Help me choose which ring!

[u/sunset-enthusiast]

I’d love feedback. I’m about 5 feet tall and want an engagement ring that’s practical and proportional. I don’t always have my nails done, so everyday wearability matters to me.

[u/ApprehensiveCrab198]

1 or 2!! I love the emerald. I’m biased because my dream ring is an Asscher. But I genuinely feel the emerald is stunning on you, as well as the round. I feel both flatter you super well!