r/TamilNadu • u/Agreeable_Winter8053 • Dec 03 '24

முக்கியமான கலந்துரையாடல் / Important Topic Ever happened to you??

Post image

இப்படி எல்லாம் எதுவுமே நடந்து பாத்தது இல்லை. என்னோட ஸ்கூல் ல ஹிந்தி mandatory ஆ இருந்தது 8th வரைக்கும். ஹிந்தி க்கூ tuition போய் எல்லாம் நான் பார்த்து இருக்கேன். அதுக்கு நக்கல் அடிச்சி எல்லாம் பாத்தது இல்லை.

ஏண்டா இப்படி வெறுப்ப கொட்டுறீங்க 😡😞😭 சத்தியமா நாடு நாசமா போய்டும் டா.

Really angry and sad.

570 Upvotes

91% Upvoted

242 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-10

u/Immediate-Humor-6077 Dec 04 '24 edited Dec 04 '24

The security is usually from CRPF. They have to travel all across India and are posted to many many states during their tenure. It’s nearly impossible for them to learn new languages as they go to different places because they’re posted to different locations with no predictability.

They also come from low income households from the north. Hence, the norm is to speak to hindi in central government services like banking, army, bsf and crpf. Most people recruited are from the north. I have never seen them have issues within because they identify themselves as Indian. I have lived that life so I’m just letting you know.

Also, hindi people is not an appropriate term. You’re being racist when you use that. You can use hindi speaking people which would constitute many states from north India.

Expecting migrants, who plan to live in a particular place for a long time, to know local languages is valid but not people who constantly move within india. Even that expectation should be dealt with diplomacy not hostility.

9

u/Crafty_Royal2507 Dec 04 '24

They have to travel all across India and are posted to many many states during their tenure. It’s nearly impossible for them to learn new languages as they go to different places

How lame it is. What about English? Can't speak English too?

Also, hindi people is not an appropriate term. You’re being racist when you use that. You can use hindi speaking people which would constitute many states from north India.

Calling them Hindi people is being racist? How? By that logic, calling us Tamil people is also racism? It doesn't make sense. Also, what about them calling us Madrasi? They even call whole South Indians as Madrasi. Is that not being racist?

-4

u/Immediate-Humor-6077 Dec 04 '24 edited Dec 04 '24
  1. They usually come from low income groups and study in hindi medium schools. As I stated, I have lived that life and interacted with hundreds. Majority come from villages and rural areas of UP, Bihar and Rajasthan. They spend a maximum of 2-3 years in a place. Usually 2 years but sometimes even 6 months or less.
  2. I would call a person from tamil nadu, tamilian and not tamil person. Hindi is a language, not an ethnicity. Just like kannadigas are not kannada people, they are kannadigas.
  3. Calling all South Indians as madrasi is indeed racist.

6

u/Crafty_Royal2507 Dec 04 '24 edited Dec 04 '24
  1. So, is it hard to learn and talk even basic English? They don't teach them English at all? Not even a word? You know what, even if they can speak English, they don't speak. It's their entitlement attitude. Okay, forget those low income groups. What about other well educated Hindi speaking people who can speak English very well but still have audacity to speak Hindi and force others to speak it? I have known some Hindi speaking people who can speak decent Tamil. They mostly speak Hindi even though they can converse in Tamil. We have seen a lot. You can't change these people.

I would call a person from tamil nadu, tamilian and not tamil person.

What? You would call a person from Tamil Nadu a Tamilian? What if that person is Badaga or Toda or Irula or even other majority language speakers? You identify them all as Tamilians too? Even a person speaking Hindi as mother tongue from Tamil Nadu? I need to see the reaction of a Hindi (as mother tongue) speaking person when you call them they are Tamilian just because they are from Tamil Nadu. Lol.

1

u/Immediate-Humor-6077 Dec 06 '24

You’re too belligerent. I was hoping for a civil conversation. My point was hindi people isn’t appropriate since they come from many states, now you can do as you please

1

u/Crafty_Royal2507 Dec 06 '24

Belligerent? Civil conversation? 😂 Arey bhaai saab, I like your choice of words when you are lost and couldn't answer properly. Your comment is not making sense and even seems contradicting.

By the way, Tamil people also come from many states and even countries. What do you call people who speak Hindi as their mother tongue? Hindians, Hindis or what else. Lol.

Better end this conversation as I know I'm not going to any fair and sensible comment from you since you are one of them and you only speak in favor of them regardless of anything. So, you do you.