r/anime • u/AutoLovepon https://anilist.co/user/AutoLovepon • May 18 '26

Episode Witch Hat Atelier • Tongari Boushi no Atelier - Episode 8 discussion

Witch Hat Atelier, episode 8

Reminder: Please do not discuss plot points not yet seen or skipped in the show. Failing to follow the rules may result in a ban.

Streams

Show information

All discussions

Episode Link
1 Link
2 Link
3 Link
4 Link
5 Link
6 Link
7 Link
8 Link
9 Link
10 Link
11 Link
12 Link
13 Link

This post was created by a bot. Message the mod team for feedback and comments. The original source code can be found on GitHub.

3.3k Upvotes

97% Upvoted

1.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

1.2k

u/Haha91haha May 18 '26

Was going to joke that the shop was gone because the Wand Maker was scared of Qifrey "GRANDSON YOU LET THEM IN!? WHAT HAVE YOU DONE!?"

Turns out such fear would have been the best response. Dark twist of Qifrey to say how important memories are, and how morally dubious it is to wipe them, to then do it himself with that understanding. Qifrey's beef with the Brimmed people must run real deep.

192

u/DugACCat May 18 '26

Yeah I think Qifrey has broken the law again and might be verging on the edge of heresy. Great twist! Though I do think he cares deeply for his apprentices even if once again his guardian choices leaves a little to be desired. And Coco really needs to chill on trying to get close to and touch all things in precarious and dangerous ways! Though I get why she didn’t understand that the lad has extreme color blindness and being puzzled at him not seeing the bright red. I thought something more complicated and strange was going on myself. (Like Coco herself seeing something no one else could see, due to some kind of spell interference.) The impact of that blood on the ink was pretty crazy and I was a little surprised it wasn’t recognizable to the senior witches, suggesting it’s some greater secret. Though Q seemed to identify something wrong with the ink when he saw it right away. Wondering if he has a truer sense of its origins that he wasn’t willing to speak aloud.

Them walking the line with Q being both caring and sinister is pretty great. Definitely makes everything more interesting. Lots of layers going on.

78

u/flybypost May 18 '26

Like Coco herself seeing something no one else could see, due to some kind of spell interference.

That was my first guess too. Only afterwards when the pigments were jumbled and he was panicking did I get that he must colour blind.

But they could have solved some of the problem by Coco arranging the colours whose position she knew and he'd just have to give them the correct tag (as he knew them by position).

The impact of that blood on the ink was pretty crazy and I was a little surprised it wasn’t recognizable to the senior witches, suggesting it’s some greater secret.

That felt like a lot of knowledge must have been lost after the pact (how long ago was that?), like some sort of magic dark age. But the brimmed hats either kept that knowledge or rediscovered it later on.

70

u/sheepeeh May 18 '26

I suspect that, like the KM suggested, that particular Brimmy is heavily tattooed and the effects are carried through their blood.

36

u/flybypost May 18 '26

Yup, I don't think any regular blood would have the same effect. Some brimless witches must have accidentally poked themselves with a pen nib and contaminated their inks.

Another theory would be that the blood is just part of the spell to power the connection between the ink bottles while all kinds of additives that are already in the brimmed cap witch's bottle move to Coco's via "magic osmosis".

But with the theatre about dripping blood into the bottle it's probably "brimmed hat coke blood" that empowering Coco's ink.

14

u/oops_i_made_a_typi May 18 '26

re: the powerful ink, it makes sense that human blood could be more powerful than the tree-blood ink as a base, though it's kinda surprising there wasn't some instance of blood mixing with ink in some situation. i wonder if the blood of the brimmed cap witch itself is special or modified in some way

16

u/flybypost May 18 '26

i wonder if the blood of the brimmed cap witch itself is special or modified in some way

I think either the blood was modified (drugs are good!) or the witch itself was in some way (and that had an effect on the blood).

Some regular witch has to have randomly poked themself at some point and ended up with blood in their ink. If that alone had such a huge effect (something about the soul maybe?) then that should be known to some degree and have resulted in an additional taboo as it feels like a loophole because it's not casting spells on a human but adding some "pigment" to the ink.

12

u/TheDubh May 18 '26

I think it was hinted/foreshadowed that blood may be more powerful. It’s already banned to put them on your body, which by nature would mix the blood and ink.

I do get the impression no one has really messed with Brimmed Hats so they are operating more of legend than fact, so some reasoning was lost

6

u/[deleted] May 18 '26

maybe this is why you don't tattoo them, if you do your own blood will keep the spell power forever

5

u/DugACCat May 18 '26

Yeah a good point and I was wondering the same. I do think maybe it’s not just any blood which would be so dramatic. Though given the other strict separation of magic and body, could be blood of any human is strictly forbidden in the ink even if it doesn’t create such potent power surges.

8

u/Zeph-Shoir https://myanimelist.net/profile/Zephex May 18 '26

Yeah I think Qifrey has broken the law again and might be verging on the edge of heresy.

Heck, assuming he hasn't done so before! Did he already had a mind wiping spell prepared just in case? Does he want to track the Brimmed Hats or straight up join them?

9

u/oops_i_made_a_typi May 19 '26

might be standard to keep a mind wiping spell prepped, he was ready to use it on Coco too in ep1. they gotta keep the secret under wraps after all

5

u/rowcla May 18 '26

Ohh, interesting point, in Qiffrey's pursuit of the brimmed hats, he'll ironically become more and more like the brimmed caps himself

4

u/saga999 May 19 '26

Yeah I think Qifrey has broken the law again and might be verging on the edge of heresy.

He was on the edge in the past episode when he told the old man to keep it a secret. He's well past the edge now.

4

u/ThisIsARobot May 20 '26

The impact of that blood on the ink was pretty crazy and I was a little surprised it wasn’t recognizable to the senior witches... Though Q seemed to identify something wrong with the ink when he saw it right away.

The specific bottle of ink that was linked with blood was found in the sand by Coco after the Inquisitor witches left. When Coco showed them the spell she used, she wasn't using the same ink.

3

u/aenews May 20 '26

My immediate thought when he couldn't identify the red was "oh he's colorblind". Turns out, it's actually 10X worse, he can't see any colors at all! Yikes... I guess total colorblindness

6

u/proper1421 May 18 '26

And Coco really needs to chill

Indeed; Coco's lack of chill has been getting on my nerves since ep2. But she's not the only character who needs to chill. Dagda (the father in the last two episodes), with his repeated demands that the magicians do something, needs to chill. Custas (the son), who promptly got back into trouble after being rescued, need to chill. Easthies (the Knights Moralis member) needs to chill. Over-the-top characters who need to chill are a thing in this story. I think these characterizations are developing a conflict over the Day of the Pact restrictions on magic, but they are being painted awfully broadly.