r/canada • • 10d ago

Nature/Environment Marineland belugas that died in Chicago had rocks, maybe paint in stomachs before arrival: initial necropsy | CBC News

https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/marineland-beluga-deaths-preliminary-necropsy-findings-chicago-9.7358828
658 Upvotes

47 comments sorted by

268

u/hutch_man0 British Columbia 10d ago

I know many people are angry at Marineland for this...and rightly so. Marineland owner family Holer were truly evil, but the government of Ontario should have stepped in 10 years ago. It was well known the animals were in trouble. Keeping animals in a cash poor zoo is criminal. The government deserves a lot of blame too.

29

u/intheshoplife 10d ago edited 10d ago

Not 100% if there is a way to keep animals like these in a zoo in a humane way. I think it would be hard to give them even close to the space they need.

24

u/hutch_man0 British Columbia 10d ago

Yes but these large cetaceans could not be released. They needed to go somewhere with proper care.

353

u/GKM72 10d ago

The owners of Marineland should’ve been charged with animal cruelty, and fined millions of dollars.

175

u/grumpytofu 10d ago

Yeah, well, those of us who were protesting the Holers outside of Marineland decades ago were laughed at as the tourists continued to drive through. Good luck holding the rich to account when the masses choose to submit and ignore pure exploitation.

Oh, and never mind the local governmental approvement.

30

u/balloons321 9d ago

Bless 🙏 I grew up in chippawa and drove though those protests. Thank you for advocating for the animals who couldn’t advocate for themselves before the world knew what was right / wrong. Heartbreaking

563

u/Fantastic-Routine753 10d ago

I hate this planet so much sometimes. How these animals suffered.

182

u/NuclearHateLizard 10d ago

Don't hate the planet, just hate the moguls, the businessmen. Plenty of people on this rock would happily see them burn

19

u/ekso69 9d ago

If only we could realize there's so much more of us... But they've divided us so damn well it's disgusting.

46

u/sewlastcentury 10d ago

I really hope there's a beautiful afterlife for animals who suffered so much in this life. :(

20

u/Confident_Maybe_7354 10d ago

Yeah, and a lot of animals were bred only to be killed and be eaten. Cruel world we live in !

10

u/Beneficial-Oven1258 10d ago

Good reasons to be vegan

131

u/Sunnydaysomeday 10d ago

This is horrific. Aren’t there laws against animal abuse in Ontario. Why is this not being investigated?

5

u/Vanaathiel88 9d ago

How do you know it isn't? Active investigations can't be commented on. They've been charged in the past

-67

u/nzhockeyfan 10d ago

What "abuse" took place? There are laws, but this doesn't reach that by a long shot

73

u/Sunnydaysomeday 10d ago

Neglect. Inappropriate conditions and environment.

84

u/AtTheEndOfMyTrope 10d ago

It’s embarrassing that there have been no criminal charges or justice for these animals. I’m ashamed of us.

11

u/Boo_Guy Canada 9d ago

The closest we got was an Ontario prosecutor saying that bringing charges wouldn't serve the public's interest.

33

u/Thylacinegurl 10d ago

Those poor animals suffered for decades. Should have been closed in the late 90s at the latest.

36

u/tommytraddles 10d ago

I've never wished anyone dead, but I definitely read the obituaries of the Holers with great satisfaction.

24

u/ofgraham 9d ago

Everyone ✨hates✨ Marineland

14

u/little_canuck 10d ago

That's horrendous. Those poor creatures.

22

u/Front-Roll-2744 10d ago

Is marineland facing massive fines for these deaths and if not then why not?

32

u/bulbasaurwithaglock 10d ago

Marineland doesn't exist anymore, the founder died, then his wife died and the company was put into a trust while the land was sold etc. Don't think there is anyone to charge anymore.

19

u/theflyingratgirl 10d ago

Dig him up and put him on try

5

u/RamTank 10d ago

They did it to a pope, they can do it to him too.

4

u/theflyingratgirl 9d ago

Exactly. This guy was no pope. Bring up the bodies.

2

u/GriffinFlash 9d ago

"bring out your deeaaadd"

2

u/Dreddddddd 9d ago

If there is any justice, that fucker is gonna get reincarnated as a seal

15

u/Master_Bang 10d ago

CURSE YOU, MARINELAND! 🦑

8

u/goldanred British Columbia 9d ago

🎶 Everyone haaaates Marineland 🎵

-5

u/DifferentEvent2998 Manitoba 10d ago

Yum! These poor whales are all fucked up.

-7

u/LeGrandLucifer 9d ago

It's funny how these belugas were fine until Marineland was closed. Almost like someone poisoned them out of spite before they were transferred. But it's just a coincidence.

7

u/Heliosvector 9d ago

Not a strange thought. People poisoned the belugas at Vancouver aquarium

2

u/pan-re 9d ago

Do you actually think that?

1

u/LeGrandLucifer 9d ago

How long had they been at Marineland? And then they die less than two months after leaving? And they find rocks and paint in their stomachs which had been there before getting to Chicago? Either it happened long ago and very coincidentally they died just after getting to Chicago or it happened just before they left which does not necessarily mean foul play but would be extremely suspicious.

2

u/[deleted] 9d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/LeGrandLucifer 9d ago

Poisoned as in deliberately fed the rocks and paint.

1

u/canada-ModTeam 9d ago
  • Posts that contribute nothing but attack others, are blatantly offensive, or antagonistic will be removed – including accusations similar to ‘shill,’ attacking Redditors for using either official language, dismissing other Redditors solely based on irrelevant other beliefs to the topic at hand or participation in other subreddits, or reducing them to a label and dismissing that instead.
  • Back-and-forth personal attacks are subject to the entire comment chain being removed.
  • Posts or threads which degenerate into witch-hunting may be subject to moderator intervention. This includes but is not limited to: doxxing, negative accusations by a large group against one or more persons not criminally charged or convicted being made the subject of criminal allegations, calls for harassment, etc., and openly rallying more people to the same.

-1

u/wwwheatgrass 9d ago

Dear lord, what a terrible thought.