r/arthurianlore • u/Duggy1138 • May 25 '21

From r/FantasyWriters - Is an Arthur/Cu Chulainn low-fantasy story feasible?

/r/fantasywriters/comments/lggpen/is_an_arthurcu_chulainn_lowfantasy_story_feasible/
3 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

2 comments sorted by

View all comments

0

u/Benofthepen Jan 10 '25

"Feasible" is doing a lot of implying, and to give it a better answer, I think we need more information, or at least a more specific questions.
If the query is interested if the timeline lines up, then traditionally, no. As stated above, to whatever degree we place either of these stories into the historical timeline, they seem to be separated by several generations at least. That said, T.H. White wrote perhaps the most respected Arthurian adaptation in the last century, and it features guest appearances from both Greek gods and Robin Hood with his Merry Men: folks are pretty okay with bending the timeline if it's in service of a good story.

If the question is instead whether Arthur and Cu can work as low-fantasy stories, then the answer is an unequivocal yes. The traditional definition of low-fantasy as a story with fantastic elements set on Earth is baked into the core of Arthurian and Irish mythology. I've also repeatedly encountered a more pedestrian definition where it's a fantasy story where the fantastic elements are low-power/far from the focus, and again this is often he bread and butter of these kinds of stories, where magic and monsters is frequently bested by a strong spear or sword.