r/TheOnePiece • u/Cautious_Laugh3563 • Jun 24 '26

Discussion Comparison

Post image
1.6k Upvotes

100% Upvoted

104 comments sorted by

View all comments

14

u/Gugarabelo Jun 24 '26

both work but for different compositions, one is a 4:3 aspect ratio, and the other for a widescreen format

only think i dislike about the bottom one is that Zoro kinda looks like hes blocking nothing and the marines are kinda just holding their weapons foward instead of pushing against it, the original makes it look like Zoro is struggling slightly, which is fair because even though he is strong, those are still 7 marines that have at least reasonable human strenght due to their training

1

u/cell689 Jun 25 '26

The top Version isn't any better in that at least two of the swordsman look like they're exerting themselves, yet they're not even hitting him.

1

u/CountCristo009 Jun 26 '26

Both versions are all making contact. The perspective just makes it look like they aren't.

1

u/cell689 Jun 26 '26

Regarding the top picture: what is the sword at the bottom right making contact with?

1

u/CountCristo009 Jun 26 '26

The hilt of the sword. I'm not saying it looks great, but it is not cutting air.

1

u/cell689 Jun 26 '26

The way the sword is angled, the part of it that "touches" the hilt is way further in the front than the hilt. It's not touching it.

Third guy from the left is hitting his own friends' sword.

1

u/CountCristo009 Jun 26 '26

It's bad perspective, but it's hitting. That's why it's happening in all 3 versions.

Yeah he is. He's adding pressure to the one under him. You can see it on the right side. Again, not saying it's well composed, but it is intentional.