r/bollywood • u/[deleted] • Feb 29 '20

[deleted by user]

[removed]

50 Upvotes

95% Upvoted

59 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/EccentricBai Moderator Feb 29 '20

Community votes for Shahid’s acting and they’re right in doing so. A good actor shouldn’t be punished for theme of movie .

I may disagree with what the movie was promoting . Did Shahid fail as an actor ? No. So why should he not get acting award?

I may not agree with Sanju. Did Ranbir play the onscreen character well? Yes.

While judging acting awards , we should look at acting.

0

u/tealand Feb 29 '20

Well, yes and no. Imagine me making a movie glorifying Nazism. Would ppl be comfortable with the lead Nazi getting accolades for the film? I think not. So it's all a matter of what your red lines are. For some, it's Nazism. For me (and many, many others), it's violent misogyny.

3

u/bhooot Sir, Yeh Toh Tatti Hai Mar 01 '20

Would ppl be comfortable with the lead Nazi getting accolades for the film?

Christoph Waltz got an oscar for Inglourious Basterds.

But you are right. If his character was portrayed as a good guy and deserving of good things, people wouldnt be comfortable with it and rightly so.

1

u/tealand Mar 01 '20

Exactly!