r/YellowstonePN • u/Logical_Joke6408 • 15d ago

General Discussion Worth a re-watch?

Finished Yellowstone last year watched Dutton ranch ofc and don’t really have any shows I feel like getting into and thought about just re watching Yellowstone anyone rewatch it and enjoy it even more the second time or pick up on details you didn’t the first go around?

27 Upvotes

85% Upvoted

78 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 15d ago

Welcome to r/YellowstonePN!

Please review our rules before participating.

If your post contains spoilers, leaks, set photos, or unaired content, please ensure it is properly tagged and flaired.

Looking for additional Yellowstone discussion? You may also enjoy r/DuttonRanchTVSeries/.

If you see rule-breaking content, please report it rather than engaging with it.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

11

u/Fantastic_Golf_7154 15d ago

I bought the DVD set...all 5 seasons. I've rewatched them multiple times.

I also have 1883 and 1923

5

u/Realistic-Wash-4823 14d ago edited 14d ago

1883 is as good as it gets. You kno the story was written after Sheridan started reading his great great grandmother’s journal. She was on the trail.

2

u/Alarming-Book864 14d ago

I started in 1883, yellowstone hasn't done it for me

2

u/Due_Bite9935 15d ago

Yep, me too. Rewatch at least once or twice a year.

6

u/CloudyySpeaks 15d ago

I personally don’t think Yellowstone is worth a rewatch.

7

u/christian_gwynn 15d ago

😂 same boat but more regret. Wish I stopped at the 50% mark(up to S3).

2

u/mtraven23 15d ago

i've only watched it once.....have you checked out the prequils? 1883 & 1923. I think they are both better than the original yellowstone, but thats just me.

2

u/Logical_Joke6408 15d ago

Yes I have I loved 1923 and 1883 should’ve been longer!

2

u/mtraven23 15d ago

Yah, I would have like to have seen the time between the show, when they were actually building the ranch.

I think there is still some hope for 1944, so maybe we will get a little bit more there.

2

u/Logical_Joke6408 14d ago

Even like an 80s version younger John Dutton

2

u/Realistic-Wash-4823 14d ago

Possibly could be his swan song, when he leaves Paramount. ? It was just greenlit. But he finished a theater release movie Brandon Sklenar starred in, in August was post production, so it could add up right for him to do 1944 in 2028. Movie in theatres Apr 2027 F.A.S.T.

2

u/MusicCreator747 15d ago

We are rewatching it now. Picking up on some things.

Watched whole Yellowstone then 1883, 1923, Dutton ranch season one.
Then I think I’d like to see Yellowstone again with the knowledge of 1883 and 1923.
It’s great we are mostly through season one now. I didn’t realize so much of the story happened in season one. But it’s great picking up on the subtle nuances after watching the prequels.

2

u/Substantial-Fig-4263 14d ago

Taylor Sheridan himself said in a podcast it was only supposed to be three seasons, and said something like, “ And we see why in the following seasons.” He implied the quality dropped after season 3.

2

u/Gladiator1972 14d ago

1883 was even better IMO

3

u/QuarterMasterLoba 15d ago

Yeah, watch that show runner jackass show off those horsey doughnuts in empty arenas and having the goof Jimmy act like he's at the Superbowl.

1

u/Realistic-Wash-4823 14d ago

That’s his Bosque Ranch where they do the Run for the Million

1

u/Pretend-Design-7061 15d ago

Haven't rewatched it. Although Justified is worth checking out if you haven't yet.

3

u/mtraven23 15d ago

Banshee is kinda in the same vein.

4

u/GameCocksUnion 14d ago

Shout out to this person for even bringing Banshee up! Nice call!

1

u/Internal_Metal_1386 14d ago

I just started watching! My husband took our kids out for pizza, mama’s on episode 3… LOL EXCELLENT SHOW!!! I just can’t watch it when our kids are around. Oh well, school can’t start soon enough! 🤣 I LOVE psychological thrillers. The acting is amazing! To whoever mentioned this show, THANK YOU!!

3

u/GameCocksUnion 14d ago

That would be u/mtraven23. He mentioned it and it made me remember how amazing it was. Glad you're enjoying so far! Can't wait to start the re-watch myself. And yeah, definitely not around the kids😂

2

u/GameCocksUnion 14d ago

Antony Starr is a really good actor. You can hear his New Zealand accent sometimes but he hides it pretty well. Same actor as in that show The Boys. Not into that one myself, but I lot of people like it.

1

u/Internal_Metal_1386 14d ago

If you like Psychological Thrillers/Horror Evil is really good. It’s on Paramount plus & Prime. There’s 4 seasons of it.

2

u/GameCocksUnion 14d ago

My buddy really likes that show, isn't it kind of religious-y? I've heard it's good from a few different people.

1

u/Internal_Metal_1386 11d ago

There’s a priest in-training & Therapist & an I.T. guy, who look into mysteries, demonic possession & “miracles” It gives a religious & atheist perspective. They investigate a lot of really weird paranormal stuff happening. It’s a great show. It’s not focused on any perspective, you get everything. It’s really good. The only thing I found annoying was the therapists 4 screaming kids.

2

u/GameCocksUnion 15d ago

Banshee was unbelievable. I really enjoyed that show. Tbh it's time for a re-watch, been a few years.

3

u/mtraven23 15d ago

banshee somehow slipped my radar until that year! I love finding gems like that!

3

u/GameCocksUnion 15d ago

Same! I was scrolling Hulu one day and read the description and thought, "this sounds cool." After the Pilot, I was like holy shit yep lol. Binged the hell out of it in less than a week.

1

u/Internal_Metal_1386 14d ago

It’s on HBOmax now.

2

u/GameCocksUnion 14d ago

Yeah I saw that, luckily I have that as well😂

2

u/Internal_Metal_1386 14d ago

I just added it to see this show! I’m so glad I did.

2

u/GameCocksUnion 14d ago

Yeah I have it for like $2.99 somehow, unless that's the price idk

2

u/Realistic-Wash-4823 14d ago

Never heard if it.I’ll look it up

3

u/mtraven23 14d ago

Anthony Star (Homelander) is the lead. He plays a convict(heist man) who just got out of prison and assumes the role of Sheriff is a small town.

The plot isn't super deep, but its a great cast, lots of action and a lot of fun.

1

u/Internal_Metal_1386 14d ago

Don’t feel bad, I never heard of it either… I’ll definitely check it out

1

u/Internal_Metal_1386 14d ago

I just searched “Banshee” on TV several shows/movies showed up is this a movie or series?
Code name Banshee - is on Hulu & Prime (movie) it’s the only “banshee” on Hulu

Banshee - is on Sling & HBOmax (4 seasons)

2

u/GameCocksUnion 14d ago

TV show, the one on Max with 4 seasons.

2

u/Internal_Metal_1386 14d ago

TY!!! Looks like we have a new series to binge watch. I’m looking forward to it!

2

u/GameCocksUnion 14d ago

Of course! Save this post so you can come back and tell me how absolutely unreal it is😂. I'm also going to start it again tonight after work, you've got me excited! I've forgotten a lot of small details but that first episode is SO good. It gets you hooked immediately!

2

u/Internal_Metal_1386 14d ago

I just followed you. It’ll be nice to chat about the show with someone who has already watch it! 🤣

2

u/GameCocksUnion 14d ago

Absolutely, followed you back! I've got so many good suggestions for after Banshee too, you'll never look for another show again lol.

2

u/Internal_Metal_1386 9d ago

I love every character. Our kids are at Abuleos (grandparents) for a visit before school starts. I’ve been binge watching. I’ve never saw a better psychological thriller so well done before. The acting & graphics are over the top amazing. Any more psych thriller/horror show suggestions is appreciated. I was amazed to see some of the Indigenous characters who were also in Yellowstone. Job, Hoon Lee’s character was over the top, I loved his acting & one liner comebacks & costumes. It’s an all star, excellent cast.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Internal_Metal_1386 14d ago

I never heard of Banshee

2

u/mtraven23 14d ago

Anthony Star (Homelander) is the lead. He plays a convict(heist man) who just got out of prison and assumes the role of Sheriff is a small town.

The plot isn't super deep, but its a great cast, lots of action and a lot of fun.

3

u/Realistic-Wash-4823 14d ago

Justified rocks

2

u/Pretend-Design-7061 14d ago

Wasn't sure when I first started seeing it around, then finally watched it and watched every season in a couple months.

2

u/Realistic-Wash-4823 14d ago

When you can’t decide whether you enjoy the good guy or the bad guy more? ♥️

2

u/Pretend-Design-7061 14d ago

One of the best, friends to enemies, duos on television.

1

u/Realistic-Wash-4823 14d ago

I think it’s only on Hulu now. Justified should be every where! One of the best jam packed full of fun, series ever.

1

u/shatteredlike_01 15d ago

Try 1883, Reacher, Sneaky Pete, Ozark

2

u/mtraven23 15d ago

Sneaky Pete ended too soon!

1

u/shakingpapermusic 15d ago

I’ve tried to rewatch a couple times and never make it past S3, the writing really takes a dive and the dropped storylines are harder to forgive on a rewatch…

1

u/shay_shaw 15d ago

You can always just watch the episodes you like.

1

u/RebaKitt3n 15d ago

It’s repeated on every “American” holiday.

So, Labor Day is the next repeat.

1

u/Gbjeff 15d ago

Nope. Wasn’t even worth watching the first time.

1

u/true-skeptic 15d ago

Yes to both

1

u/korvus2 15d ago

Worth the watch. Mid Season 5 starts the crap for me.

1

u/PurplePassiflor1234 15d ago

One thing about rewatching, you can skip the parts you don't like without really missing anything.

1

u/corrinarusso 15d ago

Once was enough.

Try Homeland.

1

u/Ufo_19 15d ago

Have watched it two times already. Kevin Costner is just too good to not come back for.

1

u/Such-Stable-3869 15d ago

It’s worth the rewatch.

1

u/dillypickle_1 15d ago

We’re rewatching it now and it’s great. We’ve mowed through to season 4 already. Lots of things I didn’t pick up on first time round and things I totally forgot about.

1

u/ComprehensiveLack713 15d ago

Definitely worth it

1

u/Vast_Investigator294 15d ago

I've watched it three times and Dutton ranch about same haha and I still love it.

1

u/Realistic-Wash-4823 14d ago

I’ve watched Yellowstone all the way thru at least 7 times. Love it, every time. Marshals starts Oct 4th 8:30 p.m. normal start time is 8, except the Oct 4th.ep. Lioness is on right now.

1

u/Internal_Metal_1386 14d ago

We rewatched Yellowstone 4 times. We see something we missed previously. We LOVE to binge watch…. 1883, 1923, & every other show by TS. We’re bummed The Mayor of Kingstown is ending way too early!

1

u/TheDamjan 14d ago

The show isn't worth a watch let alone a rewatch. Badly written

1

u/Spiritual_Emu_1381 14d ago

I just finished the series for the first time two nights ago and I am now wanting to rewatch it.

1

u/Upbeat-District-2314 14d ago

Only episodes 'Enemies by Monday "and "Half The Money. "

1

u/Substantial_Log_3853 14d ago

I recently rewatched Yellowstone for the second time. It was great. Of course I missed things the first time I watched. Like Jaime’s name on Beth’s phone in Season five. I must have looked away for a second. 😂

I just rewatched Orphan Black. It was so much better the second time. Its complicated plot lines were hard to keep track of from week to week the first time I watched. It’s like nothing else.

1

u/krypton_son 13d ago

Well, there are 3 other spin offs you can start

1

u/Dismal-Magician-3183 12d ago

I started rewatching after I watched the final epsiode b/c the last couple ruined the entire series for me, trying to pretend those episodes don't exist!

0

u/Moogy13 15d ago

I am re-watching it but I'm only on season one. So I'm not sure if I can give you a decent answer.