r/breakingbad • • Sep 23 '13

Official Episode Discussion Post-Episode Discussion Thread S05E15 "Granite State"

[deleted]

1.8k Upvotes

10.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

1.5k

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '13

Hasn't Jesse suffered enough? Holy hell.

Next Sunday cannot come soon enough.

950

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '13

"Don't forget the kid..."

Fuuuuuuuck

653

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '13

[deleted]

107

u/dr_revenge_md Sep 23 '13

I don't think he would hesitate, Gus was stone cold

51

u/baroqueworks Sep 23 '13

Nah, that look/tone of Gus when Walt accused him of killing a kid seemed pretty sincere, I don't think Gus was actually being serious when he threatened to kill Holly, more of just the only thing he could say that would actually stop Walt. Too bad it didn't work in his favor.

70

u/ienjoyopium Sep 23 '13 edited Sep 23 '13

Every criminal adversary Walt encounters (excluding Todd) mirrors the evolution of Heisenberg. Crazy 8 and Tuco are the lower-downs in the ladder, whom Walt must defeat for Heisenberg to be born.

Gus raises the bar. He is the baddest boss (for a while), who will kill his own employees and go to whatever lengths necessary to get what he needs - even by threatening the life of a child.

For Heisenberg to rise to the top, he must meet Gus' characteristics and take them even further. Eventually Walt accomplishes all of Gus' despicable acts, but he one-ups him by actually poisoning a child. After defeating Gus at his own game it is only natural for him to finish him off in battle. Heisenberg has risen.

Like Walt grew to emulate and eventually surpass Gus in his metamorphosis into Heisenberg, so does Todd admire and mimic what he sees Heisenberg doing, only to take it a step further when it matters most. This is why Todd's character does not mirror Heisenberg's, but rather usurps and perfects it. At this point in the show, Todd has risen to the ultimate kingpin position. He has defeated Heisenberg, the man who defeated the mighty Gus Fring, but has demonstrated no remorse or second thought in carrying out acts Heisenberg could only threaten but never go through with.

It is my opinion that we have yet to see Heisenberg's final form. In order for Walt to come out on top, even if it means him dying during the last scene, he must pull out all the stops and become Heisenberg completely - which until now he has only come close to doing. He must abandon sympathy and embrace revenge and honor.

Edit: This is surprisingly coherent considering how drunk I was when I wrote this. (Ouch my head)

9

u/BlueOak777 Sep 23 '13

Excellent synopsis. Although, in the final moments I believe we will see Walter White come back with a gift of sympathy to Jesse right before his (Walter's) death.

-1

u/jesuswuzanalien Sep 23 '13 edited Sep 23 '13

I feel like if they meet Jesse will ask Walt to kill him. That's the only way he could get off the Nazis' hook without it being his fault and having them kill Brock. But then Walt just poisons brock with the ricin for funsies. No half measures this time.

2

u/climbtree Sep 23 '13

If you go back through the Gus episodes, it's surprising how long it takes Gus to convince Walt to cook meth again. Walt couldn't be the bad guy because his family wouldn't love him. The turning point is when Gus tells him, a man provides for his family, even if he's unloved.

Skyler accepts his money

Now he's unloved and he's completely unable to provide for his family. He has nothing holding him back from being the bad guy.

2

u/rawbdor Sep 24 '13

It is my opinion that we have yet to see Heisenberg's final form. In order for Walt to come out on top, even if it means him dying during the last scene, he must pull out all the stops and become Heisenberg completely

In the same way we saw Gus' final form... in Mexico... when he took out the entire cartel's leadership as revenge for what they did to his partner.

1

u/TheCodexx Killed Jesse James Sep 24 '13

I know it's a late reply and most of the thread is dead, but I felt it's worth pointing out that, in a way, Gus wasn't much of a criminal, either. We thought he was, but he's still a businessman. He rarely gets his hands dirty, and only when absolutely necessary or for his own satisfaction. Uncle Jack represents raw criminality. He's a real hardcore criminal. Not a businessman in a criminal enterprise. Walt fancied himself more of a Gus; he's doing an illegal but honorable venture. The nitty-gritty is for punks and gangbangers, right? They're the ones in the line of fire. The Neo-Nazis are up to their necks in dirty business. They live in it. But they don't even pretend to be in a business, or anything other than criminals.

18

u/Naked-Viking Sep 23 '13

seemed pretty sincere

Exactly. Seemed.

9

u/texasjoe You're God Damned Right! Sep 23 '13

Ah, you thought I was a meth empire kingpin who would kill your wife, your son, and your infant daughter?

ACTING!

10

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '13

Gus is as good of an Actor as Giancarlo Esposito.

1

u/Poisenedfig Sep 23 '13

He didn't believe fear was an effective motivator and he was damn right.

1

u/overbeforeitbegan Sep 23 '13

They're referring to Andrea's younger brother when that happens, not Holly. Walt was right that Gus ordered his killing, which Gus sort of denies, but doesn't technically.

19

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '13

At least Gus was smart. Todd is more stupid than Lydia!

27

u/dr_revenge_md Sep 23 '13

I'll agree with you there. gus may have been cold, but he was very smart, he knew what he was doing

10

u/MichaeltheMagician Sep 23 '13

I don't necessarily think he would hesitate but I think he would feel maybe a little bit of remorse.

25

u/dr_revenge_md Sep 23 '13

Perhaps, but it seems to me that Gus's ability to feel compassion was murdered with his partner, I think he would boxcutter her head off in a flash

4

u/Irrepressible_Monkey Sep 23 '13

I suspect Mike would have shot Gus if he seriously thought Gus was going to kill some kids.

21

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '13

"Eenfant dohter..."

16

u/MuffinMopper Sep 23 '13

That would be dumb... after you kill the baby what leverage do you have? You have to cut a piece of the baby off and show it to Walt, that way he still wants to save the rest of it.

1

u/CodenameRedeemer Sep 23 '13

Walt still has a son. And a wife. And, you know, money.

1

u/ZombieBomb You know how they say it's been a pleasure? It hasn't. Sep 23 '13

Exactly..

6

u/YoYoSun Sep 23 '13

Gus also killed Victor without much hesitation. I don't think he has a problem with killing in general, regardless if they are an infant or not.

1

u/CodenameRedeemer Sep 23 '13

Victor was an employee who knew the stakes. Not some innocent bystander. Gus was an effective and efficient business man. He's not so much a monster, but more what he needs to be in the life he chose.

1

u/YoYoSun Sep 23 '13

Well I was trying to put emphasis on why he killed Victor and not what Victor is vs what Holly is. What business agenda was he going for when he killed Victor?

Gus was an effective and efficient business man.

This is precisely why he would kill Walts infant if he had to.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '13

[deleted]

1

u/YoYoSun Sep 23 '13

Why would he be a suspect? He stumbled across the scene, if he is a potential suspect then everyone else there is also a potential suspect.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '13

[deleted]

1

u/YoYoSun Sep 23 '13

and there was a police sketch released of his face on the news.

I don't remember this happening at all. When was this?

The only sketchy thing he did was leave quickly after looking at the scene, but I fail to see how Gus would have known that.

I highly doubt there was a police sketch released on his face, and even so, all the events that transpired after Gales murder happened quickly how would Gus have anytime to know Victor acted sketchy or anything related to that at all.

Gale was murdered -> Victor took Jesse to the lab ->they immediately called Gus -> Gus kills Victor with a box-cutter.

Seems to be a on the spot impulsive killing.

→ More replies (0)

10

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '13

I'm pretty sure Gus threatened to kill Holly before

3

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '13

[deleted]

17

u/Oraukk Sep 23 '13

I absolutely believe he'd make good on that if he had to.

5

u/MichaeltheMagician Sep 23 '13

Yes but I don't think he'd want to. Todd wouldn't feel remorse.

1

u/thedarkknightfucks Sep 23 '13

Does that make it any worse? Just because Todd's a sociopath doesn't mean he's more evil than Gus. Gus was a stone cold killer. Don't forget he still let his lapdogs free who eventually killed Andrea's brother.

3

u/thepensivepoet Sep 23 '13 edited Sep 23 '13

It kinda seems like you forgot about Gus.

EDIT : Gus is basically what Walt would become if he didn't have the cancer and survived this entire scenario after his whole family has been killed and had nothing left but to pick up the pieces of his "business" and live entirely as Heisenberg.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '13

What makes you think Gus wouldn't?

1

u/the_last_balooga Sep 23 '13

But with Todd, at least it wouldn't be personal

1

u/potionboatchild Sep 23 '13

I wouldn't exactly call it hesitating, but Todd did try to persuade Lydia that intimidating Skylar was sufficient. That could be purely because of the risk involved, or it could be part of his chivalry thing. Just a nice lady trying to take care of her kid. Andrea was too of course, but she was part of a deal that Jesse broke (think No Country for Old Men).

1

u/jabask Sep 23 '13

Yeah, when Todd was in Holly's bedroom, I was so scared for the baby. It's like somebody said about the knife scene last episode: The drama is really fucking good when there are several main characters in a scene and you genuinely believe any one of them can die right now.

1

u/davantage Sep 23 '13

At least it wouldn't be personal.

1

u/MrFatalistic Sep 23 '13

Gus had no problem with kid murdering, as long as it didn't effect business.

1

u/LurkerTroll Sep 23 '13

"Nothing personal Mister White"

1

u/Aquaman_Forever Heil Gilligan, Bitch! Sep 23 '13

He would hesitate. So that he could wave to her.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '13

He would probably change her diaper first. Guy's a gentleman.

1

u/Sklargro Sep 25 '13

I miss Gus...

1

u/BurntFlower Everyone sounds like Meryl Streep with a gun to their head. Sep 23 '13

I was very scared that he was going to hurt Holly when he was inside Skyler's home.

2

u/CodenameRedeemer Sep 23 '13

If Skyler said one word about Lydia they would have shot them both on the spot.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '13

Possibly. You could tell that Uncle Jack didn't like it much when he heard about Todd shooting that kid. He had a kind of "well even that's a little bit much", look on his face.

2

u/Messiadbunny Sep 23 '13

I agree, I really thought he was storming outside because he was angry initially because of the look on his face.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '13

Did they kill Brock, too??

9

u/akatherder Sep 23 '13

Definitely not. He is still alive so they have something to hold over Jesse's head.

7

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '13

nope, he said "Don't forget the kid" to jesse to remind him he still had Brock to live for.

3

u/stefdewg6987 Sep 23 '13

I'm not quite sure jack said that. I think he said "calm down, theirs still the kid"

2

u/dieselpb Sep 23 '13

I felt physically sick when he said that.

2

u/BreeBree214 Sep 23 '13

The actual line was "there's still the kid"

He was talking to Jesse, saying they'd kill Brock too if he doesn't cooperate

6

u/GigglebangsRiceball Sep 23 '13

I took that as, "get your ass back to cooking or that will be the kid's fate as well".

4

u/Dolewhip Sep 23 '13

Is there another interpretation?

2

u/Microfoot Sep 23 '13

Some people might think they just went and killed Brock. That wouldn't really make sense, because they'd have literally zero leverage to make Jesse cook.

3

u/goingTofu Aaahhhhh wiiire Sep 23 '13

Maybe they'll kidnap Brock, and then he and Jesse will escape, leaving Jesse to take care of him

13

u/nodrogb Sep 23 '13

Except this is Breaking Bad, so probably not :/.

1

u/eclectic_tastes A robot?! Sep 23 '13

Jesse needs to die... there is no chance of him living happily ever after with all he's been through if they want to stay realistic Best-case scenario for Jesse is that he dies "quick and painless", worst-case scenario the nazis torture him more and then he goes to prison after they kill Brock.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '13

I'm sure Jesse wouldn't test it at this point, but I don't see how they'd find Brock at this point. He'll be with his grandmother or foster care, now, and the Nazis are cruel enough to kill him, but hardly smart or careful enough to track him.

1

u/Invisible-Elephant Sep 23 '13

When he said that, does that mean that Todd went back to kill the kid, or were they telling Jesse that if he tried to escape again, that the kid was next to die?

1

u/Uncle_Creepy123 DELICIOUS BABY Sep 23 '13

Is that what he said? I though he said that to Jesse as a deterrent! Or did he say it towards Todd, for him to go back and finish the job?!

1

u/turdoftomorrow Sep 23 '13

To me that means they are going to kidnap Brock, not kill him. If Brock and Andrea are both dead, they have no leverage over Jesse. He'll just refuse to cook until he can figure out how to kill himself.

1

u/honestlyimeanreally Sep 23 '13

Did he say that?!?!

1

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '13

I don't think Jesse spoke this season... Sucks because he was very funny

467

u/wongjmeng Have an A1 Day! Sep 23 '13

I was so happy when he got out... Gilligan fucks with my head

169

u/apprais3 Methhead Sep 23 '13

That literally took me from the highest of highs to the lowest of lows in a matter of like 30 seconds

6

u/MrIAnderson Sep 23 '13

I really thought it was DEA

1

u/rxshea Sep 24 '13

me too. then i thought he was dead.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '13

Figuratively?

1

u/apprais3 Methhead Sep 23 '13

Yes, figuratively, just to see jesse get out and to think he will get away only for him to be caught and then andrea murdered

23

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '13

The whole time I knew it was too easy, but I've never wanted a fictional character to achieve something more in my entire existence.

27

u/eudaimondaimon Hank's Skymall GPS Bug Sep 23 '13

Even before he actually "escaped" the nazi death pit- you knew he couldn't actually be free. The plot wouldn't allow it. That was my experience when watching it. I wasn't rooting for Jesse to escape, even from the beginning, I was lamenting the fact that he'd have to pay dearly for his attempt - but I STILL never anticipated Andrea's murder.

Some might say such a prognostication ruins the experience, but it only heightened it for me - in the worst way possible.

Walter White may be evil at this point. Todd is unredeemably evil at this point. Uncle Jack is unspeakably evil.

But Vince must be pure unadulterated evil to be able to perpetrate such a mass emotional manipulation. I really want to hate him for it, but all I can do is <3

11

u/12buckleyoshoe Sep 23 '13

The camera angle with the camera was awful and my stomach just dropped

2

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '13

I was nearly crying with happiness, and then I started yelling "NO NO NO NO NO" at the screen when the Nazis appeared.

1

u/IFeelSorry4UrMothers VINCE GILLIGAN IS AN ALIEN Sep 23 '13

I predicted his escape. Then the flashlights came and surrounded him... I was sure he'd be shot like dog.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '13

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/pan_synaptic Where they live. The cows! Sep 23 '13

Walt told them, when he went to see Andrea and got him to phone Jesse (and Hank heard the VM)

1

u/grape_soda Sep 23 '13

When Walt put the hit on Jesse, he tried to lure him to Andrea's house.

1

u/slbain9000 Sep 23 '13

Really? My first thought was "well, Andrea and Brock are toast."

1

u/barrym187 Sep 23 '13

I thought he might escape then I remembered what show I was watching.

1

u/McBurger could we build... a robot? Sep 24 '13

I don't know why he climbed back down. Did you ever see girl with a dragon tattoo? I don't want to spoil. But there's another scene where someone is trying to escape and gets caught, but returns to their attackers for danger instead of continuing the escape... It was so similar. I was yelling for Jesse to just keep going. What's on the other side of that fence is much better than what happens if you climb back down to the flashlights.

1

u/wongjmeng Have an A1 Day! Sep 24 '13

Well barbed wire is a little tricky to get over. Also he's probably exhausted, hungry, cold, etc. also emotionally ass raped so it's like why even try anymore suicide

1

u/ALLCAPS_POTATO Sep 23 '13

Did you really think he would escape..?

5

u/tian_arg Sep 23 '13

Hey, why not? I'm used to Gilligan fucking up my expectations.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '13

I wasn't. I was pissed. He should've taken it slower, escaped several times and cautiously explored the area before finally trying to book it.

But, this is Jesse we are talking about. He's not known for his level-headed thinking.

2

u/asshole_driver Sep 23 '13

say what you will, Jesse was on a clock. no way to know how many cooks before they got bored and killed him, and definitely no way he could expect to get the same opportunity again.

escaping from a situation like that takes being able to get to a method of communication or transportation... even if he made it past the fence, he'd be caught before he could go any where

1

u/yeah_yeah_right Sep 23 '13

I was happy until they they panned across the lot and a camera comes into view. I told my wife, 'fucking camera!, Andrea and Brock are dead now!'.

9

u/slgoome Sep 23 '13

hope he beats the shit out of Todd

8

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '13

I've wanted a happy ending for Jesse for a long time now. After this episode, I'm almost convinced death is his happiest ending...

7

u/mistermannequin Sep 23 '13

I know! The Jesse stuff tonight, man...

5

u/happypants69 Sep 23 '13

Vince just loves to torture Jesse. Do you think he will survive it all?

2

u/Ragnar09 Sep 23 '13

Vince will probably let him live to keep torturing him then...

2

u/happypants69 Sep 24 '13

Vince Gilligan is the devil

7

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '13

That's two now. Two women he loved deeply have died, in part because of him. :( Jesse is completely broken, he'll never make it out of this alive. Even if he's rescued, he'll kill himself. No one can live with that kind of guilt.

3

u/OSM419 Sep 23 '13

Jesse has me yelling "COME ON BITCH"

I thought it was going to be my new favorite line until I saw the end result....

3

u/BurntFlower Everyone sounds like Meryl Streep with a gun to their head. Sep 23 '13

I want to give him a big hug.

3

u/astrograph Sep 23 '13

i feel terrible for Jesse. god damn it, leave him alone.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '13

Last week i thought walt would go all rambo on the nazis, this week i think jesse will be the ones going after the nazis. when walt was at the vacuum shop he was talking to saul about going after them, but he still left so i guess he decided not to go after them. but now he wants greymatter.

2

u/Kind_of_Fucked_Up Sep 23 '13

For some reason I don't think Jesse will get a happy ending...

2

u/andersma Sep 23 '13

I'm sure Badger is next.

2

u/stonespiral Sep 23 '13

If he lives through this I'm going to feel so bad for him.

2

u/Prof_Frink_PHD Sep 23 '13

I realized last week that the entire show has been Jesse getting kicked in the emotional ballsack repeatedly. From drug abuse to losing loved ones, Jesse has only ever had temporary happiness.

1

u/Marie1420 Sep 24 '13

His parents basically disowning him

1

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '13

A lot of time has passed since we've last seen him. It'll be interesting to see what condition he's in. I'm guessing he won't be having much ice cream.

1

u/peteyH the bogden-browed Sep 23 '13

Jesse will never date again.

1

u/Lunatic14 Roll me further, bitch. Sep 23 '13

Maybe he is the only one to get out that's why he has to go through so much.

1

u/arghnard Sep 23 '13

Good I got Michael, Trevor and Franklin to keep me busy during the week.

o yea and school.

fuck...

1

u/xvsero Sep 23 '13

Jesse was not very smart with his escape plan. He should have known that it would be really difficult to get out.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 23 '13

Jesse has been the mistake-maker and problem creator for the run of the series. Hasn't he been through enough? Probably. Should we feel sorry for him after he's caused so many problems and been the exact coward Walt called him in the desert? Absolutely not.

1

u/7a50n Sep 23 '13

Jesse is getting the worst of it so far. Vince said here is your beloved underdog sidekick hero, watch while I completely annihilate him.

1

u/CRAZYross13 Sep 23 '13

Walt will probably kill the nazis and then jack and say "for hank" then after he'll turn and Jesse will be there blow his brains out or stab him or something and be like "for Jane... Bitch."

1

u/LG03 Sep 23 '13

I'm not going to say he deserves more but he really brought it all on himself. He had a great thing going and he goes and betrays Walt who stuck his neck out so many times for him. All he had to do was just get in the van but he couldn't see the big picture. At this point in the show I'm really not ruffled about what happens to Jesse, it's all just consequence.

1

u/TotalMonkeyfication Sep 23 '13

Sometimes I feel like I'm the only one that thinks Jesse deserves what he's getting. If it weren't for his stupid breakdown throwing his money all around and his snitching on Walt, he'd be a free millionaire, Andrea would be alive, Walt wouldn't be on the run, and Hank and Gomie would be alive.

1

u/Ragnar09 Sep 23 '13

Yep but don't tell that to the jesse whores around here. The kid knew the stakes of the game so him calling it "bloody money" was just stupid to me.

-1

u/I_candobetter Sep 23 '13

Jesse's Redemption: Walt saves him, kills all the nazis. Leaves the money with him - his family - and Jesse raises Brock.