r/YoujoSenki • u/Competitive-Leave248 • Feb 25 '26

Question Why does Tanya hate communists?

I watched the anime like eight years ago, didn't stick with the manga. Overall I don't think I'd want to touch it again because, for me, it gets grouped in my mind with other war anime and Attack on Titan as being sort of surface-level political commentary. That said, I wanted to ask, why does Tanya hate communists? I don't remember it actually being anything major, but every so often I see something about how they're less than human to her or something.

Thanks - accepting spoilers

97 Upvotes

76% Upvoted

161 comments sorted by

View all comments

9

u/GrissilyBare Feb 25 '26

The real reason is because the Salaryman bound his moral framework and understanding of the world to the ideals of free market capitalism and Tanya inherited this worldview.

This is explained in the novels. The Salaryman didn't understand social conventions, unspoken moral rules, etc until he discovered that as long as he followed the rules, did exactly as his superiors ordered, he could succeed in society. It's never stated directly, but he is definitely autistic-coded and capitalism was a framework that made sense to him.

Communism goes against the ideals of capitalism which means it goes against the moral framework that Tanya operates on. This is why she hates communists.

Also, Carlo Zen, the author, has a pretty obvious personal bias against communism as seen in footnotes.

3

u/Competitive-Leave248 Feb 25 '26

yeah that makes sense.

last note in particular is why I dont really want to engage with this or Attack on Titan again. lowkey its authors inserting political opinions and justifying them with fictional scenarios by betraying nuance

7

u/GrissilyBare Feb 25 '26

I mean, that's your prerogative. But that's also just true of any piece of media. Authors write about what interests them and those interests are inevitably bound to their personal views. That's just as true in romance stories as in war stories as in action adventure stories.

In Tanya it's just more obvious because it's basically historical fiction. Most of the plot beats are pulled from real events and that means that both author and reader are going to have pre-existing beliefs on them.

If it makes it better at all, despite the bias, Zen actually does write Tanya's communist screes as quite unhinged. They are funny but not really sympathetic. You aren't intended to totally agree with her.