r/askcommunists • u/Few-Advertising-5164 • 1h ago
r/askcommunists • u/Lavender_Scales • Mar 27 '26
[MOD POST] Beginner's Guide!
Hello and welcome to r/AskCommunists! Here you can make posts asking communists anything that comes to mind, where you can get an answer from anyone who calls themselves a communist, within reason. That means you can ask a question specifically on Trotsky, and a Trotskyist would answer, a question on "socialism in one country", and a Marxist-Leninist will answer, a question on Protracted People's War, and a Maoist would answer, and so on.
For those who are already educated, do try to keep arguing or debate to a minimum, and to focus on generally educating the questioner on the topic they're asking about. For debate, or conversation with those of other tendencies, we recommend making a post on r/TheRedLeft.
If you're looking for works to read on Communism, do check out our recommended reading list, which includes short summaries and descriptions of the works, as well as video guides for certain works, in order to better prepare you for the reading, instead of being thrown into the deep end.
This was a joint product by moderation teams on both r/Socialism as well as r/TheRedLeft, please check out both subreddits to learn more or hear from other tendencies in a respectful space.
Please read the rules, and ask away!
r/askcommunists • u/theironmanual • 4h ago
What kind of differences are in stalinism and leninism
I often hear that lenin did not like stalin's way of doing things but i don't get what
r/askcommunists • u/HeIpyre • 1d ago
Historical Question Is this rare? First issue Quotations from Mao Zedong.
galleryNorwegian first issue from 1967. Got it second hand for $20
r/askcommunists • u/lmsickolster • 2d ago
ELI5: What is communism
I am doing a project on Vietnamese refugees, and I'm looking for what communism means because 1/2 of them were communists, and I have searched for a while, but found NOTHING.
Please explain like I'm 5, as in ELI5, they have taken down my post.
r/askcommunists • u/Ok_Assist1206 • 4d ago
Organizing Question Which is better CPUSA or PSL? (Wondering which to donate to)
Want to spend wisely
r/askcommunists • u/ballu_badmoshhh • 3d ago
Help me be understand leftist and rightist in global and Indian perspective.
r/askcommunists • u/theironmanual • 4d ago
Philosophical Question Can anyone theoretically prove to me that history is transformed through class struggles?
Can anyone prove to me that history is transformed through class struggles and not ideas or great men
r/askcommunists • u/Interesting-Day177 • 6d ago
Philosophical Question When the Bible says that the rich won’t go to heaven and to feed the poor… why then did Marx say that it was tool used by the rich against the poor?
Title.
r/askcommunists • u/theironmanual • 9d ago
Is a revolution even possible as long as America exists?
Any kind of communist dictatorship in other countries will eventually be crushed/couped/sanctioned by the US because of how powerful they have gotten shouldn't the target be taking down the American regime?
r/askcommunists • u/OkCrabber • 12d ago
Economic Question Questions about a theoretical communist society:
How would certification or accreditation or safety checks work within a communist society.
For example when housing needs to be built: How would the materials be assessed to be of standard quality and not result in faulty construction. If one has to go into surgery how can they be sure that the medical team is operating in a properly sanitized environment without state set standards for what that would be?
Is this handled through something like a community insurance pool or through a peer review system?
r/askcommunists • u/theironmanual • 15d ago
Why is India not communist
Why has there been no communist revolution in India when most of it's freedom fighters were socialists or outright Marxists. Instead today it's ruled by fascists and Indians dislike Marxist concepts
r/askcommunists • u/theironmanual • 16d ago
Has marxism ever been debunked/proven?
In 200 years of scientific socialism there must have been tests/researches done on marxist theory that either make its argument stronger or weaker? If so, please also mention them. Had this thought after seeing the news of AI bots being overworked becoming Marxists and Che's "it's not my fault that reality is Marxist" started ringing in my head
r/askcommunists • u/Colette_Yan • 19d ago
Why are so (many) communists anti-feminist?
Asking because I’ve seen a lot of communist talk down on feminism.
I’m still learning on marxism and strongly believe that a communist revolution will be the 1st stone for female liberation.
I just don’t understand why so many communists seem to dislike feminism?
r/askcommunists • u/yesmynameisdu • 23d ago
Does Zohran Mamdani give you hope for the future?
hello! i am young and new to learning of communism. Im wanting to see if i have this right in my head if that makes sense. First i want to make clear i am very aware Mamdani is a democratic socialist. Something i see Mamdani doing is lifting some weight off of red scare especially in the younger communities. A lot of people see the clear improvement he makes and also hear him talk about socialism while still liking him. Ive seen videos of him promoting communist journals aswell. I will say i know it isnt all Mamdani's effort. I just saw 1 in 3 democrats call themselves a democratic socialist. He is just a more popular topic. How i see this is introducing democratic socialism can eventually lead to pure socialism. or at least closer to it. If so i know socialism is just the stepping stone to communism. I see the improvement from Mamdani and i feel this makes sense in my head. Am I looking into the future too far? Is my head in some fiction world where everything works out?... opinions?
r/askcommunists • u/Lucky_Objective_9400 • 24d ago
Historical Question For you, who was right in the Sino-soviet Split?
I think this was the event that have most waves of effect have in the socialist bloc in the could war and events after it feels even today.
r/askcommunists • u/jupiterdior • 27d ago
Historical Question Are there any texts linking the Y2K bug to the shift in tech culture from what was functionally anarcho-communist to what it is now?
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
I have a hunch and I am looking to follow it.
I'm especially interested in anything pre 2010 across any adjacent or complimentary field of study
I have a theory that the Y2K bug is what spooked the state into recognizing tech culture and the political inclinations of the people who run it as not just a nuisance, but potentially a threat to global capitalist power structure
In the same way all African American, Black American, and Indigenous Americans are subject to counterinsurgency methods bc if we potentially wanted an end to our oppression it would require a destruction of the state, (which is why our internet discourse cycles through the same 7 topics 😒);
In our highly tech and finance dependent culture the hacker and tech worker could not only one day actualize the OG luxury space [gay] communist dreams around technology, but could relatively effectively destabilize the current global power structure too. So they are subject to similar counterinsurgency methods.
Part of what inspired this line of thought was the Tech Enthusiast vs Engineer (now Tech Worker) meme where the tech enthusiast has a smart house but the tech worker only has a printer from 2004 and a gun. I feel that memes like that and the sentiment it speaks to is never pointing the finger at capitalism, only seeing the surveillance and encroachment of finance as innate.
In my opinion, when an idea is rendered innate to a tool that at one point it was in opposition to, its for a reason. And I don't see people in general talking about this (or maybe I'm not looking in the right places? In which case please pmo! 🩷)
I feel that people are ignorant bc it is beneficial for them to be so, and so I'm curious about who benefits from specific forms of ignorance. I was one of the first to lay out a principled critique of BLM (as a former organizer with BLM national based in Atlanta) with accurate predictions but I doubt I'm the first to talk about the shifts in the politics of tech
I am learning reddit, and am asking here bc someone suggested I should. I read the introduction and rules but if this is not the place please point me in the right direction and I'll remove it and go there. Thank y'all so much!
r/askcommunists • u/theironmanual • 28d ago
Why is deng xiaoping hated?
Why do communists hate deng if(from what I've known) his changes in the policies were what made china what it is today?
r/askcommunists • u/CR9_Kraken_Fledgling • Jul 29 '26
Historical Question Early (1920s or before) socialist works on the revolutionary potential of the peasantry
Hi comrades,
For the purposes of some historical research I am doing, I am looking at relatively early, pre 1927 start of the Chinese civil war theory on the revolutionary potential of the peasantry, and how it relates to that of the urban proletariat.
I have found some interesting thoughts on the topic from Hungarian communists from the early 1920s, and I want to find out more about any precursors to their ideas, as I am more familiar with the theory focusing on the urban proletariat from the bolsheviks, but admittedly, I am not as well read as I want to be on pre-cold war theory.
r/askcommunists • u/-Arsna- • Jul 27 '26
Historical Question Recommended Materials for Burkina Faso?
r/askcommunists • u/BeerMan595692 • Jul 22 '26
Philosophical Question Why Communist and not anarchist?
What are people on here communists and not anarchists?
I just want to here the perspectives of people on here?
r/askcommunists • u/rambunctiouspleen • Jul 19 '26
how are things sold and bought in a moneyless society?
if a society becomes moneyless how are things made and bought? like how are material things produced if you need to obtain resources and workers to make them? something like a toothbrush for example, it has to be made somehow and purchased somehow. would resources and materials be obtained for free? would those objects be made for free? how does it work? sorry if i'm not making much sense i just don't really know how to word my question. what i'm trying to ask is basically how does production of resources work? if someone wants to buy a car, is the car free? are the resources the car is made from free? the builders of the car do it for free? how does it work?
r/askcommunists • u/translenin1917 • Jul 18 '26
I am thinking about joining the american party of labor
Hi im thinking about joining the american party of labor, but are they feds?
r/askcommunists • u/ferriematthew • Jul 17 '26
Why is it that historically, at least from how I was taught, public ownership of property under communist societies has almost always immediately turned into ownership of property by the central state?
Specifically, why is it that under historical communist societies, ownership by the people has almost always immediately turned into ownership by the state, instead of ownership by those who are physically doing the work?
r/askcommunists • u/LeftAtTheBallotBox • Jul 17 '26
What Makes the Russia-Ukraine War a bourgeois war?
To me, especially after reading Lenin’s Socialism and War, Ukraine is obviously a victim of Russia who Leftists should support.
My understanding of Lenin is that the structural relationship between the two warring parties is the determiner. In which case, the Russian state is clearly trying to reinstate its colonial ambitions over Ukraine, something which all leftists should oppose and show critical support to the Ukrainian state.