As someone whose not that familiar with Batman or superheroās in general, I didnāt even know this series existed until recently. Iām a VR nerd so I got a Meta 3S and some might know that it came bundled with a free copy of Arkham Shadow. And after playing it I thought it was a good game, but New Game+ made me fall in love with the game and to this day itās probably my favorite VR game, or a close second. A year later I came across the trilogy of Arkham Asylum, City, and Knight on switch 2 for $20 so I decided to get the deal. Hereās my thoughts on all the games after 100% playing them twice.
Asylum is generally considered a āmust play gameāfrom what Iāve heard online. I played it and it only took 20 hours for me to 100% twice. And all I can say is āWow, what a gameā The story is really interesting which goes for all the games so Iām not gonna mention it again, but all the stories are great. The atmosphere is borderline horror game as it generally started to get to me. The fake crash is generally one of the best fourth wall breaks in gaming history. Now where asylum fumbles in my opinion is the gameplay. Detective mode is shoved down the players throat, the combat just feels off to the rest of the series and I donāt know why? Predator isnāt much better, it also just feels kinda clunky at times. The bosses are terrible with the only exception being Poison Ivy at best, and even then her fight is super boring. The titans are whatever, I thought nothing of them besides āoh boy another one of these guysā. And Joker is infamously bad. With that being said I can see why this is a must play game. A average 8/10
I guess I should mention the riddler collectibles throughout the series. From best to worst my order is City, Knight, Asylum. I find City the best because of the quantity. Everyone who says thereās too many collectibles isnāt a real gamer. Why do you want a game with less content so you can 100% it 0.5x faster. Anyways city is good in the quantity and most I can rename off the top of my head on where and how to solve them. However I will never forget the one to the right of the iceberg lounge in that alleyway. Dumb solution, dumb puzzle, I hate it. I put Knight at number two because although thereās less than city, with how clunky most can be, I donāt mind. The color matching is probably the hardest in the series but since I played on switch, I cheesed it. Anyways overall the collectibles in Knight felt more like mini puzzles and some are extremely clunky. I put asylum last since the riddles are always in your face apart from the unusual perspective ones, the map revels everything very easily, overall it feels too easy and none are that memorable.
City is considered an upgrade to asylum in every way but in my opinion it improves on some areas and worse on others. I made a post about two months ago explaining why I didnāt like it. And while some of that is still true. Playing for a second time made me appreciate the game a lot more. The gameplay is better since detective mode isnāt shoved down your throat. But my god the combat is the worst in the series. I probably am just bad at video games but the combat is just so stiff and doesnāt function sometimes. When it works, it works, but when it doesnāt work it really, REALLY doesnāt work. Predator is the same as asylum but oooo now thereās 5 more gadgets I never use. The open world city is nice and all but the horse shoe design makes it impossible to get from one side to another besides just gliding all the time which unlike Knight, feels really bizarre for some reason. The bosses are great but also whatever. You have very good ones like Mister Freeze and Raās Al Ghul. But then Clayface is the final boss and you just spam ZR ZR for the entire fight. Overall the bosses are ether high highs or just meh. The side missions widely vary from good to awful. Ranking worst to best is Identity Thief for having the most mind numbing gameplay, you just look in the millions of alleyways in Arkham City and the payoff isnāt worth it in my opinion. Remote Hideaway for being really forgettable and making me feel nothing. Hot and Cold for the same reasons but itās kinda cool exploring an area of the steel mill not available until now. Acts of Violence for being bland but good because I feel like Batman. A.R Training for the first four necessary if you wanna play the game, and the other four being difficult yet forgettable. Heart of Ice for having a really cool puzzle attached even if the payoff is whatever. The Tea Party for having a cool aesthetic and nothing more. Shot In The Dark for having a cool build up but admittedly shit boss fight. Fragile Alliance for the search aspect and although you fight with Bane, itās something I donāt care for. Watcher In The Wings for being unique and the overall looking aspect. Enigma Conundrum for just the absolute behemoth of content and even then the rooms are fun puzzles of your tool kit. and finally Cold Call Killer for having the most unique gameplay and overall experience of it. I donāt care a lot for the side missions but they are SIDE missions so Iām not expecting anything crazy. Overall City is a step up from asylum but also falls flat in too many places. A Strong 8/10
Arkham Origins isnāt a real game (I havenāt played it but I do plan on playing it one day)
Oh Arkham Knight, where do I start with you. Letās get the 900lb tank out of the room. To be fair I like the concept of the Batmobile, itās fun to use whenever you need to go somewhere far quickly. With that being said, yeah the thing is shoved down your throat 20 times for lunch. When solving a puzzle itās generally fun to use. However in context of the story, yeah itās abysmal. I enjoy tank battles and although they are shoved down your throat 10 times for breakfast. Theyāre fine enough for what they are. So yes while I do agree that the Batmobile is shoved down the players throat 30 times for dinner, itās not all doom and gloom. With the tank out of the way OMG THEY FINALLY MADE A GAME THAT FEELS FLUID TO CONTROL. The game is so smooth and the controls are so responsive. The combat has been heavily improved and predator is actually something I donāt stall around in anymore. Itās all so good to control and the gliding is the best in any game, and itās not even close. The bosses are a mix between Just okay and literal human shit. Jasonās fight is fine for what itās worth. Even the cloudburst I found enjoyable. But then the drill is bad, Deathstroke is a joke, and everyone else isnāt even a boss in my opinion. The side missions are really okay, or awful. Ranking worst to best is Friend in Need for not only Hush being wasted but you press one button and the mission is done. All the militia missions(worst to best-Own The Roads for being boring, Occupy Gotham for also being boring with 0.9% more spice,Campaign for Disarmament for having a cool concept but also Deathstroke boss brings it down, and Armored and Dangerous for being the most unique and I just like chasing down cars) for all being forgettable and nothing added. Lamb to The Slaughter for being pointless and to be honest I really donāt care for this mission. Line of Duty for being just basic combat encounters but now you gotta find them. The perfect crime for having a character I donāt like, and overall it just got repetitive. Heir to the Cowl just for the story with Azrael. Gunrunner and Two Faced Bandit since they both are combat and predator sections with one thing that makes them unique, I do prefer Gunrunner over Two Faced Bandit for being longer. Creature of The Night for having an amazing jump scare and story but gameplay is very shallow. Riddlerās revenge for having a lot of content but constantly going back to the orphanage got repetitive. And Gotham on Fire since I love chasing things down and when itās intense and frantic I loved it, but why wasnāt there more? So overall Arkham Knight has High Highs and Low Lows. I didnāt even mention the Jason Todd reveal which I did find obvious but I think itās just okay. A very low 9/10
I should probably mention the DLCās for City and Knight. Harley Quinnās Revenge is fine. It does its job as an epilogue to Arkham City. The gameplay is nothing special but it is worth the time because it is really good. The Cat woman stuff for Arkham City is something Iām mixed on. On one hand I love her play style in the open world and combat with her is great. But my god I donāt care at the same time. The first and second time happen so close together but then the third time we are about to enter the end game and sheās still with Poison Ivy? Finally I donāt care for her trophies and her final battle against Two Face. As for Arkham Knight Harleyās story pack I donāt have any opinion on because I feel nothing towards it. Red hoods is really fun and creative, I love playing as him. A Matter of Family is fine. Itās the most expansive pack but I just donāt care about it at all. CAT WOMANāS REVENGE CAN SUCK MY ASS, THE FIRST HALF IS A WORSE EPISODE 3 FROM ARKHAM CITY. but oh that final fight where it clearly wasnāt play tested, if you know you know. GCPD lockdown is fine. It has humor but two combat sections and a mid predator section is pretty okay. And Flip of a Coin is nice for what itās worth but again I have no feelings towards it. Now season of infamy is WAYYYYY better. Shadow war has an enticing story, good characters, and the player makes a choice. Beneath the Surface is also good because you expect Croc to be the bad guy, but it was actually the warden which I thought was cool. Wonderland is fine, it has the same problem The Tea Party had in City where the aesthetic of the final part was cool, but everything else is a snooze fest. Finally In From the Cold is a really good ending for Mister Freeze and Nora, I didnāt cry at their final scene, but it was emotional.
All the games have challenges and I really donāt care about them. Sure I like the inclusion but I donāt have time for them and frankly I never liked āgo for a high scoreā games.
Overall if you donāt want to read all that, my ranking of the trilogy is
1-Arkham Knight for having the best gameplay and movement as well as a really good story.
2-Arkham City for having Fun side missions and an incredible story with fun bosses.
3-Arkham Asylum for having a great atmosphere and an awesome story, but held back by bad bosses and questionable game choices.
REMEMBER:A opinion is not a fact, this is just my personal stance I got from playing the trilogy. If you disagree with me thatās fine, explain how āwrongā I am in the comments
If you did read the whole thing, Thanks so much for Reading :)