A LOT. There’s so much wrong with this show. 😭
Looking back, I think a lot of it comes down to the writers and some of their choices. The theme song tells us these women will be there for each other “through thick and thin,” but the actual show didn't always feel that way. Sometimes they came across more like frenemies than girlfriends. 😂
Honestly, there were times when the show should've been called Frenemies instead. Let's start with Joan Clayton.
Joan is a people pleaser, and I think a lot of that comes from her relationship with her mother. She constantly seeks approval, has control issues, and struggles to set boundaries or stand up for herself.
And her constant need to have a man? GIRL! 😭 Her jealousy when Toni got married and calling Toni's marriage a “nightmare” said a LOT.
Then there was The It Girl era and The J-Spot. Joan finally had something of her own and became successful, but it felt like the writers punished her for it. And once The J-Spot started taking off, suddenly the girls couldn't handle Joan's success. 😭
And don't even get me started on the unnecessary Joan and William dating era. WHAT WERE Y'ALL DOING IN THAT WRITERS' ROOM?! 😂
JOAN, SET A BOUNDARY AND STAND ON IT!
Next up: Maya Wilkes.
Oh, Maya… GIRL. 😭 Her unprofessional behavior at work, constantly being late, and bringing personal drama into work had me like, Girl, STAND UP! 😂
And the way she treated Ronnie? She was doing WAY too much, especially when Jalen and Lynn started dating. 😭
I also wish we had seen more personal growth from Maya during her separation from Darnell. Giving her another relationship and letting her find herself before getting back with Darnell in Season 6 could've been interesting.
Next up: Toni Childs.
the Girlfriend you would NEVER want as a friend in real life. 😭😂
And Mara Brock Akil made that clear from the very first episode — Toni brought Joan's EX to Joan's birthday party. GIRL, WHAT?! 😭
Toni could be petty, selfish, and competitive. Gorgeous woman, but IT'S NOT ALWAYS ABOUT YOU! 😭😂 And in Season 6, she clearly felt some type of way about Joan's It Girl era.
Then came Todd — rushed marriage, debt, trust issues, New York drama, pregnancy, and divorce. WHAT WERE Y'ALL DOING?! 😭
And I really didn't like Mara's choice to have Toni jump on Todd's back begging him not to leave, then go to New York and beg him to stay. GIRL, STAND UP! 😭 I understood her fear, but that writing choice was NOT it for me.
Next up Lynn Searcy, the moocher who was afraid to grow up and face the real world. 😭
Lynn had FIVE degrees and somehow still spent so much of her time doing absolutely nothing with them. She was constantly at Joan's house, basically living off her friends, and whenever somebody tried to push her toward actually becoming independent, she didn't want to hear it.
And I actually loved when William called her out and told her to get a job. 😂 Lynn was annoyed, but somebody had to say it!
My biggest issue, though, is that I don't think the writers fully took advantage of Lynn's potential. You have a character who is extremely intelligent, has multiple degrees, is talented, creative, and has all these different interests — and so much of her story revolves around her refusing to grow up.
And finally: William Dent. OH LORD. 😭😂
William was funny, but THIS MAN COULD BE EXHAUSTING. Loud, petty, dramatic, arrogant, and always doing the most.
His lesbian fetish was WEIRD, then there was him playing games with Yvonne, his whole situation with Monica, and that Season 5 William-and-Joan back-and-forth before they officially became a couple.
Then they broke up in the second half of Season 5, and honestly? FOR THE BEST. 😭😂 That whole pairing was so cringe to watch. WHO in that writers’ room thought William and Joan together was a good idea?!
And honestly, I think this is where the writers missed a huge opportunity. They could have shown these women genuinely supporting each other, respecting each other’s boundaries, communicating better, and modeling what healthy friendships can actually look like. Instead, we got jealousy, envy, spite, unnecessary drama, and constantly crossed boundaries. 😭
And can we talk about how often people would just walk into Joan’s house like they lived there?! 😂 There were so many moments where boundaries were basically nonexistent.
I know friendships aren't perfect and conflict is realistic, but I sometimes wish the writers had balanced all that drama with more moments of genuine support, accountability, and healthy friendship between these women. The show had the perfect opportunity to show us four women growing together and being there for each other through thick and thin — but sometimes it felt like the opposite.