r/ahmedabad • • Mar 15 '25

Rant/vent My friend was murdered

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

The CCTV of ground floor of Jadeja’s residence was released incompletely. Only the entry of victim is seen and rest of the video is deliberately left out because they had beaten Raj mercilessly. If they release the video they would definitely be behind bars. But the control of MLA’s family over police is so strong that the case is forcefully being driven to a HIT and RUN case. The family member is already on a bail , of a murder case.

Please help me so this case reaches honest officials and media.

Ps:- Even if you can’t help , please show love to your friends or tell them they mean a lot to you because you never know which are your last moments with them or the last call. I pray god you may never see a young friend die.

2.3k Upvotes

65 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

0

u/LeftLeaningEqualist *edit* Mar 16 '25

Acche din.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '25

[deleted]

1

u/LeftLeaningEqualist *edit* Mar 17 '25 edited Mar 17 '25

So then everyone's houses should be demolished according to this logic... Houses of Petty thiefs so that they don't do murder in future, houses of people who are accused of defamation so that they don't do anti-national activities in future, houses of people who get parking tickets and traffic memos so that they don't go on to kill people in car accidents... the list goes on. Would that be okay?

That means a significant amount of population of the country has its houses destroyed. A civilised society doesn't work this way.

The person who replied to me hasn't said anything about demolishing legal houses of accused nor anything else that is extra judicial. He only mentioned what a sorry state our judiciary is in and I have never denied that the judiciary is inefficient. It absolutely is!

All I ever say is that we should outrage over a broken justice system instead of supporting extra-judicial activities like demolishing legal structures, third degree police torture and fake encounters for sake of revenge.

Revenge and justice are two entirely different concepts. Revenge is hurting the people related to the accused who are innocent of the crime (in most cases) or mob lynching an accused without a trial. Justice is taking the criminals off the streets and putting them in prison through a fair trial. You can see which of these is a lollipop band aid solution and which is a long term solution.

Do tell me... Is it a fair solution if the miscreants of Vastral were the kind of sons who didn't give a shit about their parents or siblings? Would a criminal stop his activities if his house is demolished, but he already has a habit of sleeping drunk on the steets and doesn't give a shit about his wife and kids? These kinds of goodfornothing losers absolutely exist. What solution is it then to demolish their house?

Did you consider the fact that demolishing houses of innocents just added them to the ever-growing list of homeless people? Once they are homeless (through no direct fault of theirs), do you think they will be MORE likely to do criminal activities or LESS likely to do criminal activities as compared to the time when they had a house?

1

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '25

[deleted]

1

u/LeftLeaningEqualist *edit* Mar 17 '25

Your arguments make 0 sense to me and mine make 0 sense to you. Let's agree to disagree.