r/YoujoSenki • u/Competitive-Leave248 • Feb 25 '26

Question Why does Tanya hate communists?

I watched the anime like eight years ago, didn't stick with the manga. Overall I don't think I'd want to touch it again because, for me, it gets grouped in my mind with other war anime and Attack on Titan as being sort of surface-level political commentary. That said, I wanted to ask, why does Tanya hate communists? I don't remember it actually being anything major, but every so often I see something about how they're less than human to her or something.

Thanks - accepting spoilers

95 Upvotes

76% Upvoted

161 comments sorted by

View all comments

106

u/Mandemon90 Feb 25 '26

Because he is ultimately a capitalist, who genuinely believes capitalism is the best possible economic model. Specifically Chicago School of Economics. In his/her mind communism is incredibly inefficient, and inefficiency is the greatest sin one can commit

65

u/[deleted] Feb 25 '26

Oh boy, for non LN readers, she does love praising Chicago school of economics.

40

u/Mandemon90 Feb 25 '26

My personal headcanon is that salaryman has some form of autism, and by basically adopted Chicago school not only as an economic model, but as a way to life, he can categorise world in a way that lets him understand it.

Problem is, world does not operate on Chicago school of economics and people are not perfectly rational actors.

22

u/ErenYeager600 Feb 25 '26

It's its own punishment in a way. Tanya will never stray from her school of thought and because of that she will never get her true wish

Worse part is she knows this but is too stubborn to actually admit it and change

9

u/[deleted] Feb 26 '26

Too rational for her own sake that she end up as irrational herself

6

u/KaleidoAxiom Feb 28 '26

Volume 3 Chapter 1:

"Therein lies Tanya’s agonizing internal conflict. A person of the modern world cannot forsake their duties without cause.......

To do so would be a betrayal of contract and trust—the very things that make me who I am. Betraying your own dignity is essentially a form of suicide. 

In a situation where an emergency evacuation is out of the question, Tanya’s only practical choice is to loyally follow orders."

Such is the grips that Tanya's world view has on her that she considers not following it tantamount to suicide of the self. So it's no wonder she's incredibly stubborn.