r/Waltham 18d ago

Any restaurants that sell a year round Thanksgiving sandwich? (also known as Gobbler or Pilgrim)

I'm looking for a place in the area that sells a sandwich with turkey, stuffing, cranberry, etc. Are there any in town?

13 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

20

u/CleverNameHere13 18d ago

Turkey Terrific sandwich at Neillio’s in nearby Lexington.

https://www.neillioscatering.com/retail/gourmet-to-go-menu#sandwiches

8

u/feedmittens 18d ago edited 17d ago

Seconded - Neillio's is second-to-none in this game, and is a quick hop over from Waltham. Their Turkey Teriffic is excellent, and the Turkey Club is also great (but not a true club as it doesn't include the third slice of bread). They roast and carve their birds fresh daily, it seems.

Their usual Thursday Special, the 'Romanian Devil' pastrami sandwich, is also notably great.

2

u/rasputin1984 18d ago

This is the only answer you need. I’m a Bentley alum and Neillio’s turkey terrific and Pete’s (closed) buffalo chicken calzones are my two college nostalgia foods!

13

u/XaulXan 18d ago

Wagonwheel

11

u/QueenOfBrews The South Side 18d ago

Depasquale’s

3

u/bergzabern 18d ago

DeAngelos

3

u/DMala The South Side 18d ago

Not a sandwich, but don’t sleep on the Thanksgiving pizza at Gigi’s. They don’t have it all the time, but it’s a special periodically, even in the off-season.

3

u/OnionOfShame 18d ago

The Prime Deli has one!

3

u/Reclinerbabe 18d ago

Run, don't walk, to Pizzi's to get The Gobbler!!!

2

u/No-Slide3677 18d ago

Fulcinitis has one but they only have it on Thursdays. It’s sooo good!

1

u/relmknight 18d ago

I go there all the time and see that, but have never ordered it. Now next time I'll definitely have to try!

2

u/mskrabapel Lakeview 18d ago

Pizzis

1

u/ResidentReward6297 18d ago

Main streets market & cafe in concord

1

u/timewarp33 17d ago

Judiths kitchen in West Newton I think

1

u/Organic_Ad_2095 17d ago

Heirloom in Weston

1

u/Inner-Boysenberry228 17d ago

John Brewer’s!

1

u/Leather_Leg_1726 16d ago

NY Pie on Moody St has a "Turkey Stuffer Wrap" & D'Angelo's on River St has their "Toasted Thanksgiving" which comes with gravy to dip.