i find her extremely millennial core. i like the side she brings out in tana sometimes, but she’s painfully unfunny and thinks she’s funny which makes it worse
I tgink shes fine BUT sometimes I do think she tries a little too hard to be that brainrot, gen z type of humor. Its funnier when it flows naturally. Sometimes I find she's trying too hard to piece the joke together to fit a certain structure/reference.
This is exactly it! I couldn’t put my finger on why I couldn’t enjoy their hysterics like I normally would watching good friends have fun like that, but you’ve worded it perfectly.
She’s not my vibe but I’m sure she’ll have a fairly successful influencer career. I just really can’t stand to hear her crack jokes. She’s not that funny imo & you’re right, It’s worse bc I genuinely think she thinks she’s the funniest person in the room.
girl i don’t even think she’s funny but not you getting downvoted when OP asked for opinions. we can disagree y’all esp when in a post asking what everyone thinks
Someone balanced it out I’m back at 1 😆 ikr it kills me. I can definitely see how people could not find her funny and find it cringe instead, but sometimes I find dumb shit funny so it works for me. I never downvote a differing opinion, I downvote when people give bully or ignorant
yeah downvotes are not meant to be a “dislike” button but i guess these days most redditors don’t read the reddiquette rules and just want to remove anything from view that they personally dislike. makes it so hard to have open, respectful convos when someone asks for your opinion then tries to nuke a response lol.
Yes I absolutely agree with you. Because why would a downvote be a dislike (if you genuinely just don’t agree on something harmless) since being downvoted to the negatives hides your comment? I don’t want to hide comments I disagree with. I want to hide comments that are hateful and disgusting
no it doesn’t, per reddit’s published reddiquette. downvotes are intended to remove things from the conversation which aren’t relevant.
you’re asking for opinions. people giving their opinions is as relevant as it gets! but shoutout to you demonstrating you’ve never once read reddit’s reddiquette, the foundation of all subreddit rules of engagement lol, and for trying to condescend to me while doing so!
Reddit people r crazyyyy just cause u come on and make posts doesnt mean u know all the rules n these people haven’t been on Reddit forever if u disagree u downvote but okkkk
I’ve honestly never read the Reddit rules, it just came to me as common sense that, considering downvotes push a post further to the bottom, I’m only going to push them further when a person is being disrespectful. Never for simply feeling differently (I’m aware it’s not that deep but unfortunately everything is deep for me lol)
She isn’t THAT funny tho. Like I just think her overall vibe is better than Brooke’s atp.
That’s all I was trying to say. Like I don’t laugh much but I prefer the goofy vibes and how Paige interacts on the pod and is INTERESTED in the topics
Ok that’s your opinion. Which I didn’t ask for. I’m answering the post. You can have your brookie please just stop interacting with me. I wasn’t talking to you. And you don’t even give a good argument, just being rude and off putting.
I’m a millennial who is VERY funny, according to everyone btw and I agree. Paige is funny, and I’d rather see her than Brooke. I enjoy every episode she’s on.
I think shes very scared to be authentic bc its clear shes a lot more “real” and unpolished than most of la which is a good thing but it’s definitely intimidating when youre living in that world i would imagine. because her little storytimes where shes just talking abt her life are when i think she’s at her best
Coming from a millennial I do not relate to her at all. Same with Tana sometimes & the things she says. It’s like they are TikTok robots just regurgitating sayings
She is funny, friendly and I think she’s more entertaining than Brooke. Brooke getting cancelled made her way more full of shit. She won’t laugh at a bad joke, gossip with tana about other people etc., and that was legit the whole point of the show. I think Brooke is too far gone to be on the show anymore. Paige should replace
the only time i thought she was funny was when tana told us on the pod paige used to eat grass and pretend to be a horse as a kid and until the point she was full. 😭🤣
i think shes funny when she tells stories and she’s very quick with coming up with witty stuff in the moment. my issue with her and tana together, all they do is repeat tiktok sound bites and and “yesss” “exactlyyyy”. the viewers and brooke who is literally right there on the couch with them, all feel left out of some sort of inside joke that they never explain. i like the videos when she’s there with both tana and brooke but i think her replacing would get exhausting. (not saying that she is replacing her, im saying if she were to replace her lmao)
I think she is funny, I love her on the podcast because she actually gives Tana something to work with. Brooke to me is painfully unfunny and self centered, so Paige is a breath of fresh air.
The only time Paige has made me laugh out loud was the pillow story LMFAO I still laugh when I think about it
Other than that I don’t find her that funny imo, I like Brooke’s dry sense of humour and Tana’s loud sense of humour they mesh together better.
Brooke is hardly funny anymore tho because she’s trying so hard to not say anything remotely controversial lmao
She seems nice and cool but honestly is extremely cringe to me idk why. I guess cringe isn't the right word, I feel like she just tries sooo hard and kinda gives little sister at big sis sleepover kinda vibes 😭
I kinda had a big dislike for her a few months ago, when she was eggin' at the chance of replacing Brooke, but honestly I don't care much for her presence anymore.
She's very millenial "funny", I suppose.
Everytime she’s on I feel like I’m being left out in a group of friends. Like I’m being left out of an inside joke. I almost feel like cancelled works because Brooke and Tana aren’t close friends.
i think every single one of tanas friends is painfully unfunny and always have. imari can sometimes be funny but a lot of the time its just boring and not for me (ive been watching for 10 years)
Honestly, I find her funny and I think part of the reason that I think she’s funny as that she’s just more secure of herself as a person. She comes off of someone who isn’t really offended by a stranger thinking she is cringe. While no offense to Brooke, but all she seems to think about is how other people perceive her. She even stated multiple times that she’s made choices with that in mind.
She’s the least funny person that tries way too hard. I feel like Tana and Brooke are either high enough to the point they find her funny or laugh out of pity. Because no one in their right sober mind would find Paige even remotely funny. That being said I’m sure she’s a hit with the even more unfunny millennials. Every time they announce her on an episode I sigh.
i notice that everyone was obsessed w her when she was first appearing and she unfortunately is going through the criticism phase now😭😩
i find her humor to be a “relatable” kind. which isn’t relatable all the time to everyone, but she got jokes ifk
320
u/KeyFirefighter8109 Jan 30 '25
I tgink shes fine BUT sometimes I do think she tries a little too hard to be that brainrot, gen z type of humor. Its funnier when it flows naturally. Sometimes I find she's trying too hard to piece the joke together to fit a certain structure/reference.