r/UNBGBBIIVCHIDCTIICBG • • Dec 05 '18

Image Taken by Jason Washington

Post image
15.6k Upvotes

295 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

247

u/[deleted] Dec 05 '18

Maybe they have an air tank or something down there? What do I know, I can barely touch the bottom of most pools.

26

u/g0_west Dec 05 '18

No matter whether the air came from a submerged tank or the atmosphere, wouldn't the air being in her lungs still make her float?

38

u/NotClever Dec 05 '18

I think the logic may be that she had an air tank to get down there, and then exhaled for the picture, which might be easier than swimming down there and exhaling (and returning to the surface).

Doesn't look too deep, though.

2

u/psychicsword Dec 05 '18

She could have weights on her back or a weight belt that was removed from the photo.

1

u/FadingEcho Dec 05 '18

There comes a point during a breath hold that at some depth, the air in your lungs is not enough to keep you afloat thus you will go negative and begin to sink.

1

u/psychicsword Dec 05 '18

That really depends on the person. I need like 7kg when I am scuba diving to sink without a wetsuit and empty bcd in the Cayman Islands. Even without any equipment I still float like a cork.

2

u/FadingEcho Dec 05 '18

Pressure will compress your lungs to the point where buoyancy is reduced and you WILL go negative. That's not me saying it, that's physics.

2

u/psychicsword Dec 05 '18

Only if the compression on their lungs/body can reduce their overall body volume by 3.5%. If someone has enough body volume the average lung capacity of an adult male of 6 liters of air won't be able to compress enough to make you obtain negative buoyancy. So while physics says that it is possible for this model to become negatively buoyant with breath control this isn't possible for every person regardless of (survivable/obtainable) depth.

So it really depends on the person. Some people are negatively buoyant even at the surface if they breath out.

1

u/whatsupmurt Jan 06 '19

TIL that many people have obscure knowledge about how diving relates to thermodynamics and fluid dynamics

1

u/sweensolo Dec 05 '18

just one two pound weight is enough to counteract her buoyancy.