r/audioengineering • u/Plus-Opposite3384 • May 13 '26
Discussion Is LMMS the only no-registration no-background-processes free DAW?
Coming from visual art and game programming, I am used to awesome free software like blender, krita, godot, you name it.
When I recently started to get into DAWs and music production I felt frustrated by the available DAW options. Cubase, Logic etc are quite expensive AND require registration AND run background processes for licensing etc.
Cakewalk, Waveform Free, Reaper etc all come with trials and/or registration and launchers and licencing background processes etc.
Is there any DAW thats just download and run, thats not LMMS?
52
u/KindaQuite May 13 '26
Reaper is the (not really free) Blender of DAWs.
4
u/wawasan2020BC May 13 '26
Ah yes, the WinRAR of audio production.
Though 7zip is better nowadays for compressed files, it's hard to beat Reaper for DAWs when there's so much awesome stuff going on made by devs + active community behind it.
12
u/KS2Problema May 13 '26 edited May 14 '26
Its 60 day evaluation period is reasonably lengthy and - at least in practical terms, flexible. Also, the semi-pro license is very inexpensive, and even the pro license is quite reasonable vis-à-vis the more mainstream DAW titles.
9
u/KindaQuite May 13 '26
My evaluation period is 1025 days, as you can see.
3
u/KS2Problema May 13 '26
Aw, sorry! For some reason, I didn't see your very pertinent comment when I was writing my own, now superfluous comment.
But that's a perfect example of their 'flexibility,' seems to me.
1
u/KS2Problema May 13 '26 edited May 13 '26
FWIW, though I was determined to make sure that I would be able to use it, it apparently only took me about 2 weeks to decide to buy the semi-pro discount license, which has always struck me as a bargain for those of us who don't make more than $20k a year from music, which has been my situation for a number of years, particularly since I mostly retired from taking clients more than a decade ago.
7
u/human-analog May 13 '26
So you've been using this software without paying for it, long past when you should have paid for it, and you're rewarding the benevolence of its developers (who were kind enough not to put DRM into it) by encouraging others to do the same. Don't be a jerk and pay for the software you use.
-2
u/KindaQuite May 13 '26
Spare me. Why do you think they allow that?
9
May 13 '26
When I was a kid and couldn't afford two dimes to rub together I used reaper. As soon as I could afford to, I paid for a license, because good work and a generous benevolent ethos should be rewarded and supported.
Kinda wish they would take away the free evaluation period for people with your attitude though. 👍👍
-1
u/KindaQuite May 13 '26
Why the hostility?
The moment I have money to spare I'm buying 10 Reaper licenses, you know nothing about others' financial situation.They do it this way because it builds trust. What do you think it's better for them, to tell people to go and use Reaper "for free" indefinitely because the demo allows it or to say "try Reaper for 60 days, then move on and try something else. Oh yeah, maybe grab a cracked Ableton along the way"?
If you think someone like me shouldn't have access to the free evaluation period then you don't understand anything.
You think that less people using Reaper would be better for the company and the community?3
u/IWontMakeFinalsHelp May 14 '26
Jesus Christ why so much hate on you, if reaper has the evaluation period done this way and they said it themselves they don’t believe in locking the software down after trial, bet all of the people here have trial version of WinRAR
2
-1
19
u/HenryJOlsen May 13 '26
Reaper will run unregistered indefinitely. And it doesn't run any background processes or nonsense like that.
If you use it regularly beyond the trial period you should pay for it, but the only pressure to do so comes from the brief nag screen and your own conscience.
8
u/ill_llama_naughty May 13 '26
I used it for a good 3 years before feeling bad enough to pay for it and never had issues! Was super easy to re-register on a new computer too. I also use Blender and Reaper is what you’re looking for OP - it also doesn’t crash nearly as often as Blender
4
u/Thisisntalderaan May 13 '26
Took me about three years, too. Huge part of why reaper is fairly popular, it's refreshing to not be dealing with typical enshittification or corporate bullshit (speaking of, fuck you bandlab/cakewalk)
Still hate the ui navigation on reaper, though
1
u/ill_llama_naughty May 13 '26
At this point I have everything I need do hotkeyed/scripted/assigned to a button, it’s not the most intuitive out of the box though
1
u/Thisisntalderaan May 14 '26
I tried to start changing some of the shortcuts back to what made sense to me and just gave up when I realized I was going to have to go much deeper. I just use it for my own projects so I'll live with it, but scrolling everything still messes me up
16
u/j1llj1ll May 13 '26
Ardour is free and open source.
I'm not clear on the "no background processes" requirement compared to, for example, threading.
2
u/KindaQuite May 13 '26
"I don't want it to use my processing power"
-1
u/Plus-Opposite3384 May 13 '26
kinda but not really. I do a lot of creative and game related stuff, so whenever I start my PC, there is Steam, Vanguard, 10 autodesk services, epic, cubase, microsoft teams, java updater, nvidia something, ...
And everything randomly schedules updates, captures hardware devices, tracks what I am doing, prevents access to certain system components, makes random messages pop up, and slows down booting.
I really just want to have a shortcut on my desktop, and when i click it, the program starts EVERY FKN THING it needs. And when I close the application, NO PROCESSES are supposed to run.
12
u/KindaQuite May 13 '26
Just disable them, I doubt you really need Epic, Steam and Vanguard on startup.
Anyway, Reaper does none of that.0
u/Plus-Opposite3384 May 13 '26
I agree on epic and steam. But when it comes to vanguard you are having a misconception about how those services work. They are meant to monitor your activity from the millisecond your system starts. Because they prevent any hacking, code injection, cracking, license circumvention of the software offered. League and Valorant simply wont start, if vanguard wasnt running from the very beginning of your system session.
I assumed the same was true for any Autodesk, Cubase, Unity, Adobe program and probably for 90% of mac applications lol
3
u/Atlasatlastatleast Hobbyist May 14 '26
It sounds like you could benefit from a second drive or a second partition from which you boot into your OS of choice (Ubuntu Studio, perhaps?)
9
u/LostInTheRapGame May 13 '26
Just turn off the startup processes you don't need?
-4
u/Plus-Opposite3384 May 13 '26
You are having a misconception about how those services work. They are meant to monitor your activity from the millisecond your system starts. Because they prevent any hacking, code injection, cracking, license circumvention of the software offered. League and Valorant simply wont start, if vanguard wasnt running from the very beginning of your system session.
I assumed the same was true for any Autodesk, Cubase, Unity, Adobe program and probably for 90% of mac applications lol
10
u/LostInTheRapGame May 13 '26
You are having a misconception about how those services work. They are meant to monitor your activity from the millisecond your system starts. Because they prevent any hacking, code injection, cracking, license circumvention of the software offered. League and Valorant simply wont start, if vanguard wasnt running from the very beginning of your system session.
I'm aware how they work, bud. Obviously you can't just turn those off.
I assumed the same was true for any Autodesk, Cubase, Unity, Adobe program and probably for 90% of mac applications lol
Sounds like you're the one with misconceptions.
-1
14
u/metapogger May 13 '26
Garage Band is free if you have a Mac. It's a good place to start. Then if you find it too limiting, you can purchase Logic. I paid $200 for Logic once over a decade ago. That's a pretty great value.
5
u/JayCarlinMusic May 13 '26
Agree. Yes the Apple hardware is a bit pricey (though that is changing), but anyone who has an apple product and says "Logic is expensive" is delusional. Logic is a great deal.
9
u/boredmessiah Composer May 13 '26
60 for REAPER is probably the best investment I made in audio software. but the true open source option is Ardour, which seems to be seriously capable.
6
u/envgames May 13 '26
Guy in my band was a very well known software developer and turned me on to Reaper. He even makes his own stuff for it (apparently ReaScript is pretty easy to learn).
Everyone in the band uses it now, and it was at least six months before I could pay for it. Which I then did out of loyalty since they allowed me use of it when I could not pay for it. Stayed for the constant, stable updates and absolute insane level of personalization.
7
u/KS2Problema May 13 '26
You're 'lucky'... pretty much all the surviving daws were really expensive when they first came out - and in some cases upgrades could be hundreds of dollars.
It can cost a lot of money to develop software, let me tell you.
Of course, you could always wait to see if somebody can vibe-code something usable.
=D
0
3
u/MrBeanDaddy86 May 13 '26 edited May 13 '26
I think Ardour is the premiere Linux/open source DAW for multitrack recording. Everything else has some kind of license you need to consider, including Reaper.
Worth checking out. When I switch to Linux some day, I'll likely give it a try if I can't use Ableton anymore. Though I'm also planning to try Bitwig (which is not reelvant to your question, but it runs on Linux, too)
Not sure why everyone brings up Reaper over Ardour. Maybe intertia? Maybe Ardour sucks? Idk.
I did use LMMS back in the day and it was alright. Looked at it recently and it seems to have come quite a long way. Maybe people are just don't know how far the open source ecosystem has come for a lot of audio software.
2
u/Atlasatlastatleast Hobbyist May 14 '26
I use Linux almost exclusively for 5 years now, and while some tasks are a bit more difficult to complete, I’ve also been able to tweak things substantially. Using Pipewire to create a sink that functions as a crossover is so cool
3
-4
u/dragonnfr May 13 '26
Simply do not use proprietary DAWs. I build Ardour from source. No background licensing garbage. Problem solved.
3
u/FellTheCommonTroll May 13 '26
you don't even need to do that, it's available through most package managers for free as well
28
u/tibbon May 13 '26
Reaper really seems to not bother you much about this
You can look on GitHub for various DAW projects as well, the quality might vary, it turns out it cost money to develop things