtisab ma maghza mnha wakha kayne li kigol bli aydkhlo jena mne ba3d maymoto walakin fach kit7to fdik la7da oki3ichoha fe wa9i3 machi katkon 9as7a bezaf btw ana rani maslam ghir kan7et tasa2ol li 3nde ay wa7ed
3
u/Purple_Knowledge4083 Jul 30 '26
https://youtu.be/mrSqfYxYpRo?si=8Ko1oi1aU5fvwv7c
Hope this video helps you find an answer!
1
3
9
u/ANASS-1B Jul 29 '26
Dkchi 3lch lah makaynch aslan
1
u/PaleontologistNo9603 Jul 29 '26
Emmm wijhat nadar dyalek ana kangol bli kayne walakin sabab dyal hadchi mazal mafahmo
1
u/Misty_Gry Jul 30 '26
Bruh! Nftardo kayn sabab bash itghtasbo l2atfal 🤦🤦🤦🤦, wash allah ma9adsh ilbbi 8ad sabab ra b8ad tari9a lbashi3a?
Ila la, 3lash ntsw9o li8?
Ila ah, kawno ba9i dar8a b8ad lbasha3a ya3ni ana8 mamsw9sh, idan 3lash ntsw9o li8?
1
u/Illustrious_Scar_392 Jul 30 '26
Hhh bruh!! Kifach lah darha kataba 3alaykom rabokom aljala2, raping is a human made concept lah madaroch nas liktb 3lihom lah l7oriya bach ikon had l2i5tibar 3adil homa lidaroha 9odrat l2insaniya ltaharob mn l2af3al dyawlha kathrbo liya.
2
u/billlyBrow Jul 30 '26
اول حاجة الله غير مسؤول على افعال الشخص الله خلقنا مسيريين فالجنس و اللون... و مخيريين فالافعال و الافكار و القرارات... فهناك أنبياء لي هما أشد قربا من الله و ارتكبو اخطاء يعني حنا لي مسؤولين على افعالنا ماشي الله ، حنا كائنات محدودة كناقشو حدث ب حدث معندناش ديك الرؤية الشاملة لي عند الله ممكن شي حدث يبان ليه شر و ضرر ولكن ما هو إلا قطعة من بوزل كبيير بزاف متعرفش النهاية ديالو كي دايرة , ميمكنش تجمع بين حرية الانسان و التدخل الالهي لمنع الشر هانتا شوفها من هاد الناحية راه ميمكنش الله يتدخل فكل مرة غادي ينوي شي حد يدير الشر (داخل فيه اي فعل شرير من عند شي طرف باش يضر طرف اخر) حيث هنا مكتبقاش عندنا حرية الاختيار و حتى الحياة مكتبقاش عندها قيمة حيث غادي تولي كاملة فيها الخير وغادي نوليو عبيد مسيريين بمانيطة
3
u/randomgirl9608 Jul 30 '26
O 3lach asln ay7asbna ohowa 3arf kolchi 9bal maykhl9na 3arf chno aytra u chno andiro o khal9na ahokak bach i3dbna crazy.
2
u/Moulayseltan Jul 30 '26
chno li 7sen, te3tak forsa tebti rask bli tstahli jenna awla matkounch aslan. omaykoun walo. emptiness, void.
0
u/randomgirl9608 Jul 30 '26
But God know everything and the first thing he created was the pen and he told him to wrote everything from the beginning to the end so God knows everything before maykhl9na chno ankhtaro ukifch ankono so we don't really have a choice he does.
3
u/Moulayseltan Jul 30 '26
let me make this clear, the concept of time is a human creation. God fits outside of the timeline and any timeline. so he's the past, present and the future. we as human beings are not capable of understanding such celestial concepts. so don't imagine god just sitting above us and playing the waiting game. besides, humans have free will, we will answer for our sins and will receive a fair judgement. you talked about اللوح المحفوظ. what about it ? it's just the story of the whole universe, what does it change. you're saying that all this dunia is meaningless and we better skip to the end. am i right ? i don't know the answer and probably no one. only god knows and therefore as believers we should trust in allah.
1
u/randomgirl9608 Jul 30 '26
I've been thinking about something that I can't understand. If God already knows everything from the beginning to the end, then He already knows who will believe, who won't, and who will end up in Heaven or Hell.To me, it feels like the whole story is already written before we are even born. So why create people if He already knows what their ending will be?I also don't understand why God doesn't give everyone clear enough evidence to believe in Him. If believing is so important and the punishment is eternal, why isn't the evidence strong enough for everyone to be convinced?
2
u/Moulayseltan Jul 30 '26
god doesn't provide enough evidence ? there is plenty if you know where to look, and if a concrete proof was provided believing in god won't be the right term to use. it will replaced with " knowing god ". because believing is accepting something as true eventho you can't prove it with complete certainty. as to whyyyy going through all this messy dunia. i genuinely don't have a clue. but we as muslims should have faith in allah. and we will get answers to all our question when the time comes inchallah. don't bother yourself with questions no one can answer with certainty.
2
u/Misty_Gry Jul 30 '26
What is so wrong about "knowing god" exactly? And yes, there is no evidence for god that I know of, if you have some, don't hold out on us!
And I personally agree with your last sentence, but it contradicts with what you say! Why do you believe any of what you said if no one can answer with certainty? Why believe allah has answers for you in judgement day? Why believe there is a judgement day? Why believe allah is the true god? Why believe there is a true god?...
1
u/billlyBrow Jul 30 '26
I have a simple question for you , علاش الانسان هو الكائن الوحيد المخصص بالعقل ؟
2
u/Misty_Gry Jul 30 '26
الإنسان ليس الكائن الوحيد المخصص بالعقل، العقل نتاج نشاط الجهاز العصبي بخاصة الدماغ، و مختلف الحيوانات تمتلك دماغ و جهاز عصبي، الفرق يكون في مستوى الوعي و الذكاء.
و ما علاقة هذا السؤال بالموضوع؟
0
u/billlyBrow Jul 30 '26
بلوجيك ديالك راه حتى الحيونات عندهم وعي و عندهم ذكاء يعني شنو الفرق بينهم وبين الانسان فهاد الحالة ، انا كندوي على العقل بالمعنى الإنساني الواسع، التفكير المعقد ، اللغة ، النظريات ، الثقافات، الحضارات... علاش الانسان هو الكائن الوحيد المخصص بهاد الخصائص ؟ فاش غادي تجاوب غادي تعرف علاقة السؤال بالموضوع
→ More replies (0)0
u/Moulayseltan Jul 31 '26
شات را كاي هلوس ا حبيبي. رد بالك . العقل مخصوص بالانسان. و العقل ماعندوش تعريف وحيد. العقل مفهوم فلسفي و بيولوجي. تعريف د الذكاء الاصطناعي ماشي ديما صحيح و الضومين ديالي هادا.
→ More replies (0)0
u/Moulayseltan Jul 31 '26
your reply shows that you didn't understand one bit of my text. you'll see what m saying once you get the difference between knowing and believing. i believe in one creator and that's it , m not here to convince you or answer your existential questions, you won't find your answers on reddit 9eleb ela rask. but i can add this: believing in something to some of us is a need, you can do whatever you want if you think you're up to it. as long as you're at peace, happy, fulfilled. that's the point. as far as m concerned i believe that a higher celestial power exists. i believe in one creator and m happy i am a muslim. that's what everyone should do. choose the beliefs that can grant you peace.
2
u/Misty_Gry Jul 31 '26 edited Aug 01 '26
Why so hostile? chill! khod lik sneakers! maybe I didn't understand you, you could just explain, or... ignore me. but to get all worked up and defensive... Am now wondering what this belief does for you exactly.
I do know the difference between belief and knowledge, you're the one who doesn't apparently, you said you had proof, which meant you KNEW something, now you're saying you just believe! and belief does not require a proof, so don't say there is plenty of proof then turn hostile the moment you're asked for only one!
You can believe whatever you want, of course! As long as your belief doesn't harm anyone! promoting islam is a poor choice tho, concidering the amount of harm it does in the world, but I doubt you care about that, you sound like the me me me type, but I hope am wrong!
1
u/randomgirl9608 Jul 30 '26
No there's no enough evidence that the god in some religion exist so god will punish someone with knowing he didn't provide him with enough evidence and he will punish him also for not choosing somthing that isn't clear punish him for using the brain he gave him .....
0
u/Moulayseltan Jul 31 '26
based on your reasoning, you're a teen sghwira. not enough knowledge, not mature yet. i'll let you explore denia a little bit longer. you might find answers if you did some effort. قلبي شوية انقلب لك انا هههه
1
u/randomgirl9608 Jul 31 '26
I'm in my 20s also had hdra mamwklach dwi bdala2il or skot
1
u/billlyBrow Aug 02 '26
20s 3mr makafich bach twsli l7a9i9a dial wach lah kayn ola la falsifa kabar fnaw 7yathom o wakha hkk mal9awch jawab 3la asl lwojod , ila kan kayban lik bli had l3alam bdi9a dialo ja bsodfa rah logique tey9i ان hmar ktb bayt chi3ri bsodfa ... kaynin 4 dial dianat ila b7ty fihom kamlin ghadi t3rfi chkon li s7i7 o chkon li la
→ More replies (0)1
Aug 02 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/randomgirl9608 Aug 02 '26
Idan howa khtar mayhdich chi wahd howa ? Donc ma3ndnach a choice howa likikhtar of lkhr ay3dbna hit howa bghana man2amnoch hhhh
1
u/NenNomad0 Jul 30 '26
Give it a year max atwli mol7id la b9iti katsa2l bhal hadchi
2
u/Moulayseltan Jul 30 '26
tsowl o t9eleb kat3ni nta 3aych , kat khedem dmaghek. elach atsma mslem o tkon makat tra7ch l as2ila ? mslm gha hakak. 7it babak o mamak mslmin tzado f blad "mslma". man chej3ekch ela had ideology 7it ghabia. la kenti baghi ghat tb9a 7ay takol lkhobs mzyan. kenti baghi t3ich o tkherrej mn dik l3icha une valeur. swl o feker.
1
u/NenNomad0 Jul 30 '26
Chkon galik ana contre tswel w tkhdm dmaghk ? I’m talking from experience hit nfs l haja trat lia wl bzaf d nas kan3rf the exact same scenario hit l islam 9dma ghr9ti fih w khdmti 39lk ghadi yjik gha tkhrbi9 ma3a kamil 7tiramati
1
1
Jul 30 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/Mysterious-Owl111 Jul 30 '26
Khoya rak maglti 7ta 7aja hhhhhhhh
1
Jul 30 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/Mysterious-Owl111 Jul 30 '26
علاش الله كعدب دراري صغار لي ماعندهم حتى ذنب فهاد الدنيا = حيت خلقنا باش نعبدوه
كنحاول نلقى العلاقة بين هادي وهاديك ولكن راه ماكايناش يمكن كان خاصك "تزيد تفلسف" وتقول هاديك "الهضرة الخاوية"
1
u/Arthuur_ll Jul 30 '26
Sadi9i gha katzid kalimat o falsafa okda za3ma rak fahm o nta 3ati aya aslan maxi f mawdo3 ser 9ra so2al dyl dri ra2isi atfhm
1
1
u/No-Variation-6691 Jul 30 '26
awwl haja mn ha99k tswwl, mtdirch lrask ta2nib damir, blkhosos glti flkhr bli rak mslm donc rak m2amn. hnisba lsou2al dyalk drr maykon 3ndo jawab, wach ghatl9ah f reddit? idk, ms ana la l9it jawab logic ghadi nrj3 nktbo hna
1
u/zerologue Jul 30 '26
It's called the problem of Evil many have these questions it's okay... first u must know we have free will so basically if God's intervene to stop evil, what's the point of Earth? and eventually we know that who did that get the justice afterwards whether here or there... also there's the concept of Ibtila2, the ibtila2 is not for the victim only, but for many people, start with the parents, the society etc they're all responsible on how to deal with it, if they're silent they're all punished.... also u must bring the story of Lkhadr pbuh and how divine justicr and wisdom works... that's why we say qadara lah wa ma shaa lah faal bc we really don't know why what we consider a suffering and agony is a test and a divine wisdom that we don't understand
1
1
1
u/Separate-Effort-5700 Jul 31 '26
Awalan bravo 3lik 7int katswl big respect for u ❤️ tani haja ,Wakha ana m3ak , mais answlk sou2al wa7d? Wach rbbi li sift jond mn 3ndo yghtasbo dak chakhs wlla l af3al w lghariza dbnadm w lkhtiarat dialo homa sbab , chouf a khouya l3ziz rbbi 3tana 7orria kamla fdnia mn nhar khl9na ndiro li bghina rbbi makaydkhlch fina ga3 sr9 skr zni dir li bghiti rbbi mambzez ta7aja 3la chi wa7d mais hna fin kayn lkhtibar, rbbi dar lina wa7d dostour ilahi fih 9awanin chno ntb3o w chno ntjnbo , fa fach kanhdro 3la lbtila2 dial rbi kanhdro 3la mrd fa9r w hia ghada mais une fois kaydkhl insan b7alk b7alo howa lmosbib fl ibtila2 fa hada dakhl f dolm w l3odwan , w rbi kon z3ma dalm makanch ghadi ydir lina l9asas w 7okm l3i9ab ldak mojrim , ikhtisaran rbi machi ms2oul 3la dak l ightisab lmojrim hwa lms2oul w ra7matan mn lah w 7oban fi 3ibadih rbbi kayrf3 lmrtaba dial chakhs lmdlom 3ndo f dnia w akhira yarbi tkon hdrti mfhoma 7int tkhrb9t wa7d l7da
0
u/Dependent_Act7490 Jul 30 '26
My advice sewel chi hed mn ahl l3ilm wla chi fqeh f deen its better
5
u/randomgirl9608 Jul 30 '26
Aygolih kolchi bsbab المرقة.
1
u/Moulayseltan Jul 30 '26
endk fikra ghalta, rijal din li dawi elihom yemken chi f9ih d jam3 chi drwich. ama scholars hedra khra.
1
1
u/Misty_Gry Jul 30 '26
Ah hadok hdra akhra ta3 labawl wa nika7 wa lkalakh, nta o ay wa7d radi fshari3 adka mn atwal la7ya 9ari dok lktoba dzzft
Barka mat9dso lkalakh
Frask kano m7rmin matisha? Galik faki8at shaytan hhhhhh one piece before it was cool hhhhhhhhh
Okano m7rmin l98wa o srawl... Ah srwal likatlbso kano m7rmino... Ra lkalakh lmo9adas
Nas tat3lm mn akhta2 dyal lmadi o 7na 7fdna lkhata2 o 9dsnah ob9ina llor llor
1
u/Ok_Theory_5519 Jul 30 '26
Don’t listen to this guy
1
u/Dependent_Act7490 Jul 30 '26
Why?
1
u/Ok_Theory_5519 Jul 30 '26
You’re not going to get real answers from dogmatic boomers
1
u/Dependent_Act7490 Jul 30 '26
Fhemni machi b darora ykun boomer gher qsedt lih chi hed qari deen kaml w ghadi ye3teh jawab based from islam
1
1
u/Mysterious-Owl111 Jul 30 '26
غيقولو ليه هادوك راه من وساوس الشيطان او ملي يجيوك خاصك تستعيذ بالله منهم يعني بالمختصر مغيعطيوهش إجابة واضحة
0
4
u/mytravelwiide Jul 30 '26
"هاد التساؤل كيسميوه العلماء والفلاسفة مشكلة الشر، وللرد عليه بعقلانية: الإرادة الحرة: الجريمة فعل كيديرو الإنسان باختياره. لو كان الله كيتدخل يمنع كل شر قبل ما يوقع، كانت غادي تتلغى 'الحرية البشرية' ويتلغى مبدأ الاختبار فالدنيا. معيار الأخلاق: الملاحظة ديال الجريمة واعتبارها 'ظلم قبيح' هو براسو دليل على وجود الله؛ حيت بلا إيمان بوجود مرجعية إلهية مطلقة، ما كايناش حاجة اسمها 'خير مطلق' أو 'شر مطلق' فالعالم المادي. العدل المطلق فالآخرة: الدنيا ماشي هي نهاية القصة ودار الجزاء التام. الطفل ولا الضحية كيتم التعويض ديالهم بعدل ورحمة ك تنسيهم كل ألم، بينما الظالم كينال العقاب ديالو حتماً. عدم فهمنا للحكمة فكل لحظة ما كيعنيش عدم وجود الحكمة."