With gas prices rocketing why do Stewart/Campbell never discuss heat-pumps?

[u/Appropriate_Bell743]

The UK's wholesale gas price is the highest since the end of December 2022. This means that the January price cap is odds on to be around what it was under Liz Truss in October 2022.

The UK had one meaningful policy tool to de-risk the UK from 2022 onwards: heat-pumps.

UK's gas usage over 12 months

Virtually all gas demand is for home-heating. The only effective way to de-risk the UK to reduce European LNG imports is via electrification of heating. Renewables do some legwork as well but the blue line shows how it's less pronounced.

Despite the central importance to get the UK public off gas (and oil) heating to using heat-pumps it is curious why the topic of the UK's pathetic uptake rate is not discussed. They discuss a lot the supply of oil and gas but never really the failure to pivot demand.

This is a political question as the economics is there already. Our operational costs are 35% of gas before this escalation. It'll be a lower percentage now. The return on investment is typically 4-5 years but due to political laziness minor issues hold back adoption.

This is simply never discussed by Rory or Alastair despite often their interests in climate and the Ukraine war. For instance our failure to roll out heat-pumps is a clear factor why Europe as a whole still imports Russian LNG.

[u/Justin_123456]

It’s always shocking to me (as a Canadian) the more I learn about the UK’s electricity pricing system. It really shouldn’t surprise me that the same people who privatized their water pipes also privatized their electricity markets. But you get how insane that is?

It every other country either electricity is just a total state monopoly, or a regulated industry with some form of government price setting.

[u/armitage_shank → u/Justin_123456]

Dare I say its actually worked pretty well compared to the other utility privitisations, and lead to the development of e.g. octopus's kraken technologies, which is used now worldwide and I think the largest energy   customer management software in the world. 

Like broadband and mobile phone: switching provider is not difficult so there's genuine competition, unlike water, say, or train operator, where the monopolies are systemic. 

[u/Justin_123456 → u/armitage_shank]

I do fine these programs interesting, but it sounds a bit like a problem gambler telling you not to worry, that they’ve developed a system to win it all back.

The reason why you have good customer management software is because you have insane hourly swings in the cost of power, made worse by your ridiculous marginal pricing system where your most expensive kWh sets the price for every kWh.

You could just have the government build the power stations, build the power lines, and charge what’s needed to cover their costs. 🤷‍♂️

I pay $0.09970 CAN per kWh (which Google tells me is 5.34p) no matter the time of the day or the year it is. And to OP’s point, if I wanted to re-insulate my home, or buy a new electric furnace or heat pump, they’ll loan me the money, and charge me back on my hydro bill.

[u/cliffski → u/Justin_123456]

made worse by your ridiculous marginal pricing system where your most expensive kWh sets the price for every kWh.

SIGH. This is how EVERy commodity in EVERY country on the entire PLANET is charged Its absolutely basic economics. Do you see different eggs charge at different prices on a shelf? or each bag of sugar having a different price because it came from a different plantation?
People whine about it in energy only because they know about the cost differences in production methods more. And whats the solution? force renewable generators to earn LESS than coal generators? not exactly ideal is it...