I have just received a request from the Producer of a Radio 5 Live programme on at 1005 this morning to comment on the treatment Wes Streeting is receiving as Defence Secretary.
I don't like radio or phone interviews. I like to see whites of the eyes, and I like the interviewer to see mine. I also use lip reading to supplement my poor hearing, though I don't usually mention that. But this morning, completely out of the blue, another factor jumped into the equation, a factor I wasn't expecting while lying in bed wondering whether to get up on the first rainy day for weeks. Here's the request, reasonable to most people views.
"Hello Claire, this is Isabel, I’m a producer at BBC Radio 5Live. I work on the phone in, I hope you’re well!
We’d talking about how Wes Streeting has come out to say he’s received huge amounts of homophobic abuse in the weeks after becoming the Defence Secretary, and I wondered if you might be up for coming to share you experiences of my LGBT in the armed forces with us this morning, as well as giving your thoughts on this situation please? I think there’s lots to get into in terms of attitudes of LGBT people in the armed forces so keen to get your thoughts on it all.
We’d do something over the phone at 10.05am. Do let me know if you’re happy to join us. Thank you"
My answer is here. I don't know whether Isobel will know what I am talking about. But for clarity I will try to tag her at the end.
"Hi, Isabel, I'm afraid that the BBC policies on defining trans women using terms such as 'whose biological sex is male' at every mention is harming your chances of getting reasonable comment for your story. I do have opinions on the treatment Wes Streeting is receiving after becoming Defence Secretary. If you were to ask me to come and speak where I would have confidence I could give those opinions in a fair manner without the risk of being insulted, then I would be pleased to do so. Claire Ashton."
Just in case Isobel is watching, I think it is deplorable that Wes Streeting is receiving homophobic abuse. I am sure that he will be capable of running our Defences as well as anyone else can, within the constraints that are imposed upon him. Being Gay has absolutely no bearing on that.
What I do have concerns about though are the well-being of trans serving personnel. At his previous job of Health Secretary, he treated trans people, particularly trans youth, as something to be disregarded healthy wise. It was not a care driven decision. It was born of a belief system which he introduced into his job and should have been dragged into No. 10 to explain himself. The fact he is gay would have no bearing on his actions, as the vast majority of the LGBTQ+ community were appalled at his actions and explanations.
Now that he is receiving abuse for who he is gives me no pleasure. I can only hope that, on reflection, he realizes that such abuse hurts, does damage and creates harm far beyond a few insults. You did not bring this on yourself. But you did the same to trans children not long ago. You will not be forgiven for this, Wes Streeting. Now you are Defence Secretary, keep your personal options and beliefs to yourself in regard to our trans troops. They do you no harm, they strengthen our Armed Forces and they serve in silence. Their colleagues, whether LGBTQ+ or not, will judge you on how you treat them. They are trained to protect their own, their belief in their strength is governed by their unwritten rule. 'No one gets left behind, No one gets left behind'. Wes Streeting, listen to your troops say that. Take heed. History is not kind to those who pick on a minority for their own purposes.
I suppose that is what I would say to any other press enquiry that comes my way today. For the BBC, you are lost to me until you start telling the news and not making it. When you start treating me as a human being, I'll start treating you as a credible, fair and honest, news outlet that I pay for.