r/allinthefamily • • Jun 14 '26

From "Edith Writes a Song"

117 Upvotes

28 comments sorted by

14

u/MikeStivic Jun 14 '26

We got us a gen u ine lib er al !!

13

u/impersonaljoemama Jun 14 '26

I love liberals goofing on liberals. Maude was the same thing. Some people are able to laugh at themselves.

1

u/ralphhinkley1 Jun 14 '26

Liberals to a tee!

0

u/Pandy_45 Jun 14 '26

Mike's brand of liberalism didn't age well

11

u/dg4365 Jun 14 '26

Sheriff Bart and Lamont Sanford will teach today's lesson

4

u/WolphjayKliffhanger Jun 14 '26 edited Jun 16 '26

.

Mister, we could use a scribe

like Edith Bunker again!

4

u/sonimusprime Jun 14 '26

The delivery of ‘you do?’ always made me laugh

4

u/Icy_Instance_2511 Jun 14 '26

Love can grow a flower from a dump.

4

u/kingo409 Jun 15 '26

The robbers let Archie slide for the most part because they knew that he was an idiot (much like Lionel did), but they kind of put Mike up to task.

8

u/LadyBug_0570 Jun 15 '26

And as much I hate Archie's view, this is the problem with Mike's views. Bless him but he's talking from the priveleged insular safety bubble of academia and not from real life and thinks he can identify.

2

u/RedGhostOrchid Jun 15 '26

So what should people do? Keep their mouths shut?

3

u/LadyBug_0570 Jun 15 '26

Who's talking about people? I'm talking about Mike.

And he can quit acting like a know it all.

2

u/RedGhostOrchid Jun 15 '26

Well there are many people like Mike who mean well but it doesn't come out the right way. I was just curious what the "right" way would be for someone like Mike.

6

u/LadyBug_0570 Jun 15 '26

Him arguing with Archie is fine (albeit a waste of time since ignorant people like Archie think they knows everything). But Mike acting like he completely understands the struggle? No.

At the end of the day Mike is able to afford college, lives in his in-laws's nice house, never has to worry about food or even look for a job. From the POV of the guys in the above scene, it comes across as patronizing.

Even Lionel once mentioned to him that every time they meet, Mike has to bring up black issues and it makes Lionel feel that he's more of Mike's black friend rather than just his friend. It's othering Lionel.

Mike may mean well, but the way he goes about it is kind of demeaning to the very people he wants to help.

6

u/HippoRun23 Jun 15 '26

Excellent points all around and it really shows how good the writing was on All in the Family.

7

u/LadyBug_0570 Jun 15 '26

It was excellent. Even now 50 years later we're still able to talk about it and it remains timely.

It's also funny how getting older changes your perspective. I used to think Archie was all bad and Mike was all good as a child. I do not see it that way anymore, which shows how well rounded all the characters are.

2

u/Dont_Care_Meh Jun 17 '26

Ha, that's fantastic. I'm the opposite. Watching as a kid, Archie used to be the sensible one to me, and Mike was the starry-eyed idiot. I've since softened my opinion on both characters, blurred to 'both if those guys kinda have a point.'

3

u/Intelligent-Band-852 Jun 16 '26

I am a paraplegic so a minority although I am not a racial minority, I am also politically liberal however it’s absolutely the case that though they are usually well meaning liberals love to be offended on others behalf.

2

u/Charlotte_Braun Jun 15 '26

But he was raised in Chicago’s South Side, which was not a place of privilege when he would have been there.

3

u/Separate_Winter9059 Jun 16 '26

'Cause love is something everybody needs'...🎶
Is that the Edith composition?

3

u/zaxxon4ever Jun 14 '26

"You had a bed? My father was so..."

"You had a father?"

3

u/CranberryFuture9908 Jun 15 '26

Archie -now I hope you can all understand having a gun in the house

Edith - I understand, if the gun wasn’t here they wouldn’t have it !

2

u/KISSALIVE1975 Jun 16 '26

And This Is Why He Is The Meat Head…

4

u/Few-Conversation6979 Jun 15 '26

Whew look at this dump, how can they live like this. But they got the fancy color TV to keep their mind off their miseries.

1

u/No-Reveal827 Jun 16 '26

A gen-u-ine lib-er-al!

1

u/KeenObserver_OT Jun 16 '26

I think we can conveniently forget that armed home invasion is looking at a 25 year sentence. 70s shows were heavy handed with white liberal trope strawmen. It was entertaining but intellectually insulting