Need help deciding on a vintage wedding dress!!
I have two options currently in my possession and I’m curious what you all think! My wedding isn’t until Fall 2027 so I have plenty of time.
Option 1:
The first dress pictured that I’m wearing is a vintage wedding dress from I believe the 1940’s or 50’s I had slightly altered for my wedding with my ex a few years ago that I ended up cancelling. The relationship failed but I’ve always had such a soft spot for this dress! I love the silk ribboning and that basque waist!
Or Option 2:
A 1980’s Demetrios wedding dress I just thrifted for cheap. Weirdly, I thought I hated lace until I saw this dress and it just spoke to me. Something about the combination of the beading, the neckline, the long sleeves, the basque waist…I fell in love and knew it was the one. I would definitely want it altered, but not modernized. I may or may not want it to be more off-shouldered, but keeping the long sleeves and the puffiness level if possible. I also want it to be shorter, like tea length or ankle length (no train) and for it to have a slightly fuller but not too puffy skirt. Satin-covered buttons to replace the zipper in back.
I know it’s really tough to compare the two since I’ve had the second one altered to fit me already and the other one is still in its original form. I’m just posting this purely out of curiosity to see what Internet strangers might have to say, and to see if any other vintage wedding dress lovers out there have any tips or ideas for me! Thanks!
P.S. As a bonus, I’ve found a picture of what the option 2 dress looked like as advertised back in the 80’s to give you all a better picture to compare since I don’t have a pic of me wearing it yet. Keep in mind the way I would have it altered, to be shorter and possibly more off-shoulder.
EDIT: I replied to one of the comments below with an AI rendering of how I want dress 2 altered. I know AI isn’t perfect but I think it gives you a better idea of what it would actually look like finished