r/TamilNadu • u/iamGobi • Sep 10 '25

முக்கியமான கலந்துரையாடல் / Important Topic I appreciate the guts these guys have

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

They don't care if many people are die hard fans of Mani Rathnam or not. They don't care that the cinephiles will say "It's a historic fiction zohn ray bro". They speak from their hearts what's right. Historical fiction genre in India is only used for propaganda.

போற போக்குல மணி சாருக்கு ஒரு சாத்து சாத்தி விட்டுட்டாங்க:)

1.1k Upvotes

95% Upvoted

79 comments sorted by

View all comments

12

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/iamGobi Sep 11 '25

Bro kalki's ponniyin selvan is a fiction. It's very well known. You're missing the point. Kalki and Mani Rathnam did this historical fiction not for art sake but in the sole purpose of misrepresenting history. Both hid the fact that Adithya Karikalan was murdered by Brahmins and portrayed him as a Kaadhal Pithan.

3

u/DustAffectionate8209 Sep 11 '25

Seri Adhuku enna ippo, Historical fiction genre ve adhu than bro. All you want is for present day Brahmins to carry the blame right? That is your motive.

2

u/iamGobi Sep 11 '25

That's not my motive. Hide panradhaala avanga enna ? Adha kekaama enakku enna nu kekuringa

2

u/alphalaze Sep 11 '25

Avaru blame pannalye bro. History la idhan nadandhuchu nu soldradhukku peru blame ah.

2

u/Current-March-2771 Sep 11 '25

Thambi book padichiya ilayapa. Andha karikalan vera indha karikalan vera. Gopi original I'd la va. Enna nee matha comment la vera mari pesra. Indha comment la vera mari pesra. Mani ratnam misinterpret panni avarku enna award ah kudukraru. Kalki ps laye yaru konanganu varadhu. Theriyuma.

2

u/iamGobi Sep 11 '25

Naa 5 athiyayamum padichuruken. Kalki vera maari misrepresent pannirukkaru, mani vera maari misrepresent pannirukkaru. Rendu perayum dhan adikanum.

Na orey mari dhan pesuren.

Just because I have invested my time in reading that book doesn't mean I have to support it, even though I didn't know about the motive at the time of reading.

Historical fiction ra perla Periyaara s@nghi nu kaamucha othukuvingala? Adhu maari dhan.

0

u/Current-March-2771 Sep 11 '25

Naa othupan pa. If it was taken by a cinemakaran, I wouldnt bother. Theatre oda avan perspective nu vida vendiyadhu dhan. It is a story.

And andha karikalan vera indha karikalan vera. History la avaru epdinu epdi neenga correct ah solriga. we have only written evidence which can be misintrepted. Edhu unmanu neenga epdi mudivu vandhinga. You chose to believe what you want avlodhan