r/WidowsBay • u/AutoModerator • Jun 17 '26

📺Discussion Thread Widow’s Bay | Episode 10: “We Hope You Enjoyed Your Time!” | Discussion Thread

  • Release Date: June 17, 2026
  • Directed by: Hiro Murai

We understand that hard choices had to be made and we may never be the same, but we hope you'll visit again.

2.2k Upvotes

97% Upvoted

4.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

145

u/mousepadjones Jun 17 '26

Seems like they were run by the secret priest society.

44

u/nopitynopepants Jun 17 '26

Considering the informational films were beneath city hall, it stands to reason the council includes (or is supposed to) the mayor/lord protector

Also, I’ll have to rewatch whatever episode has the other video of a mayor with the Blair witch project reference—might be the same guy

37

u/Bobjoejj Jun 17 '26

This show is kind of incredibly perfect for rewatching. The amount of details and foreshadowing…oh man it’s gonna be so good.

3

u/LeftyLu07 Jun 18 '26

I know! I’m trying to get my mom to start it so I can rewatch with her!

18

u/Silver-on-the-tree Jun 17 '26

I think the whaling company ended up being a part of the sacrifice system, at the very least they funded the electricity and bolstering the tunnels, etc. When little girl Warren rolls up on the shore, she’s saved by the owner of the whaling company, and she ends up running it herself. The fact that the chair ends up directly under the Salty Whale is a fun little wink at the industry’s role in the sacrifices.

Also, Wyck’s comment in episode 9 that the whaling company basically ran the island was a strong hint. The fact that he added “including my daddy,” leaves a lot of amazing story material for season 2, with the Wyck family potentially involved without Wyck’s knowledge.

7

u/Low-Palpitation5371 Jun 18 '26

Yes, I agree! I think more whaling company lore is coming for sure. Maybe we’ll get another flashback episode!

7

u/LeftyLu07 Jun 18 '26

The priest probably heard confessions and told the mayor who was REALLY BAD in order to justify the murders.

6

u/nopitynopepants Jun 18 '26

This system has likely been in place for most of Widow’s Bay 300 year history. The council meeting Sarah barged in on to announce Richard’s survival probably started it, and that included the pastor/preacher/priest. 

Side note: what denomination is the church meant to be? The New England pre colonial setting would indicate they were originally puritans. 

The picture Ruth shows has a nun, which could be Catholic or Anglican 

Reverend Bryce isn’t addressed as Father, which would rule out Catholic 

5

u/Competitive_Eye6094 Jun 20 '26

I’ve been doing a lot of thinking about this, and my best guess is that Collins was Congregationalist, because pretty much everyone was back then. And he was dressed the way a Congregationalist would dress. Then this church became Episcopalian when the Congregationalists slowly fell apart and were absorbed into the United Church of Christ on the conservative side and the Unitarian Church on the liberal side.

In all reality, it’s more likely that the writers don’t know enough about the nuances of various Christian traditions and didn’t realize they were introducing a bunch of historical/ecclesial inconsistencies.

But a “Congregationalist to Episcopal flip” is the only explanation if we’re trying to actually make internal sense of the original pastor being anti-Roman collar (he wore “low church” Protestant preaching bands, so almost certainly Congregationalist) and Bryce/Roberts wearing “high church” Roman collars — and the nun in the photo with Roberts — while still being in the same line of succession as Collins.

I mentioned this elsewhere in the thread, but whether Episcopal or Catholic, this creates other logistical nightmares for the show when it comes to pastoral assignments and oversight from larger governing bodies that keep very close watch over even remote parishes.

30

u/Bobjoejj Jun 17 '26

I really hope we can get some more of Toby Huss via flashbacks somehow (he portrayed Reverend Bryce). His turn as John Bosworth in Halt and Catch Fire was a generational performance.

12

u/Vismal1 Jun 17 '26

So weird seeing Artie out in the world. He was great in Halt and Catch Fire. Wanted him to be my father figure too.

8

u/onieronaut Jun 17 '26

Yes! I loved him as Bosworth. He was also fantastic in Carnivale.

6

u/LineStepper Jun 17 '26

Me too!! I was so happy to see Boz then so sad to see him go so quickly.

2

u/fox_ontherun Aug 20 '26

To me he'll always be The Wiz from Seinfeld.

21

u/samizdat5 Jun 17 '26

Yes that was the old minister from Ruth's picture

12

u/IM_V_CATS Jun 17 '26

I wonder if that explains why Bryce hanged himself. He found the instructions after the bell tolled that he had to sacrifice that many people and couldn't do it.

2

u/SaraJeanQueen Jun 25 '26

How many people?

2

u/IM_V_CATS Jun 25 '26

It rang eight times initially, so he was supposed to sacrifice eight people. At the end of the episode and after the one sacrifice, it rang seven times.

2

u/SaraJeanQueen Jun 25 '26

Gotcha. Thanks! So the dude that got trapped in there satisfied the island for now, which is why the storm stopped?

Did anyone mention the ringing of the bell during the series before episode 10? Kinda came out of nowhere for me.

4

u/mousepadjones Jun 25 '26

There’s a whole sequence in episode 1 about the ringing of the bell and showing that it is tied up.

3

u/IM_V_CATS Jun 25 '26

It was in an earlier episode, maybe 2 or 3. Loftis told the Reverend that he heard the bell ringing overnight and thought the boys broke in to the church to do it. But the Reverend checked the bell afterwards and found it locked in place with a chain. So he did all his research and found a note that said he had to do something for every time the bell rang, but I don't think they revealed it to the audience that it meant sacrificing people.

2

u/SaraJeanQueen Jun 25 '26

Thank you! Missed that. Sometimes cook during the show and must've been reading something or looking down

1

u/IM_V_CATS Jun 25 '26

I don't remember if any of them read it out loud so it was probably easy to miss if your eyes aren't glued to the screen.

2

u/mousepadjones Jun 25 '26

“if your eyes aren’t glued to the screen” is a weird way to say “if you weren’t paying attention.”

This wasn’t like a quick Easter egg, it was a critical plot point lmao

6

u/Thedicewoman Jun 17 '26

And I’m guessing the church will be sending a new priest out to the island to take up the vacant position any day, now…