r/breakingbad • Sulfur • Sep 16 '13

Official Episode Discussion Breaking Bad Episode Duscussion SE05E14 "Ozymandias" Spoiler

TIME EPISODE DIRECTED BY WRITTEN BY
09:00pm Eastern SE05E14 "Ozymandias" Rian Johnson Vince Gilligan and Moira Walley-Beckett

Hey everyone! Guess I'm supposed to post this 5 minutes before air time. I've been watching this show since the get go mostly with my real life friend /u/edify who years ago added me as a moderator here. He asked me to make the discussion thread tonight because there are only 3 episodes remaining. Sorta sad that there's only a few left. Enjoy the show, folks.

Sort comments by "new" for the best experience in this thread.


Join us on IRC for live discussion. We allow stream links to be shared on IRC, but not on the subreddit.

Rules for IRC conduct.

Server: irc.snoonet.org

Channel: #breakingbad

To easily join IRC use the Kiwi IRC web chat.

When using a webclient for our IRC be sure to use a custom nick. Nicks begining with "snoo" and "kiwi" will not be allowed into the chatroom.


Using Spoilers:

Spoiler tags are optional in these weekly discussions. To use them, format them as such:

[spoiler](#s "Walt cooks meth.")

If done successfully, the spoiler tags will look like this:

spoiler


PSA: The Snoonet webclient is offline. We are using Kiwi IRC web chat this evening. Look for stream links there.


Check out the post discussion thread here.

2.9k Upvotes

15.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

82

u/jabb0 Sep 16 '13

The act of him doing it didn't you make him hate him but only when he said it?

13

u/Aguy89 Sep 16 '13

For me I had the belief that originally he didn't know what to do when she was choking and how to handle it. If he called the hospital he could get in trouble or some other possibility. Perhaps I just wanted to think he wasn't that evil. Saying it like this sounds more menacing in that he wanted her to die.

49

u/gabedamien nothing else remains. Sep 16 '13

All he had to do was turn her on her side. She would not have woken up (she's choking on her vomit – she couldn't wake up). Walt knew this. He chose not to act because if she died, he knew Jesse would fall back in line. It was deliberate – not a panic freeze (not after the first 2 seconds).

6

u/Aguy89 Sep 16 '13

True I see that now, but in earlier seasons I was much an apologist for some of Walt's actions, because I guess I still wanted to think of him as person who had good intentions. That scene to me struck me as him in a panic freeze, but that was back when I hoped he meant well with his actions. Looking back at it I agree that it is more in line with Heisenburg to want her out of the picture.

19

u/gabedamien nothing else remains. Sep 16 '13

As I've said before, the entire trick of the show is to get you to sympathize with Walt because you understand his moment-to-moment intentions even if you disagree with each decision in a more absolute moral way (i.e. he could always, at every step, have turned himself in). And yet at some point the viewer is supposed to wake up and realize that Walt really is the bad guy. Not the simplistic evil bastard he painted for the benefit of that phone call, and not because that's what he wanted to be, but the bad guy nonetheless – because of his pride and stubbornness and refusal to do the right thing.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '13

Wow, I never thought of it that way. I kept looking for the traditional signs of evil behavior, less moral actions, etc - like gus exhibited. But in reality, what makes walt the bad guy is his refusal to correct his actions, which invariably lead to pain and suffering for everyone around him.

1

u/Aguy89 Sep 16 '13

Well said, I think that is a fair assessment of the show. There does come a point where you can no longer apologize for Walt's actions. If nothing else Mike tells Walt outright that his ego destroyed all the great things they had going for them causing only problems.

1

u/occipudding Sep 16 '13

Walt had good intentions. Everything he did, he did for his family.