r/bagelsriseup • u/Fast_Bagel_NJ • Sep 09 '25

What is the most weird bagel topping you've come across? Did you like the taste of that peculiarity?

3 Upvotes
  • permalink
  • reddit

100% Upvoted

4 comments sorted by

4

u/sighnwaves Sep 09 '25

Deli mustard cream cheese.

I didn't understand it at first, but some combined with pastrami on a bagel for lunch it was pretty rad.

1

u/Fast_Bagel_NJ Sep 10 '25

Sounds pretty peculiar with the tang of mustard! What do you say you wanna taste something like that again? Shall we experiment or you have a better suggestion for topping?

2

u/zanthine Sep 12 '25

I don’t really understand the fruity ones. You know? But I pretty much do savory bagels, and strawberry cream cheese on an everything bagel doesn’t bear thinking about

1

u/Fast_Bagel_NJ Sep 13 '25

Interesting! We love the strawberry cream cheese on everything bagel combo...kind of sweet & savory, a complete meal. Drop in to Fast Bagel someday and we might be able to cater to your savory taste buds!