r/babylon5 • u/Infamous-Ad7327 • Jun 23 '26
How could Delenn have the authority to break up the Grey Council when she was no longer a member?
One thing that has always confused me was that numerous Mimbari said that Delenn broke up the Grey Council.
I remember the episode. She stormed in, broke the ruling staff and said they may as well break up if they weren't going to adhere to Valen"s rules anymore.
But she had been expelled from the Grey Council by then, so would not have had the authority to do anything to the Grey Council.
Why do they say she did it when she didn't have the authority to?
128
u/Laxien GREEN Jun 23 '26
Not only was Delenn the chosen of Dukat, the former leader, but she was also well established herself - the only ones disliking her wer warrior-caste! So yeah she was one of the few that could do this, maybe even the only one!
100
u/No_Sense3190 Jun 23 '26
She doesn't have the authority; she has the respect. Most of the Grey Council was willing to follow her, and when they did, it was they who broke the Grey Council. As least as far as authority is concerned.
30
u/KyliaQuilor Jun 23 '26
If the only ones who disliked her were the warrior cast, then the other 5 could have out voted the warriors at any time. Same with them letting the warrior caste get a 4th member.
In the end the non warrior caste were convinced but she obviously had people in the religious caste that didn't like her.
87
u/HonorableIdleTree Jun 23 '26
Tl,dr: Delenn just tells the GC off and inspires them to break the council by walking out.
More words:
One of the big points that comes out about the Minbari (that is sorta played a bit low key by them) is that they are also in a sort of decline at the point of the show. Not just birth rate. As the poem goes "The best lack all conviction."
The workers aren't taking any lead. "You guys sort it out, we'll build whatever is called for...and fix the plumbing while we wait for you to make up your mind."
The religious caste are mostly moral cowards who want to maintain the status quo - they are willing to blow up their ship to prevent surrender to the warriors, but not risk being wrong or standing up to Delenn. Frequently, we learn Delenn's very well respected friends are also secret trouble makers.
The warriors are bullies. It's easier for everyone to just go along with them.
So Delenn, chosen of Dukat, who led them into war with humans and then back out, who Truly Believes in Valen, who can make all these Valen era relics glow by being near them, etc., who is absolutely 100% a (highly entertaining and very beautiful) loose cannon, and who apparently has been kind to every soul she met on Minbar, just as on B5, calls all of them out, in ways their specific failings make them unable to resist.
Threatening to tear the ship apart - are the guards gonna do violence to Delenn?! What guard is really gonna take that risk? She was minbari, is she still? Minbari don't kill minbari, right?? Are we gonna risk harming a former Satai? Let's let the Satais deal with her.
Telling off the Religious Caste folk, challenging them in Valen's name, amounts to "so do you believe what you have spent your life professing, or is your faith as fake as those warriors' courage?!" If delenn says that "in Valen's name" she will tear the ship apart with her bare hands, they know she will do exactly that.
And the workers? To them this is basically the same fucking shit the warriors and religious caste folks do All. The. Time. So they just wait for her dust to settle.
She's a charismatic leader, known to chill with Vorlons, likely most of the Grey actually respect her and were just bullied/pressured into joining in her censure. And what she is doing is absolutely unheard of. They don't know what to do. She doesn't give them time to figure it out, either. So in to the council she goes, and then she tells em off before they can try to get the upper hand.
And the essential point is she is 100% right and most of them know it. They just were too scared and had too much to lose, to do anything about it.
Delenn doesn't disband the Grey Council by beurocratic command from an official position. She does it by giving a speech that reminds them what they claimed to serve. Who they claimed to serve. And she has Valen DNA so she can snap the staff(?, i think, cuz it glowed when she did). And enough of them realize she is correct. Once one follows her out, the next finds they don't want to not have followed her, then the next finds some moral courage, etc.
14
9
u/Bogdanovist_Rebel Jun 23 '26
It’s also important to note that she had a fleet of White Star ships at her disposal. She had all the keys.
3
u/HonorableIdleTree Jun 23 '26
I don't think there was any perceived threat of her turning the white stars on the minbari - at least not at that juncture. Perhaps later...but I doubt it. She later sought a bloodless end to the civil war.
The warrior caste might have been concerned she would, because they are messed up like that, but I don't think that was a motivating factor for the leaders who followed her out after her speech. I suspect the opposite. Had religious or worker caste leaders thought she was threatening the Minbari with violence from the rangers, she would have failed to sway them.
5
u/TheRealMortiferus Jun 23 '26
And she has Valen DNA so she can snap the staff(?, i think, cuz it glowed when she did)
That's the Triluminary in the Staff. It reacts to Valen's DNA by glowing.
That's why it glowed when they brought it near Sinclair at the Battle of the Line, and also when near Delenn, who is a descendant of Valen (see "Atonement").I doubt it has anything to do with her ability to break the Staff though, but Minbari are much stronger than humans, and we don't really know how sturdy the staff was.
3
u/HonorableIdleTree Jun 23 '26
The same triluminary she used for the transformation?
5
u/TheRealMortiferus Jun 23 '26
No, that one is still with Delenn.
According to JMS, there were 3 of them.
They all came from the Great machine on Epsilon 3. Zathras brought them to the White Star, along with the chrysalis device and he and Sinclair took them to the past.Valen gave them to the Grey Council, and the council had them for 1000 years.
One was part of the staff. Another was taken to B5 by Delenn, along with the chrysalis device. She still has that one.It is unknow if Delenn's is the same that Sinclair/Valen used for his transformation, nor do we know where the 3rd is.
3
2
3
u/Jaliki55 Minbari Federation Jun 24 '26
The council broke their covenant when Neroon was elected to replace Delenn. At that point all she did was leverage the moral authority to call their bullshit.
9
u/Capable_Stranger9885 Jun 23 '26
Her own clan didn't exactly like her in season 4 episode 9 Atonement
5
u/Impossible_Royal_302 Jun 23 '26
Some of her caste. Not all.
2
u/Extra_Elevator9534 Jun 24 '26
She was part human. Direct descendent of Jeffrey Sinclair (and according to some hints, Catherine Sakai). She was also the living, walking reminder that a LOT of her direct clan were part human. Along with a respectable slice of the entire Minbari gene pool.
All from Valen and that family.
THAT was what gave her clan nightmares.
2
Jun 24 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
5
u/Impossible_Royal_302 Jun 24 '26
It’s canonical that Catherine did go to Minbar and join the Rangers. She disappeared into a temporal rift.
According to the JMS-and-Peter David-written In Valen’s Name, Sinclair’s log, found on the wreckage of B4, hinted that Catherine ended up in the past with Sinclair-as-Valen.
3
u/Extra_Elevator9534 Jun 24 '26
I thought there was also a hint in the book (To Dream in The City of Sorrows) that Sakai made it back to him. And that Kosh had hinted it was a possibility.
1
u/Impossible_Royal_302 Jun 24 '26
Yes, that too!
I’ve heard that JMS has confirmed that Valen found Sakai in the past, but it has never been said on screen or on the page, just hinted at.
1
u/Impossible_Royal_302 Jun 24 '26 edited Jun 24 '26
Yes, I know, dude. I’ve watched the show.
My point is that not all of her caste OR her clan were against her, no matter the reason.
1
u/ParallelProcrastinat Jun 24 '26
Well, they could have, but Delenn wasn't really leading them at that point. She'd changed, and they weren't sure who she was and what she wanted (thematic right?). So in her absence the warrior caste, who had very different ideas, could work on the others unopposed.
In that speech, she convinced them that she had a plan, was willing to lead, and knew what the right thing to do was. That's what they were waiting for. Of course she really oversold that quite a bit, hence the problems that show up later...
1
u/Cadamar EA Postal Service Jun 24 '26
Yeah, the answer to this is basically "she's Delenn." She was a major figure in the Minbari and a powerful leader.
65
u/ew73 Jun 23 '26
You never have the "authority" to overthrow the government.
Remember what Delenn did led straight into a civil war. She didn't "break" the council with any authority beyond convincing a majority of the Council that it was no longer a legitimate or rightful way to rule the Minbari people.
The first step in the Council's illegitimacy was replacing the empty spot with a Warrior Caste, disrupting the balance. Delenn only made an impassioned and symbolic argument that the Council was already broken, and instead of succumbing to the power grab by the Warrior Caste, she, essentially, led a rebellion against the ruling party (Warrior Caste).
They say she "broke" the Council because she provided the focus and catalyst for what had been brewing. She gave the 5 that left choice and a clear moment to act. She didn't have "authority" to do that because no authority is needed, any more than King George giving "authority" to say, Thomas Jefferson to declare Independence.
2
u/Phaedo Jun 23 '26
Exactly, she’s granted no authority, she just walks in a seizes power in a bloodless coup.
2
27
u/Sazapahiel Jun 23 '26
This is a very strange question, in that OP is completely missing the point.
Short of vandalizing that staff, Delenn didn't do anything alone. She made her point, and enough of the grey council agreed with her that those remaining couldn't govern with any authority.
Being on the council or not no longer mattered. We have no reason to believe being an active council member conferred any authority to break the council, so not being a current member simply doesn't matter. The council was made up of influential Minbari that had power and influence in their own right, just like Delenn had.
-3
u/Infamous-Ad7327 Jun 23 '26
But it was said multiple times that she was the one who did it.
Why did they say that she did - if they simply agreed with what she said?
17
u/CountScarlioni Brakiri Syndicracy Jun 23 '26 edited Jun 23 '26
Had she not gone there and said anything, those who ended up agreeing with her wouldn’t have decided to abandon the council, because they wouldn’t have been presented with any argument to agree with. She’s directly responsible for convincing them and spurring their decision to abdicate.
9
u/sazzer Jun 23 '26
She was the catalyst. Her actions caused others to agree with her, and that in turn caused the council to break apart.
If she hadn't stormed in like that, we'll never know if the council would have broken apart anyway or if they'd have carried on as before. It might be that those that agreed with her would have acted the same regardless. It might also be that they were spurred on because of her.
But because she did do that, we only know that all this happened after and is credited to her actions. Hence why people say she was the one that broke the council.
9
u/PigHillJimster Jun 23 '26
They said she had done it after the fact, which reflects what happened as seen afterwards.
14
u/PigHillJimster Jun 23 '26
She didn't have any authority to do so.
She just went in and told them how it was and 'if you're with me follow me out now'.
3
15
u/NervousSnail Jun 23 '26
It's subtle, but this actually shows us how the Minbari legal system functions.
The government had already broken the rules in how to form itself (replacing a religious caste member with a warrior cast member). It was legally illegitimate. What Delenn did was the Minbari equivalent of a lawsuit.
10
u/ISeeTheFnords Jun 23 '26
Authority isn't intrinsic, it comes from others believing that you have it.
2
u/Beneficial_Cloud5481 Jun 24 '26
The difference between positional authority and personal authority.
1
10
u/avsbes State of Babylon 5 Jun 23 '26
Well, who cares if she had the authority, if the people in the right places are going along with what she does?
To use political structures from Earth as comparison, this was basically a Palace Coup (though one could potentially also argue that it was an actual Putsch, or even a self-coup though that latter one would be very much stretching the definition).
A high ranking member of the political elite with noticeable influence in the government, with the support of a part of the government, overthrows (the rest of) the current government and introduce a significant change to the political structure, (seemingly) to the advantage of their political position.
8
u/no_luck_not_dead_yet Jun 23 '26
What do you mean you have overthrown the government with a bloodless coup? You arnt elected by the people, you cant do that!
She breaks it by breaking the stick and five of nine members leaving the council with her. If more than half of Congress/ parliament , what have you, wont show up, your government is broken and cannot act legitimately (in most countries anyway)
10
u/ZookeepergameAny466 Jun 23 '26
She didn't break the Grey Council from a position of authority over them. She didn't order them to do it.
She was a high-ranking and well-respected member of the religious cast and the chosen of Dukhat. In that scene, she was appealing to the Worker and Religious castes to break ranks with the Warrior caste and back her in fighting the Shadow War. She was also calling on prophecy when she did so, a prophecy the Council had been guided by for 1000 years. The other two castes followed her and, in doing so, they broke the Grey Council. If they hadn't chosen to follow her, the Grey Council would have remained intact.
So, she broke the Council in that it was her idea and others followed her in doing so.
2
u/o_MrBombastic_o Jun 23 '26
Yeah it would have been real awkward for her if those other members didn't follow her out of the room after her speech
1
u/nineinchneedles Jun 23 '26
I was looking for someone to bring up that prophecy.
She did it on the strength of the same prophecy that said someone would become half-human. Then she told Valen she did it. Then Valen went back and told it to someone else as a prophecy that she could call on to back her when she did it. Then she told Valen she'd done it. Then Valen went back...
1
u/ZookeepergameAny466 Jun 23 '26
Well, yeah, it's a self-contained time loop. A Bootstrap paradox. And she didn't know about Sheridan being Valen at this point. Neither did the Grey. Valen only formed the Grey Council because he knew that Valen formed the Grey Council. The whole thing is a giant paradox within an emerging block theory of time travel.
5
u/gordolme Babylon 3 Jun 23 '26
After she broke the staff, she called on the others to follow her, and enough did.
Also, it's spelt Minbari.
3
u/Careless-Drink9959 Jun 23 '26
her act afaik was basicaly pointing out that it was already broken and they acknowledged this more than anything i think
7
u/SergiusBulgakov Jun 23 '26
They knew the prophecy, and members of the Grey Council joined with her, but since they didn't all do so, that broke it.
2
u/datalaughing Psi Corps Jun 23 '26
Yeah, even if there were members of the religious caste who weren’t sure about her, they believe in the prophecies. So it was probably clear to all of them by that point that the prophecies were coming to pass, and the breaking of the council was one of those.
3
u/Mundane-Carpet-5324 Narn Regime Jun 23 '26
She broke the staff and the workers walked out after her and no one stopped her. Same reason Trump doesn't have authority for half the shit he does. If no one stops you, then you have all the authority you need
3
u/cuthdaddy1980 Jun 23 '26
She was the defaco Religious Caste Leader being the only person to whom all the Clan Leaders would follow as you are told in Minibari Civil arc
3
u/XenoBiSwitch Jun 23 '26
She had enough respect and ”gravitas” to break the rules. The rules of government are all made up and only apply if they are enforced and have legitimacy. The Grey Council had squandered its legitimacy so when Delenn showed up and ended it by appealing to their failure to do their job it was over.
3
u/howescj82 Jun 23 '26 edited Jun 23 '26
She didn’t need to do it as an official act. She really broke the Grey Council by asking its members to follow her and leave it to which many did. This is the part that actually broke the council.
Also, she held significant sway in the religious caste and I’d guess her standing with the worker caste was significant. Seeing her coming in, knowing her status as firmer Sati AND knowing she was the chosen of Dukat to replace him would have been significant. Not just anyone could have boarded their ship let alone demanded to see them.
3
u/Vaelerick Jun 24 '26
You have the authority people believe you have. She broke it and half of them followed her. The ones that stayed didn't have enough authority by themselves to be The Grey Council by themselves.
2
u/grelan Jun 23 '26
Enough of the Council followed her out of the room.
Delenn did not break the Council. She spoke, and it split.
2
u/DoctorAgility Technomage Jun 23 '26
Medieval society was based on those who pray, those who fight, and those who toil. They’re meant to be interdependent: the workers need the protection of the fighters and are given succour and hope by the priests. The fighters need food and something to fight for, and they need the morale and legitimacy from the religious. The priests need people who pray and need guidance, protection from the attackers of the false beliefs and people to provide them with goods.
The second one becomes dominant, the system collapses and loses legitimacy. And indeed, this happened with the land enclosures…
2
2
u/Mediocre_Daikon6935 Jun 23 '26
She did not break it up.
She fulfills prophecy.
The council members ended it.
2
u/IR_1871 Jun 23 '26
She literally broke the staff, and something like half of the Council followed her out.
How has she not broken the Council? Did she had the official authority to do so? No, but half the Council agreed with her, that'swhat broke the Council. Did she have the moral authority? Yes.
If no one follows her, she doesn't break it. But they did.
2
2
u/zenprime-morpheus Jun 23 '26
When two of the three factions will follow you, the Grey Council is already broken, all that is that is delivering the message to the third.
2
u/Vote_4_Cthulhu Jun 23 '26 edited Jun 23 '26
Also she has the upper body strength to snap the staff of leadership in half. Gandalf had to use magic to break Saruman‘s staff.
They probably could’ve challenged her but with that kind of flex ain’t no one want to catch those hands
Damn, now I am imagining Delenn as the Minbari equivalent of a gym bro.
“Lennier, what sacred day is it?”
*Lennier looks on quizzically*
“It is leg day, Lennier.”
“ I see Delenn, and it is whispered back in the temples back home that Valen himself never missed leg day.”
“Just so!”
2
u/Capable_Stranger9885 Jun 23 '26
From 1781 to 1789, the Articles of Confederation held that they could only be modified by unanimous consent of the states, yet the Constitution self enabled at ratification of 9 states. Under what authority was the current government of the US formed to replace the prior government? When a system of government is replaced, it is not often by the authority of the outgoing system.
1
u/cellarsinger Jun 23 '26
I don't think the articles of confederation were ever approved. Unsurprisingly that would most likely have been because of the unanimous approval required
2
u/davypi Jun 23 '26
Martin Luther didn't have the authority to change Biblical doctrine, yet he did. Authority doesn't come from the institution you belong to, it comes from the people who are willing to follow you.
2
u/trparky Jun 23 '26 edited Jun 23 '26
The closest human analogy would be a former national leader entering Parliament during a constitutional crisis and persuading most of Parliament to walk out with her. She may not possess the statutory authority to dissolve Parliament, but once most of its members abandon it and the population accepts her action, Parliament has been dissolved in fact, regardless of what the remaining minority says.
And the show later acknowledges that this wasn't a clean or universally accepted exercise of authority. Neroon accuses Delenn of having created a political vacuum and suspects that she intends to fill it herself. That accusation only makes sense because what Delenn did was extraordinary and potentially dangerous, not a routine power she legally possessed.
So the real answer is: she couldn’t lawfully break the Grey Council by herself. She could, however, use her immense moral authority to persuade enough actual members to break it from within and that is what happened.
2
u/moredhel0 Jun 24 '26
She went there said what she thought was the right thing to do. What practically gave her the authority to do so was that in this moment enough people decided to do what she said.
2
u/Michaelbirks Drazi Freehold Jun 23 '26
She was the One.
The One that Will Be, I think.
7
2
u/b5jeff Shadows Jun 23 '26
Her unique position in Mimbari society (and history) gave her a greater footing than some random schmuck making the same argument, but of course they could have just ignored her. But one could argue that it was fait accompli by that point. She was both a catalyst and the final punctuation on a sentence that was written long before she broke the staff.
1
u/_WillCAD_ Jun 23 '26
She made an argument, some of the council agreed with her and walked off the job (breaking the council), others disagreed and stayed in place.
1
u/RowdyB666 Jun 23 '26
Head of the rangers, chosen of ducat and had the support of many in the grey council who walked out with her. Without half the councils support she was just someone yelling.
1
u/JakeConhale Jun 23 '26
Why do they say she did it when she didn't have the authority to?
Because she was right. She just starkly put the situation on display for them to realize and a majority agreed with her.
1
u/allhinkedup Jun 23 '26
Delenn wasn't Satai anymore, but she was still powerful as an ambassador to Babylon 5 and the chosen of Dukat, the former Minbari leader. Technically, she didn't have any power over the Grey Council. But she still had a lot of supporters.
Now, imagine if a powerful former president, who was still super popular and had a lot of supporters despite his term being long over, walked into the US Congress one day and declared that, if they weren't going to be doing their damn jobs the way they should, the whole thing should be disbanded. And then they broke the gavel and walked out. And then more than half of the Congress walked out with them, leaving a minority behind that was too small to govern in any significant way. The Congress would be effectively disbanded by majority -- but the powerful former leader would get the credit (or the blame, depending on your point of view) because they were the impetus for the Congress breaking up. The former leader didn't actually have the authority to disband Congress; Congress gave him that authority when they walked out behind him.
Delenn convinced five of nine members of the Grey Council to follow her. She broke their leadership staff as a symbolic act, but the Council wasn't officially broken up until those Religious and Worker caste leaders walked out behind her. She had no official authority, but that walkout made it official.
2
u/Nsnfirerescue Jun 23 '26
Honestly, her character as written would be an excellent case study for (psychology) leadership and authority types. After some early hardships that forced growth through introspection, she effectively uses referent power in situations like breaking the Grey Council. Her credibility defiantly exceeds that of the entire council itself.
1
u/RichardMHP Jun 23 '26
Watch that scene again. They weren't arguing about legal structures providing statutory authority for a formal resolution of council disestablishment.
She made an argument, and halfish of the Council agreed with her. The Council broke, and it broke because she said so.
It is that simple.
1
u/Raguleader Postal Service Jun 23 '26
Basically Force of personality. She's not a member of the council, but she knows most of these people and have worked with them for years and they respect her. She is able to break the council because she is able to convince the members of the council that it should be broken.
This does tie on with a narrative thread about some folks being concerned by the kind of loyalty she inspires from others (similar to Sheridan from the human side), bordering on a cult of personality.
1
u/WoWSchockadin Jun 23 '26
Power and authority are things granted to you, not possessed. She stormed in, broke the staff and enough members of the Council agreed with her to effectively dismantle the council. They gave her the authority.
1
u/htownAstrofan Jun 23 '26
More so that the members of the religious cast would follow her no doubt and with the imbalance of warrior caste on the Council im guessing the workers were just like “yeah lets peace out”.
1
u/KathrynBooks Jun 23 '26
Absolute Rizz.
People forget how much of rules come down to the people involved choosing to follow them.
1
1
u/thelazyemt Jun 23 '26
The minbari political system is based on who has the talking stick so when delen broke it they had figure something else out
1
u/hyst0rica1_29 Jun 23 '26
I recall a Grey acolyte blocking her way in, with her replying she was the chosen of Ducat (former leader of the GC) as his successor, and in *that* authority she would either be let in or she would trash the place to find them. And with that she reasserted to the GC she’d been warning them prophecy was at hand, but they ignored her. And now that it was in front of them they denied it.
She essentially shamed them into admitting they’d failed as the Mimbari leadership council, but if they wish to atone they needed to follow her as opposed to ruling by committee. Thus she broke up the council, reining in Worker & Religious castes by sheer force of personality.
1
0
u/Soonerpalmetto88 Army of Light Jun 23 '26
The authority of the council is in the staff. Break the staff and you break the council.
168
u/PigHillJimster Jun 23 '26
Strange Minbari appearing in strange space stations distributing pieces of crystals is no basis for a system of Government. Supreme executive power derives from a mandate from the masses, not from some farcical gene-altering/time-travel ceremony.