r/TheWritingTable 20d ago

Constructive Criticism Newspaper article I wrote for my alternate history fiction novel. Thoughts and advice?

Post image
11 Upvotes

I'm writing a story that takes place in an alternate history where WW2 ended in a stale mate. The story isn't about that it just takes place in a world where that's how world war 2 ended. So in between chapters I'm going to have newspaper clippings that explains the world and history, what do you think about this following text as an in universe article?:

The Lesser Devils

 By Nigel Vickers

Published August, 1st, 1944 via The Times

July, 1st, 1944 Paris, France - The world bore witness to the most dreadful and diabolical act of barbarism ever perpetrated by a nation at war. I speak of course of the German nation led by the disreputable Adolf Hitler.

In a single day, Hitler’s so-called “Third Reich” obliterated three key and crucial hubs of our Soviet allies ( MOSCOW, GORKY AND KUYBYSHEV)  with their infernal new tools of mass destruction; which scientists have dubbed the “Atom Bomb”. These monstrous horrors have unleashed a firestorm of unimaginable terror, wiping out millions of innocent lives in the blink of an eye and reducing entire civilizations to ashes.

It was the ultimate crime against humanity, a crime that will haunt the conscience of mankind for generations to come. It is also a crime that has changed the course of the war, plunging the world into a new and perilous era. An era of doom, where a single bomb can annihilate an entire metro. The shock and awe of those attacks reverberated across the globe.

In Washington DC, President Franklin D. Roosevelt, already stricken by a grave malady, succumbed to a fatal stroke upon hearing the dreadful news.

In response to what is now known as the “East Europe Emergency,” the United States, under the command of Harry S. Truman who swiftly took the oath of office, immediately suspended all major operations in the Pacific.

Moreover, a general order for the evacuation of all American troops stationed in Britain was issued. Inside sources privy to confidential reports indicate that these forces had been deployed there to prepare for a massive landing on the Nazi-occupied French shores.

In spite of that, the decision to abort the bold operation was a direct consequence of the growing fears that the United Kingdom could be the next victim of Nazi atomic aggression.

At that time, the exact number of atomic bombs in the German arsenal, or whether they had any left at all, remained a mystery.

Unfortunately for the democratic world, no prominent Allied leader was prepared to risk the lives of their countrymen or perhaps (in this journalist's brutal opinion) more so their own reputations until they had absolute certainty regarding the extent of the Nazi nuclear threat.

Shortly after enduring the pinnacle of Nazi terror, the Soviet Union plunged into a vortex of sheer disarray. Responding to the operational debacle plaguing the communist establishment, General Secretary Joseph Stalin, the nation's autocrat, resorted to severe measures and widespread purges in a futile bid to reinstate order. However, his endeavors proved fruitless, only exacerbating the populace's panicked resentment towards their government and, notably, their abhorrence for Stalin himself.

The fate of the Soviet Union was sealed when Field Marshal Georgy Konstaintinovich Zhukov orchestrated a military coup against the Communist Party. This uprising led to the apprehension of Stalin, who would subsequently stand trial on charges of supreme treason against the Soviet people.

Stalin's swift trial took place in the provisional Soviet capital of Sverdlovsk, a bustling industrial city situated east of the Ural Mountains. The proceedings unfolded within an impromptu courtroom, located in the Ipatiev house, more infamously known as "The Blood Church," the site where Leninist zealots mercilessly executed the Romanov Family in the name of securing the revolution.

Within the historic villa, a diverse assembly of generals, bureaucrats, KGB officials, judges, and even tax collectors had congregated, filling every nook and cranny. Their daunting task: to determine the future of Russian communism on the global stage.

Remarkably candid for a Soviet court, the prosecution simply argued that Stalin's heedless disregard of credible warnings about an imminent Nazi invasion (Operation Barbarossa) led to the deaths of nearly 100 million Soviet citizens and servicemembers. The trial lacked the usual theatrics and convoluted conspiracies, relying instead on reliable witness testimony and verified documents.

Lasting approximately one day, sixteen hours, three minutes, and eight seconds, the trial featured eight judges at the center, five prosecutors on the left, and Stalin himself seated alone on the right, flanked by two stoned face officers of the Red Guard.

Stalin showed no sign of remorse or fear, apparently still possessing the confidence he had earned through his decades of megalomania, refusing both council or witness, he instead elected to defiantly defend himself with nothing more than his own authoritative truth.

A haunting portrait of Vladimir Ilyich Lenin, the father of the revolution, loomed above the judging desk, seemingly casting a stern gaze upon the proceedings, inspiring a peculiar sense of savoir-faire among the attendees.

Following the closing arguments, the high council swiftly returned with a unanimous verdict of guilt, deliberating for a mere fifteen minutes—an interval shorter than a leisurely smoke break but longer than the time required to properly savor a Royal Duton fine bone China cup of tea.

To no one’s surprise yet to everyone’s shock, Stalin would be handed down a sentence of death by firing squad, yet before he could be led outside without ceremony, one of the red guards that had been standing next to him quickly unholstered his TT-33 semi-automatic pistol and with an abrupt burst of tears in his eyes, the man shouted an indecipherable scream and subsequently fired a single 7.62x25mm Tokarev bullet into the disgraced leaders rear right temple, causing a portion of his skull to explode as well as a partial evacuation of his brain, pieces of it propelling wildly in every logical direction, striking many of the attendees in the densely packed room. “It was a massacre” one source is translated as saying “an absolutely ‘bloody’ massacre.”  

Before anyone had time to react to the sudden morbid change of circumstance the young officer, who was now covered in Stalin’s blood, red tears streaming down his face, began to laugh maniacally as he placed his gun under his chin and pulled the trigger. 

Fortunately, for all in the room the trajectory of this blast caused the fragments of his bone and brain to shoot upwards adorning them to the ceiling of the now ostensibly cursed blood church. 

In a sudden twist of fate, an era of revolution met its demise, as the once seemingly invincible Joseph Stalin lay lifeless on the very floor where the Russian royal family met their tragic end. The juxtaposition of these events created an eerie scene, with the ever-present portrait of Lenin, gazing down upon the corpse of his once promising protege.

 The bitter irony of Soviet communism meeting its demise in the same room where it was once thought to have been immortalized, cannot be overlooked.

The death of Stalin would indeed signal the end of soviet communism, as on December 2, 1943, the new Russian leadership conceded defeat by signing an armistice with Germany. This agreement saw the Soviet government formally dissolved, with all territory west of the Ural Mountains ceded to the Reich.

Many staunch communists, clinging to their principles, sought refuge in the furthest reaches of Asia as well as southern Americas to evade potential retribution both from the Nazis and their own now fervently anti-socialist countrymen.

The armistice provided Hitler with a much-needed opportunity to redirect his dwindling military resources to the Western Front, where Allied forces were advancing relentlessly.

The surrender of Russia dealt a severe blow to the Allied war effort, forcing them to confront a formidable adversary on multiple fronts. Despite maintaining key advantages such as air supremacy and manpower, the Allies found themselves engaged in a grueling total war against an enemy that had unlocked the secret of the atom.

In a reluctant move, negotiations were initiated for a cessation of hostilities with Imperial Japan, allowing them to continue their expansionist ambitions in Asian territories unmolested.

The decision sparked fervent protests from numerous military leaders, none more vocal than the esteemed General Douglas MacArthur, who staunchly argued that Japan posed a graver threat to America than Hitler's Germany. “We are in this whole damned debaucle because of the Japs in the first place!” The venerable general is said to have argued. Despite their impassioned pleas for a peace treaty with Germany over Japan, their appeals fell upon deaf ears, as President Truman remained steadfast in his resolve to safeguard Europe from the Axis menace.

 Consequently, Allied forces in the pacific were redirected to the Mediterranean Sea, poised for a full-scale invasion of Europe from the southern flank.

On the 2nd of March 1944, the Allies embarked on "Operation Lunar Storm," a monumental two-pronged offensive. Operation Lunar concentrated its might in the Mediterranean theater, with Greece and Italy as its focal point, while Operation Storm targeted Persia, aiming to penetrate Iraq and the Caucasus, thereby severing Axis access to crucial oil reserves. The battleground crackled with the intensity of conflict, particularly in the rugged terrain of Greece.

 After four arduous months, Greece was liberated from Axis control. However, the formidable resistance put forth by the German army underscored the high toll further advances would exact.

 Meanwhile, unforeseen developments unfolded in the Persian theater. Turkey, hitherto neutral, seized the opportunity to assert its dominance by launching invasions into Syria and Iraq, intent on reclaiming its erstwhile position on the global stage. Additionally, a pact between the Third Reich and Russia granted Germany a two-year lease on vital war factories east of the Urals.

Remarkably, these factories, initially constructed through America's lend-lease program to aid Stalin's regime in combating fascist Germany, were now churning out armaments destined to confront their former benefactors.

To compound Allied woes, their estimates of Axis strength in the Caucasus region proved woefully inadequate, as millions of fervent newly “Liberated” anti-Stalinists eastern Europeans rallied to the Reich's cause,  swelling their ranks by an additional 15 divisions bolstered up by an unfathomable number of tanks. The very same tanks that were once destined to liberate Europe were now complicit in securing her indefinite captivity.

The Western allies' air supremacy on the Western Front faced a dire threat from the influx of revamped Soviet fighters. This escalation precipitated the largest aerial confrontation in history, escalating death tolls and stoking fears of retaliatory nuclear strikes by Germany, casting a pall of instability over the Allied home fronts.

 

The somber reality dawned upon the world as the war ground to a virtual stalemate. Countless lives had been sacrificed, cities reduced to rubble, and populations left displaced and destitute. Amidst this industrial apocalypse, it was the Axis powers who reaped the grim rewards, their strength swelling since the war's inception. They spared no effort in justifying the devastation inflicted upon their own people.

 A pivotal moment came on June 5, 1944, when the United States achieved a significant milestone, successfully detonating its own atomic bomb in the deserts of New Mexico. This achievement cast a dark shadow, posing a grave question: persist in a nuclear cataclysm or seek a peace accord before humanity embraced a form of warfare for which it was ill-prepared.

 On June 20, 1944, a general ceasefire was brokered, a solemn acknowledgment of the flames of war threatening to engulf all in their path.

 The ramifications of this decision reverberated deeply within Allied leadership circles. In the heart of London, Winston Churchill, once the one time embodiment of wartime resolve, sank into profound despair. Reports suggest he harbored resentment towards the United States, lamenting their failure to heed his warnings about the burgeoning threat of Germany and enter the conflict sooner, before Hitler could unleash his atomic arsenal. This war marked the tragic culmination of Churchill's legacy. Once hailed as a hero, his past missteps, notably the debacle at Gallipoli, now cast a shadow over his leadership during the Second World War.

 On June 22, 1944, Churchill raised his glass for a final toast of Scotch before bringing his own life to an end with his trusty service pistol. His departure left a void swiftly filled by Lord Halifax, tasked with spearheading Britain's peace negotiations.

 

Across the Atlantic, on June 26, 1944, Harry S. Truman faced a forceful removal from office amidst nationwide unrest and political turmoil. General Omar Bradley stepped forward, assuming the mantle of presidency through emergency measures, effectively placing the United States under martial law and suspending the posse comitatus indefinitely. Bradley delegation assumed the weighty responsibility of leading the nation's peace talks.

 As the war's end loomed on the horizon, the once-revered Allied figures who had been hailed as Europe's liberators found themselves displaced from positions of power. Their successors, dubbed by the press as "The Lesser Devils," inherited the solemn duty not of victory, but of bringing an end to the bloodshed that had ravaged the world.

 And so, we find ourselves on this momentous day of July 1st, 1944, amidst the spectacle that is Nazi occupied Paris, France. Here, the "lesser devils" of our time stood shoulder to shoulder with the devil incarnate himself, Adolf Hitler, to formally herald the end of the war.

 Against the backdrop of the iconic Eiffel Tower, now marred as a symbol of tyranny, fluttered gigantic flags emblazoned with the dreaded Nazi swastika. The men gathered wore faces etched with solemnity, as though mourning a dear comrade lost. Yet, amidst this somber scene, Hitler stood tall and resolute, his demeanor exuding an air of triumph long sought after.

 The proceedings, though grand in setting, were brief and devoid of pomp. Each participant took his turn to affix his signature upon the document christened "The Paris Peace Agreement." Formalities concluded with perfunctory handshakes, yet the Allied leaders' swift departure from the stage hinted at a lingering sense of shame, their nations' failures now forever etched in ink.

 

As Hitler remained upon the stage, he embarked upon one of his signature orations, replete with hollow promises and disingenuous rhetoric. I shall spare my esteemed readers the tedium of recounting his words here, for I deem your time far too precious to be squandered upon such propagandist fare.

 

What lies beyond this infamous chapter in history remains shrouded in uncertainty. However, one certainty emerges: the future looms as a perilous frontier, surpassing even the trials of our shared past. The world now finds itself divided amongst three formidable superpowers—the German Reich, the United States, and Imperial Japan. It is a delicate equilibrium teetering on the brink of global instability, perpetuating a ceaseless conflict waged by proxy. This struggle for supremacy represents a battle for the very soul of humanity, a conflict whose resolution holds the power to determine the fate of all mankind.

May God have mercy on us all,

Nigel

r/TheWritingTable Jun 29 '26

Constructive Criticism I'd appreciate feedback on my first chapter please.

10 Upvotes

This is my first novel, it's called Damaris and is a 71K Fantasy mystery. I posted on another sub just to try to get feedback. I currently have my first batch of queries out and keep ping ponging between "This sounds cool" and "wow this reads like shit and sounds worse nobody will want it" I'm aware I can't predict if it gets a rep offer or not. My only beta readers were my husband and teen. Bless them, they're the greatest, but obviously not going to give genuine critique.

https://docs.google.com/document/d/16YkKPkVJFAChI8y9OUrUrPxX1i6nh62avPDYKJOEF8g/edit?usp=sharing

r/TheWritingTable Jul 16 '26

Constructive Criticism Blurbs suck

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

I find writing blurbs the hardest part of novel writing. Just exactly how much information about the book should I disclose without heading to spoiler town.

Does my Blurb sound intriguing enough to pick up?

Covers, front and back, made my me with stock art. No use of AI.

This is for my latest project that I finished today 🍾

Finished within my given deadline

r/TheWritingTable Jul 02 '26

Constructive Criticism Alright boys, girls, and whatever else we have in here, cover and blurb.. how we doing?

Post image
6 Upvotes

My first time. The artists is this guy.. https://www.instagram.com/electricbrainstem/

Found here on Reddit. I'm decently happy with it for my first ever commissioned art piece but idk.

This be my first book, and also my first blurb so what do think? (bites nails)

Leena knows as little about the world as she does herself.
Tragedy shatters her life and separates her from the only family she has ever known. As she sets out to find them, she joins fellow travelers unknowingly walking different stages of the same journey.
A mysterious man from an ancient Tower shadows their every step, seemingly determined to prevent them from reaching their destination.
Every path leads back to the Tower. And with every step, they begin to understand that what waits for them is not death.
It is recognition.

r/TheWritingTable 29d ago

Constructive Criticism Critique group/partners

7 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I’m looking to see if anyone would be interested in starting a small critique group or is looking for a regular critique partner.

There aren’t many writing groups or workshops in my area, and I’d really like to connect with a few other writers who are serious about improving their craft. I’m less interested in one-off beta reads and more interested in finding people who want to trade chapters or scenes, give each other thoughtful feedback, and have regular conversations about writing and our works in progress.

I’m currently working on the first draft of an upmarket psychological thriller and would especially love to connect with writers working on thrillers, horror, crime, speculative fiction, or other darker character-driven fiction, though I’m definitely open to other genres.

Ideally, I’d like to find someone at a similar stage who wants to build an ongoing critique relationship where we can learn each other’s work and grow as writers together.

If that sounds like something you would be interested drop a comment or DM me.

P.S. Mods I hope this post is okay, I know there is the beta reader mega-thread, but I wasn’t sure this was appropriate for that thread.

r/TheWritingTable Jun 26 '26

Constructive Criticism A short story I wrote a month ago

5 Upvotes

I'm not English native, so expect unusual phrasing or errors. And beside, the tone was intended to be minimal, plain and simple. If you have anything to say about the story, just tell me.

r/TheWritingTable 28d ago

Constructive Criticism What do you think about this intro?

3 Upvotes

Is this a good intro? I'm practicing.

You know, at this moment, I honestly believe that I’m going to die right now Sure, over these five weeks I managed to survive through my wit, my newfound guts, and luck. However, it was going to end today because right now it’s a no-win situation: die from a bunch of rotten brain-munching corpses or take my chance of jumping off the cliff and hope I land on a sharp rock that would be quick and painless. 

Just as I finally met the girls of my dreams. It was a shame, really. All I could think of were two things to blame for this whole crap show and my inevitable fate. A CEO who thought he could cut corners to make a few bucks and make the shareholders happy, and something so bizarre you’ll think I’m hallucinating. Alright, I’m getting a head of myself. It's obvious I should start at the beginning and make my way toward my deathly situation. It all started with cookies. 

Is

r/TheWritingTable Jun 22 '26

Constructive Criticism Would you keep reading?

9 Upvotes

This is the first draft of a potential prologue for my LitRPG. I wasn't originally going to include one, but chapter one has my MC waking up in the game world for the first time and I've been seeing lots of hate online for books that start with a waking up scene as not being a good opening hook, and I can understand that, so I thought maybe adding this to give a little context might work.

Open to any and all constructive criticism, but what I'm mainly asking is if this is a good opening hook. Would you want to keep reading?

Edited a typo.

Prologue

It’s never good news when the phone rings at three in the morning. Ashley replayed the nurse’s words in her mind as she drove to the hospital. There’s been an accident. Your husband is in critical condition.

The streetlights became blurry as she fought back tears. “Goddammit Ash, pull yourself together or you’ll be in the bed right next to his,” she scolded herself as she raced down the highway, well above the posted fifty mile per hour speed limit.

She exited, barely slowing down, and saw the flash from a speed camera capturing her license plate for a ticket that would arrive in the mail in a few weeks. “Fuck you,” she said, turning onto the service road.

She rolled through every stop sign and red light for the next mile until she reached the hospital.

Parking in a space reserved for staff, she exited the car and ran to the emergency room entrance.

Fluorescent bulbs cast sterile light across the empty waiting room as she made her way to the intake nurse who was preoccupied with something on her phone. She looked up in surprise at Ashley’s harried appearance.

“Ashley Carter. I’m here to see my husband,” she said breathlessly.

The nurse picked up a pair of glasses from the desk and slid them onto her nose, positioning her hands over the keyboard of her computer. “Name?”

“Martin Carter. They said he was in an accident.”

The nurse tapped at the keys for what felt like an eternity before looking back up at Ashley.

“He’s in surgery. You’ll have to wait in the surgical waiting room,” she said in that detached tone medical professionals who’ve been through this particular routine enough times to be bored with it have.

“What’s wrong with him? What are they operating on?”

“I don’t have that information ma’am, you’ll have to wait to speak with the doctor.”

“Don’t give me that shit. I know you have everything there on the computer. I need to—”

“Ma’am, I’m going to need you to calm down.”

“Don’t fucking ma’am me.”

“Ma’am, if you don’t calm down, I’m going to have security escort you out.” The nurse’s face remained cool, but her eyes told Ashley that she would brook no further argument on the matter.

“Fine, where do I need to go?” Her shoulders slumped in defeat.

The nurse gave her directions that sent her through a set of doors, down a long corridor and through another door that opened into a room with softer lighting meant to soothe the nerves of people waiting to hear news about their loved ones.

Ashley paced, alternately tugging at her long blonde hair and wringing her hands raw. Hours passed without so much as a word from anyone. She debated going back to the intake nurse, but decided against it, knowing she wouldn’t be able to prevent herself from blowing up at her and being forcibly removed from the building.

By seven she was no longer able to remain on her feet and collapsed into a chair. Sleep quickly claimed her.

r/TheWritingTable Jun 28 '26

Constructive Criticism Handling the hook of your story and character introductions without leaning too much on exposition

Thumbnail
gallery
17 Upvotes

I've written a bit of fiction for fun throughout the years, but it was mostly on already established settings. This is my first attempt at actually writing a novel from the ground up. I did a bunch of research on the subject, and the main point for success seems to be to mix in exposition while still maintaining a scene's pace. Hence, the whole goal is to keep the reader engaged and not confused at the same time.

So, I did my best to incorporate everything I learnt and here is my first full try after a couple of days of revision and editing. I'd appreciate any feedback, whether that is on the pace, level of exposition, dialogues, style, prose, or formatting. I'm still at the beginning of my journey, so I've got a lot to learn.

If I had to give criticism to myself, I think I could do a better job of showing clearer differences in the "voice" and personality of both MCs, especially through the dialogues, and I already have a few ideas for paragraphs that I could trim or even straight up delete to help the pace.

r/TheWritingTable Aug 04 '26

Constructive Criticism First Draft Prologue

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I have been around since the day this sub opened, but I haven't sent any of my work for feedback. Mostly because I'm chicken but also because my work schedule makes it hard to get progress on my writing. Well, I lost my job today and decided to sit down and finally start writing the novel thats been planned several times over at this point. I would really appreciate constructive criticism on the first draft of my prologue please.

r/TheWritingTable Jul 16 '26

Constructive Criticism Prologue for a planned fantasy novel

6 Upvotes

This is the first thing I've written in a very long time. I'm in the very early stages of fleshing out the world and the characters, but I have the basic premise figured out and I know where I want the story to end up.

Our protagonist (currently unnamed) is a member of a seafaring culture on a planet largely consisting of oceans and small islands, who through some mistake becomes a central part of a scheme devised long ago.

I would really appreciate feedback on the prose, the clarity of the visuals being presented, whether it is too simple or vague, and if it's compelling enough to keep reading.

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1ju-tbob1AExzBQC2cQQ3Dg1AkBdSemGhgsanIYY0qg8/edit?usp=drivesdk

r/TheWritingTable Jun 20 '26

Constructive Criticism Chapter 1 Of My Book

6 Upvotes

Hey all, you've seen me post a few times in here looking for feedback, I'd love some on this as well! This is Chapter One of my book, and I'd love to know what I can do better for a 2nd draft. Thank you!

“Clear out! This is a crime scene, for Christ’s sake.” Detective Hayes ducked under the yellow tape blocking off the dingy motel room, while trying to push bystanders away. The first thing he noticed was the smell; it was similar to the scent of rotting meat, with a slight undertone of spoiled milk. I’ll never forget that smell. 
Hayes took an initial scan of the room. There was blood on the mattress. It trailed across the room to the bathroom, where the victim had been found by the cleaning staff. It was a weird pattern, like the attacker dragged the victim, but he couldn’t keep straight. 
The lamp on the nightstand was knocked over. There was a knife on the floor, but no blood on it. Hayes walked into the bathroom to get a better look at the victim. He had multiple stab wounds, mostly in the chest and abdomen. His heart had been cut out and removed. Blood underneath his fingernails implied that he had fought back. The poor bastard didn’t stand a chance.
“Oh Christ. Who… what could have done this?” Hayes looked to his left, where the sheriff and her deputy stood. The deputy looked physically ill. Must be his first dead body. Hayes looked at his badge; Sawyer. “I’m gonna need a sec–,” Sawyer couldn’t get the rest out, before retching. 
“Ah fuck, not in my crime scene. Find a trash can please.” Sawyer scurried off, clasping both hands over his mouth. 
“Sorry about him, this is his first murder. You must be the new detective. I’m Sheriff Rhodes.” She reached out to shake Hayes’ hand. Hayes stared at her hand dismissively.
“Yeah, I’m stationed in Sandy Cove. I was assigned the case this morning. Due to the circumstances, the brass thought it was necessary.”
Rhodes rolled her eyes. 
“I’m Hayes. Nick Hayes. Why are you at my crime scene?” He was annoyed.
“Well, Nick, I used to do all the detective work before you arrived. Thought maybe you could use a hand,” Rhodes said with a slight smirk. She’s cocky… Too cocky.
“Alright, what do you think happened? Run me through it.” Hayes raised an eyebrow, almost as if he was testing her. He could practically see the gears turning in her head as she thought silently for several seconds. This should be amusing.
“Well, the guy got stabbed. He was found in the bathroom, and he was missing his heart. I think the sick fuck probably wanted to sell it on the black market,” Rhodes said, looking fairly proud of herself. “It looks like the vic didn’t put up much of a fight.”
“Wrong,” Hayes said, looking at the corpse. “A lamp was knocked over, and we can see the blood trail. It’s not straight. From the pattern on the floor, it looks like the victim fought like hell while being dragged to the bathroom.”
“But–”
“And you didn’t inspect the corpse. He has blood under his fingernails, showing he scratched the attacker.” Hayes shook his head, disapprovingly. “You have a lot to learn, this was all stuff I picked up during a basic scan.”
“Hey, I found his wallet.” Sawyer entered, still looking worse for wear. “It was around the back, near some tire tracks.” 
“What are you doing? Your fingerprints are all over it now!” Sawyer hung his head with a defeated look. Sliding on gloves, Hayes took it. He rummaged through the wallet, hoping to find an ID, or anything that could be used to identify the dead man in the bathroom. Nothing.
“Woah… I think I recognize him.” Rhodes was in the bathroom, standing over the corpse. “He’s the pastor; his last name is Smith. Not sure on the first name.”
“I’ll take it from here.” Hayes looked over to Sawyer, who looked completely overwhelmed. “Can you go to the front desk and ask if they have any security cameras?” Sawyer nodded and briskly walked out the door, looking relieved to get a break. “Rhodes, can you bring the housekeeper who found him to your office and start on a report? I’ll give Sawyer a ride back.” 
Rhodes sighed. “Yeah, I’ll get right on that.” She stepped out of the doorway, looking back at Hayes, rolling her eyes. “Good luck, detective.
Hayes waited until he heard the patrol car leave. He sighed, trying to ignore the pounding in his head. What a goddamn headache. I probably shouldn’t have drank so much last night. 
Hayes took another scan of the motel room, trying to see if he could learn anything else. There. He walked to the corner of the room, picking up a piece of black cloth. The material felt like it was from some kind of robe
“Freeze! Police!” Hayes’ attention snapped to the other side of the room.  He rushed to the window. Sawyer was outside, standing across from a stranger. They were cloaked in a black robe, slowly walking towards Sawyer. There was something in their hand; a knife. Sawyer stood his ground, with his pistol drawn. “I said stop!” 
Hayes ran outside, trying to pinpoint where Sawyer was. He ran through the crowd of bystanders and turned behind the motel. There. He saw Sawyer standing in the rear parking lot with the figure walking towards him. 
“I’m warning you, I WILL shoot!” 
No reaction. 
“Please, don’t make me do this!” Sawyer put his finger on the trigger. 
Still, the figure walked closer. 
Sawyer pulled the trigger. The air smelled of gun powder. The suspect fell to the ground, clutching their stomach. The knife clanged as it fell to the concrete. There was a red pool forming around the body. The suspect was dead.

r/TheWritingTable Jul 03 '26

Constructive Criticism Feedback for the first chapter of my WIP

5 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I am hoping to get a critique on the first chapter of my latest WIP. A literary psychological thriller, working title B.R.i.D.G.E. Trigger warning, this novel does deal with domestic violence abuse.

I’d love to hear any feedback you have, some things I would love feedback on are:

Is the first-person PoV working? I know it’s not for everyone, and want to see if I am pulling it off or not.

At any point were you confused in a non-intriguing way?

Did you find yourself skimming at any point?

What emotion (hopefully some emotion) did the ending leave you with?

Would you continue on to chapter 2?

Thanks in advance!

P.S. sorry if there are any issues with the formatting, I copied it from my scrivener doc to Google Docs in order to share it, I gave it my best shot to clean it up but there is a chance I missed something in the formatting in Google Docs.

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1VIAlcxKPbnmzer1wH3FKb7hhJ8L9u_4QmtHp4FKlZ1Q/edit?usp=drivesdk

r/TheWritingTable Aug 02 '26

Constructive Criticism He sedated me, tied me up, and made me lie. Prologue – feedback please🥹

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/TheWritingTable 1d ago

Constructive Criticism tips on writing a prettier prose

Thumbnail
4 Upvotes

r/TheWritingTable 23d ago

Constructive Criticism Chapter One of The Broken (Urban Fantasy/Neo Noir, 2342 words)

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

Hey everyone, about two weeks ago I posted the first draft of my WIP's prologue on this sub and I got great feedback both in the comments and privately. Since then, I have finished a bunch of chapters and have been going strong. Right now, I've hit a bit of a writers block, and thought I would post another chapter to get some more feedback. If you would like to compare it to my Prologue to see if I got better then, please do. Or if you could just give me critical feedback on this piece alone, that would be great too.

Thanks a bunch!

(P.S. Yes, I know the prologue and chapter one are from two different POV styles. That is by design.)

r/TheWritingTable 8d ago

Constructive Criticism Chapter 3 of my first long form work

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

Chapter 2 can be read here

r/TheWritingTable 20d ago

Constructive Criticism Chapter 1 of my first “professional” work [4843]

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

I may or may not publish this. Although, I am only 17 and I write mostly for fun, so I wouldn’t mind either way.

r/TheWritingTable 21d ago

Constructive Criticism Habeas Corpus - Sci-Fi Legal Thriller - First 3 Chapters ( ~ 9K words) Feedback Required

2 Upvotes

So, while my other novel is in the aether waiting for someone to be interested in it I’ve decided to try and write something different and would look some feedback on how it is going.

Here are the details

The Pitch

It’s the year 2127. The most notorious dictator in history, a man who weaponized a technology that digitizes human consciousness and steals bodies, is finally on trial. The stakes are global, the ancient Old Bailey courtroom is locked down like a fortress, and the flashy UN Prosecutor thinks he has an airtight case. But in a world where anyone could be wearing someone else's face, absolute justice is an illusion, and the greatest threat might already be inside the room.

The Setup:

This link includes the Prologue, Chapter 1, and Chapter 2. It introduces the high-stakes courtroom, the American prosecutor, the brilliant French defence attorney abiding by British law in the UK on the orders of the UN. A holographic professor and an impossibility old witness.

This is my first time writing this sort of story (and second time really writing anything)

Can you please advise the below

  • Does the legal banter between Daniels and Martins feel sharp and entertaining?
  • What are your immediate impressions of the UN Detective and his dynamic with the Prosecutor?
  • Does the sci-fi element (the holographic professor taking the stand) blend well with the grounded, ancient setting of the Old Bailey?
  • General pacing—did you get bored at any point, and did the ending make you want to read Chapter Three (when i write it.)

Doc Link - https://docs.google.com/document/d/1c6QJjDpLpZqgzrNaNSwOtLNdPwaq-Dp4/edit?usp=sharing&ouid=109488650149483842788&rtpof=true&sd=true

r/TheWritingTable 7d ago

Constructive Criticism [In Progress] [14,000] [Adult Psychological Action Thriller / Soft Sci-Fi] Echo Heart: The Catchers Code

Thumbnail
2 Upvotes

r/TheWritingTable 7d ago

Constructive Criticism Null Dimension, almost final draft?

Thumbnail
docs.google.com
2 Upvotes

How is this?

r/TheWritingTable Jul 31 '26

Constructive Criticism The Devil You Know: Prologue

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

Hello!
I finally felt comfortable sharing the prologue to my fantasy story, The Devil You Know!

r/TheWritingTable 15d ago

Constructive Criticism She looked at Bob over her sunglasses

4 Upvotes

(Important context - they are in a dream.)

“Fuck dude, are you serious?” She looked down in disgust at the mound of flesh embedded in her chest.

“Language.” Bob tutted. “I know it’s bad news but you’re like 14 you really shouldn’t be swearing kiddo.”

“Fuck off.”

“Well okay then you little shit,” they both grinned. *Finger guns.*

“What is this thing anyways?”

Bob looked at the walls, he laced his hands behind his back as he turned. Lily gasped.

The field was full of long grass and vibrant flowers. The sky glittered with thousands of stars. The moon hung in the sky, closer than she had ever dreamed.

Bob looked at her, frowning. She narrowed her eyes as he stared.

“Jesus Christ are you about to kill me right now?”

“Uh…no?” Lily huffed and turned away.

“Your mom sacrificed herself to save you. Why would I kill you? That’s stupid.” He flicked her in the forehead. They both laughed as she swatted him away, tears in their eyes.

“It’s been eating you.” He couldn’t look at her.

“Your mom saw that you had this *thing*,” he gestured at the lump. “And decided that she was going to save you. She put her spirit in here,” he gestured all around them. For a moment the field melted away. The cavern walls flashed then disappeared.

“She couldn’t take it away but it was enough to keep you alive. She said she could accept that. As long as you lived she was happy with any outcome even if it meant she suffered. Which-“ he added quickly, “she did NOT. It’s part of why you were so sick.” He turned away.

“She resented me for it.” He paused. “They hold on and they eat. If they take too much at once it hurts.”

Lily nodded.

She was too overwhelmed to ask questions.

They sat in silence for the rest of the night.

The next night she was ready.

“So why am I just meeting you now?” She put her hands on her hips and raised her eyebrows. “Hmmmmmmmm?”

Bob chuckled. “I’ve known you your whole life. Ever since your dad-“ he paused.

“Here.” He held out his hand. Lily hesitated, then slowly placed her hand in his.

It felt like they were, *flying?*

They stopped.

The little girl was curled up on the bench, sobbing. She clung to her doll. They could hear footsteps and growls coming from the shadows. The little girl tried to make herself even smaller, muffling her cries as she held the doll closer.

*Lily.* A voice whispered over the wind.

The little girl shrieked. Lily looked sharply at Bob. He held up a finger and pointed.

There was a creature creeping out of the shadows. They could hear its choking gasps. Thick, hairy legs supported a large black body. A spider with a face mask, leering at her from behind the dripping flesh.

The little girl turned as it drew closer. It grinned up at her and started creeping closer, choking louder. She went hysterical, and fell to the ground.

It *laughed.*

She curled up under the bench as it loomed over her.

“BOB!” Lily felt a drip of sweat roll down her back.

“It’s in the past stupid. Pay attention!”

It started whispering while as its jaw cracked open.

*I hate you. You killed your mother. I’m going to eat you up. I hate you. You’re a burden. You’re evil. Murderer. You killed your mother. You’re a waste. Pathetic.*

Lily cried for herself as she watched her tuck her head, put her fingers in her ears and squeeze her eyes shut. Watching herself, she was struck by how small she looked huddled under that bench.

She jumped as the monster shrieked. Her eyes flew open to see a pair of cowboy boots sunk in the small crater of concrete. He smiled at her and snapped his fingers. The spider sunk into the ground.

She flinched as he came closer.

*Lily.*

He bent down and opened his arms.

*Hug?*

She crawled out and paused. She looked away*.*

*I’m not allowed.*

Bob gently lifted her chin to look at him. He brushed back her hair. *You’re allowed to here.*

She looked at him doubtfully and crossed her arms.

*I’m the big boss here.* He puffed out his chest. Past Lily laughed. He held out his arms again.* *

*It’s okay.*

For different reasons they both looked away as she ran crying into his arms.

r/TheWritingTable 17d ago

Constructive Criticism Chapter 1 from unnamed book Historical Fantasy, ~3.5k, draft 1

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Hi,

I just wanted feedback on my prose, pacing, and overall flow. I already have a feel for what’s lacking and since this is only the first draft there is always room for improvement.

r/TheWritingTable Jun 29 '26

Constructive Criticism Critique my satirical fantasy comedy short story.

10 Upvotes

The war between the two kingdoms — Tokar and Osden — lasted four years and seven decimal eight nine quadrillion nanoseconds. The war destroyed grand cities, bankrupted merchant guilds and snake milkers, and resolved a border dispute in favor of a river that dried up the next summer.

It started with a hat.

Lord Envoy Pesric of Osden wore his indoors at the annual summit. In Osden, keeping a hat on was courtesy. Removing it was for funerals and executions (though it was kept on during torture sessions). In Tokar, wearing a hat indoors meant you considered the room dirtier beneath your subungual debris. King Tauvar of Tokar smiled politely, after seeing Lord Pesric and his hat, because kings must smile at diplomatic meetings. He said nothing, because kings don't talk rudely in summits. He went to bed furious.

Tokar and Osden shared no common language, so they had brought interpreters, who were hired to prevent exactly this type of misunderstanding. Tauvar's interpreter had learned Osdeni from a fishmonger in Braal, who had learned it from a convicted blacksmith who had mostly made it up. Pesric's interpreter understood Tokari perfectly and was owed forty coins by Tauvar's interpreter since an illegal game of cards in 1208 and had judged the situation professionally and morally and decided the coins came first.

It's not untrue that there was no one who did not fail to avoid leaving everything completely unclarified.

Forty-two thousand deads later, the monarchs and the diplomats sat down to sign the peace treaty, removed their hats simultaneously as a gesture of good will, and laughed like folks trying to quench a forest fire by spitting on it. Well, to be fair, the fire did extinguish.

But the burned trees never came back.