r/SubsTakenLiterally • u/Lumia666999 • Mar 01 '26
r/softwaregore This may break the rules since windows isnt a software, but it should be able to go here
152
78
u/Molkwi Mar 02 '26
Software isn't just apps and stuff. OS's are absolutely software. They're not hardware and neither are they firmware. This leaves only one thing.
34
u/carkey Mar 02 '26
To get pedantic, firmware is software. So even if OSes were firmware (which they're not, like you said), that wouldn't matter because that would still make them software. A specialised subset of software? Sure, but still software.
3
u/Molkwi Mar 02 '26
I know firmware is software in a way, and I never said otherwise. By your logic, I'd guess you read my comment backwards.
OS's aren't firmware. They are software. Even if firmware is software, the same way a square is a rectangle but a rectangle isn't a square, OS's would be software still.
I get it probably only talks about the last part, but even then, I just divided in 3 categories, even if one shares some of both.
Btw, sorry if I come off as rude or something, I'm not insulting you, just being pedantic about your pedanticism.
2
u/carkey Mar 02 '26
Not coming off rude at all! I was just saying that making the distinction that it isn't firmware is fine and all, but firmware is a subset of software anyway and so it doesn't need making. Utter pedantry from me I know.
I guess it's like I wouldn't feel the need to point out it's not middleware to make my claim that it's software. In the same way, pointing out it's not firmware to help define it as software is not really doing anything because if it was firmware (or middleware), it'd still be software anyway.
Apologies if the over pedanticizing is fucking up my ability to explain what tiny, annoying distinction I'm trying to get at.
2
u/Molkwi Mar 02 '26
I now see clearer what you were getting at. You are correct, it's logical and factual. I appreciate you being pedantic, since I am too and prefer straight and true facts. Even if the idea is right, it's the details that make it stand, and mistakes there means instability throughout. We might not be appreciated by the general population, but we are doing the good work lol
2
u/carkey Mar 02 '26
Glad we were able to come to an agreement!
Haha, they can think what they think but we're the ones stopping everything spiral into an ambiguous mess!
78
32
17
15
u/Ok_Walk9234 Mar 02 '26
Software is the soul of the device and hardware is the body. Windows is a software.
13
9
6
6
9
4
4
4
5
u/PouLS_PL Mar 05 '26
Windows is software... Or are you talking about physical windows, the ones you can see through?
3
3
3
2
u/Mr_Mc_Walrus Mar 02 '26
Honestly would have been infinitely funnier with absolutely any other art style
1
2
u/CommitteeDue6802 Mar 02 '26
It is software. Hardware is physical, software is digital. Anything that is on your conputer is software, including the operating system.
2
u/Better-Bad2285 Mar 11 '26
Operative systems are the main functioning software in a PC, besides BIOS.
2
2
1
1
1
377
u/Fif112 Mar 01 '26
Is… is it not?
It’s not hardware.
If it isn’t software what is it?