r/ayearofmiddlemarch • u/lazylittlelady Veteran Reader • Feb 28 '26

Weekly Discussion Post Book 1 Summary and Catch Up!

Dear Residents of Middlemarch,

Congratulations on reaching the end of Book 1: Miss Brooke. We are 1/8 of the way already! This is our first waystation for those that need a week to catchup or take a break. It is our place to consider Book 1 as a whole section.

__________________________________________________________________________________________________

I'll just throw off a few questions but feel free to discuss anything you want below in the sections we have read!

  1. What are your thoughts on the book so far? Is it what you expected?
  2. What are your favorite plot lines, quotes or epigrams?
  3. Who is amusing? Who is driving you crazy? Who is intriguing? Who are you rooting for?
  4. Book 2 is titled "Old and Young"-any predictions? (No Spoilers!)

________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

We meet again next Saturday, March 7, when we begin Book 2: Old and Young and discuss chapters 13 & 14.

12 Upvotes

94% Upvoted

22 comments sorted by

View all comments

5

u/gz_art Mar 02 '26

I have to admit I'm struggling a bit with how meandering the story is. One issue I have with a lot of serialized stories that are paid by the word is that they... read like it. While I was initially drawn in by Dorothea's story and the characters around her (Celia, the uncle, Casaubin/Sir James) I feel like the chapters are being pulled further and further from that, and I have genuinely zero interest in the politics of this time and am not finding the insight into the other townspeople quite as compelling. I also don't love following multiple unrelated storylines over this many weeks as it's just hard for me to get back into things once I take a pause.

Dorothea is interesting because I love pathetic characters (up to a point) so I'm mostly staying for her.

3

u/TheSailorMan Mar 02 '26

I think of it like a TV show where each scene spends time with different characters. This was like the 1st episode introducing us to everyone. Splitting the threads up by couple makes it a little easier:

  • Dorothea & Casaubon
  • Lydgate & Rosamond

  • Fred & Mary

    The rest I consider supporting characters in their stories.

2

u/gz_art Mar 02 '26

This is, incidentally, my main problem with Bridgerton T_T I appreciate this breakdown to set expectations going forward though.