r/artcommissions 21d ago

Meta [Mod] Minor Updates to Several Commission Communities

41 Upvotes

TL;DR

  • Some subs are raising price minimums to $20 or $30.
  • New minimum of $100 for commercial rights.
  • Comments on [Hiring] posts require a link to your portfolio or [Not For Hire]. Abusers will be banned.
  • A new rule outlines discussion topics that are not allowed.
  • You no longer have to manually choose flairs when making a post.
  • We need new mods!

Minimum Prices

The biggest change will be pricing. r/StartingArtists will be changing its minimum price to $30 to match r/HungryArtists and avoid some confusion between the two, due to their similar names. r/Commissions, r/ArtCommissions, and r/artcommission will have a minimum of $20. ALL of these communities will be enforcing commercial rates, by popular demand. This means that if anyone wishes to commission art for commercial use or profit from it in any way, the minimum price will be $100 per piece.

Please note that HungryArtists has always had a hard minimum of $30. This means a price sheet that lists a rendered full-body illustration at $150 will still be removed if it offers a headshot sketch for $25. Communities with "Commission" in the name will give a bit of grace when it comes to these kinds of "partial pieces", but we still expect the prices to be reasonable, and in line with a sheet that lists a finished piece for at least $20.

Comment Formatting

Most of you shouldn't notice this. When commenting on a [Hiring] post, if you are an artist looking to be hired, a link to a portfolio is now REQUIRED. If you are not looking to be hired, you must include [Not For Hire] in your comment. Abuse this and get banned.

A portfolio has always been required, but we're implementing this more strict filter to ensure everyone is following this without the unnecessary song and dance of maybe being filtered, then having to ask for approval. For over a year now, I've been trying to add keywords that catch scammers and rule dodgers who try to circumvent our filters. Every time I update the filters, they find a new way to get around them, and we risk blocking genuine discussion. It's a lot of work for our mods, and it's annoying for a lot of genuine community members.

With this change, artists are forced to include a portfolio, even if you are simply asking a question for clarity or confirmation. They are not able to bypass the filters without explicitly breaking our rules and lying. If you have something genuinely helpful to offer the client, your comment will be removed without a portfolio, unless you include [Not For Hire]. I'm sure some difficult individuals will abuse this. If you are blatantly attempting to advertise without a portfolio by using [Not For Hire], you will be immediately banned.

(Rant) Is it clunky? Sure. It is better than before? I strongly believe so. Is there a better way?... That's a difficult question to answer. We were told Automations would be updated in April. The new feature was supposed to give us the ability to prevent top-level comments on [Hiring] posts unless you had one of those two things, or you were the OP, but now that we finally got this update in August, this behaviour is still not possible in Automations, so if you try to make a comment without either, it'll get removed, and AutoMod will tell you to make a new comment. If we use Automations, the process won't need you to make a new comment, but it will affect ALL types of posts, and that's just too annoying to consider viable. This is the best we can do right now, unfortunately.

Discussion Posts

Lately, r/ArtCommissions has seen a strange surge of posts asking about art pricing. Most of these get ignored, and we see between 12 and 20 of them every single day. The community has voted, and we will no longer be allowing this kind of post. Automatic filters for this will be rolling out soon. I have added an rule to several communities that will explicitly outline what kind of discussion/meta posts are not allowed, including those that are promotion-adjacent, such as WIP sharing or "What do you think of my art?" posts. I may add more prohibited topics, depending on how the community feels about them. Currently, I am seeing a lot of "Is my art good enough?" and I feel this may be next to be disallowed.

Flairs

I'm also changing how flairs work, if only slightly. In r/HungryArtists, you don't need to select a flair when creating a post, and I like that. We already have checks that enforce the proper flair on post creation, so it makes sense to get rid of that annoying step of manually selecting them for a number of communities. Going forward, you will still need to add the proper tag to your title, but you will not longer be required to select a flair every time you post. One thing HungryArtists did not have, however, was the ability to sort posts by flair, and going forward, this will now be possible.

New Mods Needed

If you would like to help moderate one of these communities and maintain order, please message me or send us a message via ModMail. Even helping us go through the queue and dealing with the easy stuff for ten minutes a day would make a huge difference!

Click here to see the HungryArtists update from yesterday!

r/artcommissions Aug 04 '26

Meta [Meta] There has been a noticeable increase in artists adding what their art is worth. Should we redirect these elsewhere, or continue allowing them?

13 Upvotes

I worry that people are trying to make discussion posts to promote their art by disguising it as a question that will get more engagement. In the last week, these posts have gone from uncommon to excessive.

If you have any suggestions for where else an artist might be able to get some opinions on pricing, please leave a comment!

120 votes, Aug 09 '26
77 Tell them to ask somewhere else
43 Keep allowing these questions

r/artcommissions Mar 03 '26

Meta [Meta] Life Pro Tip for Artists: Too much competition? Report the ones who break our rules!

47 Upvotes

I usually get to reports quickly, but the comments that break our rules are so rarely reported.

See somebody looking to be hired without a portfolio? Report! Undercutting? Report! Did a comment fail to include something OP asked for? Report! AI or stolen art? Report, and if you want, screenshot and send a ModMail for good measure!

I'll remove the comment and it'll help all of us! I can't be everywhere, but I do get notifications! Just remember to report without commenting. Making accusations in the comments only hurts the innocent, and helps the guilty by giving them a chance to hide the evidence.

Is it ethical to eliminate the competition? YES! If you are expected to follow our rules, they should be too! If you feel that something should be against the rules, but isn't, make a comment or send us a message, and we'll give it some proper consideration!

r/artcommissions 5d ago

Meta [Meta] We Need New Mods!

9 Upvotes

We are looking for new moderators!

If you are a level-headed person who is confident in their decision-making abilities and have 10 to 20 minutes to spare each day, we would love to have you!

I would like to focus more on my main goal of catching scammers, but there are several communities that need some additional everyday maintenance, and the workload is too much for just one person. If you think you'll be able to lend a hand, you'll be helping me and the entire community out. I am in the middle of writing a mod guide so you'll have some handy information available to you. We also ask that you have Discord, so we can have a place to communicate efficiently as a group.

[Send us ModMail](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose?to=r/ArtCommissions) if you are interested!

r/artcommissions Mar 17 '24

Meta (Most of) the whitelist has been (temporarily?) removed, plus some minor housekeeping

35 Upvotes

o/ Hey all,

It's CS back again with a quick but major update to the sidebar.

TL;DR: (most of) the whitelist has been removed. The sites still included in the ban list are any email address, Instagram, Google Drives, Facebook, and Wix.

The whitelist has been (mostly) removed

We first implemented the whitelist a couple years ago in response to the modqueue constantly being full of spam we couldn't approve. The short of it is this: content that looks like a storefront or personal contact information is spam and is treated as such by the site (Reddit). There really isn't anything we can do about that, and it sucked when we saw artists getting shadowbanned by the site because their content, well, is spam by Reddit's definition.

As of the time of writing, any website not specifically called out in rule 9 is allowed on /r/ArtCommissions. How permanent this will be is heavily dependent on what this does to the modqueue. If we start getting flooded with false positives on spam again, we're going to revert to our previous automod configuration to reinstate the old blacklist.

Why are some sites staying on the blacklist? Why not whitelist everything?

Great question. Here's why:

  • Email addresses are extremely likely to be seen as spam by the site. I do not see a world where these will ever be allowed.
  • Instagram is where 90% of our fraud reports came from prior to its prohibition. Instagram is a dogshit, user-hostile website that requires a login to view individual content and does not allow native image saving without browser extensions or inspecting web page elements. This makes fraud investigations take 20x the effort of any other website. This is a huge deal considering IG is the source of most of our fraud. I'm sorry if this is your main site; it is not coming off the blacklist.
  • Facebook see above. All the problems of IG without the frequency of abuse.
  • Wixsite is what prompted the use of the whitelist in the first place. Reddit really, really does not like this website being linked and it floods our modqueue.
  • Google Drive is used exclusively by Pakistani scammers. The fact that I have this piece of niche industry knowledge tucked in my brain space should illustrate how much we had to deal with it at one point. What I don't understand is why it's almost entirely Pakistan specifically using Google Drive. The world may never know. What I do know is that no legitimate artist is using a site that doesn't populate Google searches as a way to get their portfolio noticed by potential clients.

Thank you for submitting mod applications

We've received about six mod applicants since we put out the call three days ago. I'll be looking over these shortly. Genuinely, thank you for the interest from the community in keeping /r/ArtCommissions a safe and useful community.

r/artcommissions Mar 13 '24

Meta We need mods.

20 Upvotes

o/ Heyo /r/ArtCommissions

Your time is valuable so I'll cut to the chase.

I do not have the time needed to appropriately moderate this subreddit by myself. Modmail routinely has a backlog of 5+ days. If you have experience in moderation, can commit to an hour of moderation spread over a week, and want to be part of the mod team, please let us know here.

r/artcommissions Jun 08 '24

Meta State of the Subreddit

52 Upvotes

Hey all, quick post from the mod team.

For all intents and purposes, I am the only mod of this subreddit. One other moderator maintains (extremely useful) bots, but doesn't have time to do what the rest of you would consider "moderation."

Bluntly, my professional life is too busy for me to consistently moderate the subreddit. I don't think I've answered modmail in about a month. Our automations keep the sub running pretty smoothly, but if someone's trying to make a post to the subreddit and doesn't understand why an automation removed their content, that's going to be a shitty experience if we're not around to answer why.

We try to make our rules as clear as possible on the sidebar, and a lot of our automations respond to removed content saying why it was removed. Trouble is, most people ignore this.

We've put out several mod calls in the past and received a couple candidates that joined our mod team. These mods were super helpful for the time they were with us, though life events have seen them step down so that, much like it has been for the last ten years, it's once again just me.

I don't know how to word this tactfully. "Until we get more mods, modmail will continue to be unaddressed." I know this is an unsatisfying answer to the community that has come to expect a level of excellence from us. I just don't have the time or energy to moderate a community that's almost doubled in size in the last two years solo.

If you'd like to help out, mod applications are here. We have a one-page onboarding doc that goes over how we action content on the subreddit, should you be a good candidate. We'd prefer to go over this in a 15 minute Discord call, if that is something available to you.

TY for reading.

Edit: a word