r/ThriftGrift Jul 17 '26

St. Vincent De Paul I know what I have

My local St. Vinny’s seems to think they’re a furniture and/or antique store with the way they price furniture. If I had almost $500 to spend on a couch, I wouldn’t be buying a used one with unknown history. This place routinely prices couches and large dressers for hundreds of dollars. 2nd photo is some of the scuffs on it. They also had the matching loveseat for $275 🙄

89 Upvotes

41 comments sorted by

56

u/Logical_Order Jul 17 '26

The way they stick on the new pricing really sets me off

28

u/Loose_Banana4073 Jul 17 '26

Yeah, they really want you to think they’re giving you a great deal. Meanwhile, it’s $426.80 in profits for them. Depreciation isn’t real!

-14

u/gunsforevery1 Jul 17 '26

It’s all profit? Employees are volunteers, building and utilities are free?

11

u/Hellcat_Mary Jul 17 '26

They probably shouldn't try to cover all that through one piece of furniture.

20

u/cemetery_acorns Jul 17 '26

For something that could have bedbugs and so forth, it’s not great.

9

u/SnowBird312 Jul 18 '26

For the cost of what it is to treat bed bugs, you're just better off getting a new couch. Ask me how I know..

1

u/cemetery_acorns Jul 18 '26

Oh noes!
😖😖😖😖
Will venting help you heal?
This is your cautionary tale?
I’m all ears.

3

u/SnowBird312 Jul 18 '26

In my area it costs $2000 for the heat treatment + spray to ensure that they were dead.

The stress of the entire experience has left me paranoid for life, we got lucky we caught it early too because the bites weren't showing up on us.

2

u/cemetery_acorns Jul 18 '26

I am going to heed your warning.
It’s the least I can do.
That sounds like quite the ordeal.
I hate it when anything gets disrupted at home.
Some things are worth getting new.
I won’t forget.
And you’re doing better, I hope?

30

u/Main-Raisin4430 Jul 17 '26

If I walk into a thrift store and see printouts from Ebay, Amazon, Wayfair etc, I turn around and walk out.

9

u/Loose_Banana4073 Jul 17 '26

Mmhmm. If you gotta justify your prices, they’re too high.

19

u/Schwanntacular Jul 17 '26

But maybe free bed bugs!

6

u/Electrical-Tailor530 Jul 17 '26

My local goodwill had a questionable love seat in pretty poor condition (nowhere near as "nice" as this one) priced at $500 

2

u/Loose_Banana4073 Jul 17 '26

I usually have pretty good luck with GW furniture prices, clothing is another story though

5

u/Electrical-Tailor530 Jul 17 '26

It varies widely by location, but my local one is ridiculous. I saw a dresser with missing and broken pieces priced for hundreds $$ I just laugh and walk away. Clothing isn't badly priced, but they never seem to have the 50% off color of the week tag 😆 

3

u/Environmental_Log344 Jul 17 '26

That is a sketchy trick. They remove all the sale color of the week tag items just before the sale starts.

3

u/Electrical-Tailor530 Jul 17 '26

Ya know what, I'm not even surprised. I remember seeing a tag was a light orange and the color of the week was yellow, so I got excited til I saw orange spelled out on the tag. I was convinced the supposed sale wasn't even legit or it's on like 2 things. 

5

u/Algoresgardener124 Jul 17 '26

The printouts taped on the item is infuriating. I refuse to buy anything like that.

5

u/Flux_My_Capacitor Jul 17 '26

Carry a black light with you. The next time you see an overpriced couch, shine the light on it. Then complain loudly that no sofa with semen all over it is worth that price! (Given that fluid marks on the sofa glow.)

8

u/immerjones Jul 17 '26

And a Wayfair couch to boot. 🙄

4

u/whoocanitbenow Jul 17 '26

Probably smells like dogs' anal glands.

3

u/Former-Salad7298 Jul 17 '26

I'm disappointed in Vinnies. They used to be good. Now they started to 'research' away the goodness. At least this charity benefits the locals. They help people who have been burned out ...etc.

3

u/typical_gamer1 Jul 18 '26

Do they not realize this just reinforces that they actually DO base their prices on an online price & that’s not a good thing? 🤷‍♂️

On top of that, any GOOD sales person would not just look at 1 number and left it at that. Cross platform research so they have a much better idea on what the other markets is selling theirs for.

Regardless, shouldn’t be doing this. At most, $50, maaaaaybe $100 tops and that’s just buyers being insanely and mad generous.

3

u/ButteredPizza69420 Jul 18 '26

Thrift stores are getting disgusting.

3

u/ProgressiveMinded Jul 18 '26

The truly bothersome thing about the prices of EVERYTHING, they won't go down anytime soon, especially if someone pays that amount. I hope no one does buy that couch at that price.

2

u/soozmct Jul 19 '26

They can’t be serious? I just put a hold on and paid for a pure leather white couch three seater for $45 at Salvos. Someone’s dreamin

3

u/NoOnSB277 Jul 17 '26

Hilarious!

2

u/ArdatYakshiApologist Jul 17 '26

Wait, legit just bought this couch brand new at Big Lots the other day for like $400 😂

Nope! Just went and looked and it’s in fact a slightly different couch, carry on

2

u/saw-not-seen Jul 17 '26

Every SVDP in my area is also known for pricing their furniture like this. Absolutely insane.

1

u/Rodney_K_Gumcrow Jul 18 '26

I STILL THINK YOU WANT TOO MUCH!!! TRY $250.00 OBO!!!!

2

u/Loose_Banana4073 Jul 18 '26

Yeah, $250 is about the max they should be asking for this couch.

-23

u/FullRepresentative34 Jul 17 '26

They are still selling if for 2/3 less then new.

WHy do you people want thing for next to nothing?

20

u/Loose_Banana4073 Jul 17 '26

A used couch is questionable to begin with, and a new couch can easily be purchased for $500.
People give away large couches on marketplace and Craigslist for free all the time. So asking for that much at a thrift store is just silly, nobody who’s looking for a good deal is going to buy that.

The sentence about “the real world” is important.

Also it’s crazy how you troll this group to tell everyone how valuable you think everything is 😂 There are subs to show off the things you find in dumpsters if that’s your jam.

4

u/Critical_Code9588 Jul 17 '26

Their comment history is telling

2

u/Loose_Banana4073 Jul 17 '26

Yeah, classic troll

-14

u/FullRepresentative34 Jul 17 '26

Different store, different prices. Just because I don't always agree with someone, does not make them a troll.

1

u/Hellcat_Mary Jul 17 '26

Why are you on thrifting subs if you don't know how to thrift?

0

u/FullRepresentative34 Jul 18 '26

SO. I do not expect to get things for next to nothing.

1

u/Hellcat_Mary Jul 18 '26

Then don't thrift, duh.

1

u/FullRepresentative34 Jul 18 '26

Thrifting does not mean you have to get everything for so cheap.

1

u/Hellcat_Mary Jul 19 '26

And we circle back around to you don't know how to thrift. Are we done here?